What XI would you like to see...

[scfcwebby]

When everyone is 100% fit and available?

For me

Bonham (until Jan hopefully get Travers back)

Junior
McNally
Rose
Gooch

Burger
Pearson

Junho

Campbell
Wesley
Haksabanovic

Would love to bring Travers back and get Brereton-Diaz in January along with a strong, quick centre back, like Tuanzebe of he was for all of the time

[cvillestokie]

Dec 23, 2023 17:27:00 GMT scfcwebby said:

When everyone is 100% fit and available?

For me

Bonham (until Jan hopefully get Travers back)

Junior
McNally
Rose
Gooch

Burger
Pearson

Junho

Campbell
Wesley
Haksabanovic

Thompson for Gooch and Baker for Pearson. I’d be happy with the rest though.

[jesusmcmuffin]

Dec 23, 2023 17:27:00 GMT scfcwebby said:

When everyone is 100% fit and available?

For me

Bonham (until Jan hopefully get Travers back)

Junior
McNally
Rose
Gooch

Burger
Pearson

Junho

Campbell
Wesley
Haksabanovic

Prefer Thompson to Pearson to be honest. Not that he's great, he doesn't concede pointless free kicks and slow what few moves we create down.

[xchpotter]

The end of Mmaee, Hoever and despite doing a bit better recently Laurent.

[bridgnorthstokie]

Cheesy chips for a quid and a free wagon wheel for pudding.

[thepottypotter]

I would like to see Lowe get more games

[rickyfullerbeer]

I'd like to see us score...5 goals scored in our last 9 games and not a single win in that time.

At this point, Junior, McNally and Burger are the only three who I'd want in the team. The rest are either meh or total dross.

[mrnovember]

A win or two.

[thehartshillbadger]

A footballing identity would be lovely. I’d take Pulisball over this shite anyday

[jesusmcmuffin]

As the commentary rightly said, Mmaee isn't a back to goal player but forced to play like that because we simply have no creativity.

[napperwainwright]

Manchester United and Port Vale to go bump and me to win the Euro Millions.

[WorkingclassHero]

Bonham

Tchamedan Burger McNally
Gooch Thompson
Pearson

Bae Baker


Campbell Mmae

[spirered]

Bonham

Gooch Junior McNally Stevens

Burger Pearson

Lauren

Campbell Vidigal

Maee

[jimigoodwinsbeard]

Dec 24, 2023 12:23:23 GMT spirered said:

Bonham

Gooch Junior McNally Stevens

Burger Pearson

Lauren

Campbell Vidigal

Maee

Bae has to start. Vidigal and Mmaee need dropping.

[Veritas]

Dec 24, 2023 12:14:51 GMT WorkingclassHero said:

Bonham

Tchamedan Burger McNally
Gooch Thompson
Pearson

Bae Baker


Campbell Mmae

Tchamedan as a centre back! Based on what evidence?

Campbell & Mmaee as the front two for a manager who expects a high energy game! I doubt it.

[baconburger]

Bonham*

Junior
McNally
Wilmot
Stevens*

Burger
Laurent

Campbell
Bae
Vidigal

Lowe*

*players I really don't want to be picking but see no better alternatives and even then I'm picking players who aren't fit but everyone else is so thought I'd play along.

[mickstupp]

Dec 24, 2023 12:14:51 GMT WorkingclassHero said:

Bonham

Tchamedan Burger McNally
Gooch Thompson
Pearson

Bae Baker


Campbell Mmae

What’s this mess?

[potterpaul]

Are people picking Campbell due to their confidence he can change things positively or just because we're running out of options and they don't know who else to name?

[GeneralFaye]

Dec 24, 2023 12:54:07 GMT potterpaul said:

Are people picking Campbell due to their confidence he can change things positively or just because we're running out of options and they don't know who else to name?

He has more about him than any of the other chancers. It's up to the manager to get it out of him consistently.

[cvillestokie]

Bonham

Junior
McNally
Rose
Thompson

Burger
Baker

Campbell
Bae
Haks/Vidigal

Wesley


Or, alternatively:

Bonham

Junior
Rose
Clark
McNally
Gooch

Burger
Baker

Bae (or maybe Mmaee?)

