|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Nov 8, 2022 22:01:58 GMT
Bonham 5, doesn't fill me with confidence. We certainly need a new man between the sticks in January!
Clarke 6, very willing going forward.
Wilmot 5, despite doing a lot of good stuff he always seems to make a mistake or two.
Souttar 7, a bit rusty, but still dominant in the air.
Fox 8, MOM for me tonight.
Baker 6, a decent game, but lost the ball in the middle of the park again in the first half which could have given Luton a big chance.
Smallbone 8, a very good game from him.
Powell 7, started ever so well, but faded a bit as the game went on.
Gayle 6, worked hard and had some good touches.
Fosu 6, very up and down tonight.
Delap 6, tried hard, but many of his decisions when on the ball is annoying.
Brown 5, not much time to show much.
Tymon not on long enough.
|
|
|
|
Post by boskampsflaps on Nov 8, 2022 22:08:42 GMT
Bonham 5, doesn't fill me with confidence. We certainly need a new man between the sticks in January! Clarke 6, very willing going forward. Wilmot 5, despite doing a lot of good stuff he always seems to make a mistake or two. Souttar 7, a bit rusty, but still dominant in the air. Fox 8, MOM for me tonight. Baker 6, a decent game, but lost the ball in the middle of the park again in the first half which could have given Luton a big chance. Smallbone 8, a very good game from him. Powell 7, started ever so well, but faded a bit as the game went on. Gayle 6, worked hard and had some good touches. Fosu 6, very up and down tonight. Delap 6, tried hard, but many of his decisions when on the ball is annoying. Brown 5, not much time to show much. Tymon not on long enough. I think you're being a little kind to Baker but other than that I think that's spot on. |
|
|
|
Post by wakeypotter on Nov 8, 2022 22:11:54 GMT
Bonham 5, doesn't fill me with confidence. We certainly need a new man between the sticks in January! Clarke 6, very willing going forward. Wilmot 5, despite doing a lot of good stuff he always seems to make a mistake or two. Souttar 7, a bit rusty, but still dominant in the air. Fox 8, MOM for me tonight. Baker 6, a decent game, but lost the ball in the middle of the park again in the first half which could have given Luton a big chance. Smallbone 8, a very good game from him. Powell 7, started ever so well, but faded a bit as the game went on. Gayle 6, worked hard and had some good touches. Fosu 6, very up and down tonight. Delap 6, tried hard, but many of his decisions when on the ball is annoying. Brown 5, not much time to show much. Tymon not on long enough. I think you're being a little kind to Baker but other than that I think that's spot on. Yeh baker was worst on pitch for me. Going off this guy |
|
|
|
Post by middleoftheboothen on Nov 8, 2022 22:12:00 GMT
Bonham 5, doesn't fill me with confidence. We certainly need a new man between the sticks in January! Clarke 6, very willing going forward. Wilmot 5, despite doing a lot of good stuff he always seems to make a mistake or two. Souttar 7, a bit rusty, but still dominant in the air. Fox 8, MOM for me tonight. Baker 6, a decent game, but lost the ball in the middle of the park again in the first half which could have given Luton a big chance. Smallbone 8, a very good game from him. Powell 7, started ever so well, but faded a bit as the game went on. Gayle 6, worked hard and had some good touches. Fosu 6, very up and down tonight. Delap 6, tried hard, but many of his decisions when on the ball is annoying. Brown 5, not much time to show much. Tymon not on long enough. Very fair markings there, I would give Powell and Souttar an eight though and thought Powell just edged mom. Can't argue with most of that though 👍 |
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Nov 8, 2022 22:13:19 GMT
Bonham 6 - sloppy kicking and one dire fumble but he was ok I guess.
Clarke 6 - was ok
Wilmot 6 - was ok
Souttar 7 - was good
Fox 7 - was good bar that fucking free kick, stupid boy. I do wonder what our players see sometimes
Fosu 5 - needed to use the ball better
Smallbone 6 - lots of hard work
Baker 5 - lots of hard work but shit set pieces
Powell 7.5 - great header, most tackles in the game for us, all round good effort
Delap 4 - just have no confidence he has the ball under control. Complete opposite to that control, turn it and shot at the end. Did put a good shift in though.
Gayle 5 - like Delap minus bothering the keeper but being able to control the ball.
