Pelachs rating

[stokesupporter]

6 from me (considering it was his first game in charge).

First half good.. but you don't defend 1-0 lead for 50 minutes in Champo, like he said in his interview. You just try to score another. Very naive approach, we are not Spain, we leaked and will leak goals with our defence. But 6 for the first half.

[wonderwall]

Been here 48hrs so no rating.

I just hope he understands how truly wank we are and how much he has to fix.

[figo85]

Not really much on for him, but man alive, he’s a job on.

[cheekymatt71]

1 because the starting line up was sensible

But putting Tezgel on the right wing. We practically deserved to lose based on that decision alone

[greystokie]

I don't think that had anything to do with the new manager. He hasn't had any time to get to know the players. It's more than likely that Walters picked the side. But the real problem was the players themselves.

[PotteringThrough]

If Schumacher was in charge for that performance I’d give it a 3 tops.

Too late to respond to Junior being hammered by Millar. Wanted us to carry on passing from the back when they switched the formation and allowed their press to get on top of us. Subs were too late and I’m not convinced they were the right ones.

But I’m not going to give him a rating because he’s only been here a few days.

[maninasuitcase]

First game in and seems to have suffered from an alex neil moment regarding the subs.

Didn't feel like he picked that team to be fair and I hope he never picks that back 4 again.

[bjarnig]

Probably a 5 as he's new.

Worryingly started Manhoef out of position.
Left Cannon on far too long.
Tezgel on the right.
Didn't change formation when behind.

It doesn't help when he simply doesn't have a decent squad and a league 2 defence.

[willieeetmiout]

Anyone who thinks Jordan Thompson should start gets a 0 from me

[xchpotter]

Didn’t react to sort out our right hand side when it was obvious where the threats were coming. Hopefully a one off.

[premieraj]

Why can’t people see it’s not the managers it’s the players they have assembled they are very simply not good enough not there fault they are just not good enough!

[ethers26]

Sept 20, 2024 21:14:01 GMT willieeetmiout said:

Anyone who thinks Jordan Thompson should start gets a 0 from me

It absolutely baffles me that people slate any player who plays alongside Burger, and yet continues to overlook the fact that Burger is absolutely shite

[questionable]

Data Driven clueless appointment.

Zero

[bloodtypered]

Bin......need a few games first

[thepottypotter]

0

Worst performance of the season

[citynickscfc]

Needs a rating, very poor right

2

[steewee]

It was a utter shite pointless waste of time, turgid boring crap.

[stokesupporter]

Sept 20, 2024 21:14:09 GMT premieraj said:

Why can’t people see it’s not the managers it’s the players they have assembled they are very simply not good enough not there fault they are just not good enough!

Worryingly the two Johns didn't understand this.

Hopefully it gets better though, I'm not dismissing Pelach just yet. But the first signs aren't very good.

[dwr17477]

5. Hope that team wasn't his pick. He needs a bit of grace but Tezgel on the right? Needed to make defensive changes sooner - we could all see how bad we were on the right.

[chad]

Silly to even consider giving a mark But he sure has to improve things quickly

[stokiekm]

I can't rate him after 2 days. He'll know more about the character and ability after that

[Bang Bang Cauliflower]

Too soon to rate him but very worrying subs. Taking Koumas off and leaving Cannon on was odd.
Defence aren’t good enough to play out from the back as a rule.
Coaching staff too animated. Calm the f*ck down.
Doesn’t bode well.

[premieraj]

Sept 20, 2024 21:19:31 GMT stokesupporter said:

Sept 20, 2024 21:14:09 GMT premieraj said:

Why can’t people see it’s not the managers it’s the players they have assembled they are very simply not good enough not there fault they are just not good enough!

Worryingly the two Johns didn't understand this.

Hopefully it gets better though, I'm not dismissing Pelach just yet. But the first signs aren't very good.

It’s not him or Shoey those players are just as I say simply not good enough. Why can’t people see that we are where we are not because of managers it’s the players we have assembled.

[Billy the kid]

0 we lost to a team that have scored 2 all season before tonight, they helped themselves to 3 in 45 mins. Fuck off.

[Chewbacca the Wookie]

I don’t think he can be judged after 1 or 2 training sessions. He needs a good month to get them playing his way.

I’m sure that if things continue this way that Schumacher will have been the greatest ever manager.

1 word “Oxford.”

Nothing against SS but I could have seen a similar outcome with him in charge.

[citynickscfc]

Sept 20, 2024 21:20:55 GMT stokiekm said:

I can't rate him after 2 days. He'll know more about the character and ability after that

Well tactically today said quite a lot

Were the players up for the fight?

Did he do anything to manage the game?

Yes it's his first game but that was probably as bad as it gets

[jay1610]

Not fair to rate at this stage.

But I am pretty concerned to see us outmaneuvered by, and unable to offer any answer to, the opposition’s tactical change again.

I’m hoping that changes soon as it’s a shared trait of our last few managers.

[wagsastokie]

I’d like to think it can only get better

[willieeetmiout]

Sept 20, 2024 21:16:45 GMT ethers26 said:

Sept 20, 2024 21:14:01 GMT willieeetmiout said:

Anyone who thinks Jordan Thompson should start gets a 0 from me

It absolutely baffles me that people slate any player who plays alongside Burger, and yet continues to overlook the fact that Burger is absolutely shite

This is Thompsons 5th season? He's been wank for all 5.

Nothing to do with Burger

[Billy the kid]

Shumacher wouldn't have lost that game.