Campbell
Wesley

[headsgoup]

Honestly:

Bonham

Clark
McNally
Rose

Junior
Burger
Pearson
Thompson

Junho
Baker

Mmaee

I think the squad is too poor to go toe-to-toe with most of the division right now, so a variation of Pulisball where we keep it tight and counter-attack would serve us best for now in my opinion.

Only McNally, Burger, Junho and Junior would be in a team with playoff aspirations.

What a mess.

[Fred Merger]

New keeper

Tchamadeu
McNally
New CB
Gooch

Pearson
Burger

Haksabanovic
Baker
Vidigal

Mmaee /New CF

[spirered]

Dec 24, 2023 12:42:46 GMT Veritas said:

Dec 24, 2023 12:14:51 GMT WorkingclassHero said:

Bonham

Tchamedan Burger McNally
Gooch Thompson
Pearson

Bae Baker


Campbell Mmae

Tchamedan as a centre back! Based on what evidence?

Campbell & Mmaee as the front two for a manager who expects a high energy game! I doubt it.

Based on the future...he's the only player (exc Burger) that has the potential to play at a higher level.

I'd start grooming him now for a centre half role, with the intention of selling him for £20m + in a couple of years time..

If we are discussing playing players based on evidence, then that's a flimsy argument. The whole team is evidentually crap.

[spirered]

Dec 24, 2023 12:54:07 GMT potterpaul said:

Are people picking Campbell due to their confidence he can change things positively or just because we're running out of options and they don't know who else to name?

I think it's based on the fact that he's scored more goals (probably) than the rest of them put together...he has the potential to create or score the odd goal. On that basis he needs to be in any starting 11 (it just shows how shit we are up front)

[Laughing Gravy]

I always find it hilarious when we get one of these threads.
We regularly moan our bags off at the team the manager picks but then when we're given the opportunity to display our tactical nouse some of the selections look like they're LSD inspired.

[baconburger]

Dec 24, 2023 12:54:07 GMT potterpaul said:

Are people picking Campbell due to their confidence he can change things positively or just because we're running out of options and they don't know who else to name?

Perhaps just because they can see where else goals might come from, from within the current squad.

[potterpaul]

Dec 24, 2023 12:55:23 GMT GeneralFaye said:

Dec 24, 2023 12:54:07 GMT potterpaul said:

Are people picking Campbell due to their confidence he can change things positively or just because we're running out of options and they don't know who else to name?

He has more about him than any of the other chancers. It's up to the manager to get it out of him consistently.

I know we've had 5 really poor managers in Campbell's time but none of have achieved the last word in your reply.

I'd probably name him my team if I'm honest but I'd expect to be dropping him after 2 games Max.

[cvillestokie]

Dec 24, 2023 13:11:49 GMT spirered said:

Dec 24, 2023 12:42:46 GMT Veritas said:

Tchamedan as a centre back! Based on what evidence?

Campbell & Mmaee as the front two for a manager who expects a high energy game! I doubt it.

Based on the future...he's the only player (exc Burger) that has the potential to play at a higher level.

I'd start grooming him now for a centre half role, with the intention of selling him for £20m + in a couple of years time..

If we are discussing playing players based on evidence, then that's a flimsy argument. The whole team is evidentually crap.

But he’s best at going forwards. Why would you take that away and try to make him a central defender, a position where you don’t really attack?

[bayernoatcake]

Bonham

Junior McNally Rose Gooch

Pearson Burger

Campbell Bae Vidigal

Mmaee

Bar Bonham and Rose I really like the look of that team and it should easily be mid table. Gooch shouldn’t be a regular either.

[spirered]

Dec 24, 2023 13:17:18 GMT Laughing Gravy said:

I always find it hilarious when we get one of these threads.
We regularly moan our bags off at the team the manager picks but then when we're given the opportunity to display our tactical nouse some of the selections look like they're LSD inspired.

Well successive managers haven't proven to be any better...they can't all be on drugs 😂