The performance didn’t matter tonight though. The win did. 2 good goals and key players playing well.
|
|
|
|
Post by willieeetmiout on Nov 8, 2022 22:13:40 GMT
Bonham 5 - poor kicking, anticipation and coming for crosses.
Clarke 6 - okay
Wilmot 4 - both their excellent chances were down to his awful defending. Taylor should get a chance.
Souttar 7 - didn't seem to break sweat.
Fox 8 - two excellent crosses and a great tackle at the end.
Fosu 6 - okay
Baker 6 - okay
Smallbone 8 - busy all night. Much better CM than a CAM
Powell 7 - faded as the game went on.
Gayle 5 - poor
Delap 6 - I like him but decision making suspect tonight.
|
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Nov 8, 2022 22:13:57 GMT
Bonham - Far better than Bursik, crazy 6
Wilmott- loads of missed placed passes but he doesn’t shirk 6
Souttar - looked like he hadn’t missed a game 7
Fox - 2 assists, can’t give him any lower 7
Clarke - Got plenty of endevour, I wonder if he’s frustrated by the lack of quality he plays with 6
Baker - Fallen off a Cliff, very worrying downturn in form 5
Smallbone - As others have said, much improved but I’m not sure he’s cut out for this league 6
Powell - Good finish, looked to have a bit of mojo back 7
Fosu - Bull in a China shop, needs to think what he’s doing at the end of his latest head down charge 6
Delap - He’s very raw, which I did t expect. Thought he was alright overall 6
Gayle - He’s on his way out isnt he, shame 4
|
|
|
|
Post by boniek on Nov 8, 2022 22:16:53 GMT
Bonham 5
Fosu 5
Fox 7
Souttar 7
Wilmot 5
Clarke 6
Baker 5
Smallbone 8 Motm
Powell 7
Gayle 6
Delap 5
———————————
Brown n/a
Tyson n/a
|
|
|
|
Post by wakeypotter on Nov 8, 2022 22:17:28 GMT
Bonham - Far better than Bursik, crazy 6 Wilmott- loads of missed placed passes but he doesn’t shirk 6 Souttar - looked like he hadn’t missed a game 7 Fox - 2 assists, can’t give him any lower 7 Clarke - Got plenty of endevour, I wonder if he’s frustrated by the lack of quality he plays with 6 Baker - Fallen off a Cliff, very worrying downturn in form 5 Smallbone - As others have said, much improved but I’m not sure he’s cut out for this league 6 Powell - Good finish, looked to have a bit of mojo back 7 Fosu - Bull in a China shop, needs to think what he’s doing at the end of his latest head down charge 6 Delap - He’s very raw, which I did t expect. Thought he was alright overall 6 Gayle - He’s on his way out isnt he, shame 4 I know it’s your opinion mate but no way was Gayle any worse than delap. Sorry |
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Nov 8, 2022 22:18:36 GMT
Bonham - Far better than Bursik, crazy 6 Wilmott- loads of missed placed passes but he doesn’t shirk 6 Souttar - looked like he hadn’t missed a game 7 Fox - 2 assists, can’t give him any lower 7 Clarke - Got plenty of endevour, I wonder if he’s frustrated by the lack of quality he plays with 6 Baker - Fallen off a Cliff, very worrying downturn in form 5 Smallbone - As others have said, much improved but I’m not sure he’s cut out for this league 6 Powell - Good finish, looked to have a bit of mojo back 7 Fosu - Bull in a China shop, needs to think what he’s doing at the end of his latest head down charge 6 Delap - He’s very raw, which I did t expect. Thought he was alright overall 6 Gayle - He’s on his way out isnt he, shame 4 I know it’s your opinion mate but no way was Gayle any worse than delap. Sorry Opinions. To be fair I spent most of the second half cooking tea |
|
|
|
Post by tejstokie on Nov 8, 2022 22:18:45 GMT
Bonham - Far better than Bursik, crazy 6 Wilmott- loads of missed placed passes but he doesn’t shirk 6 Souttar - looked like he hadn’t missed a game 7 Fox - 2 assists, can’t give him any lower 7 Clarke - Got plenty of endevour, I wonder if he’s frustrated by the lack of quality he plays with 6 Baker - Fallen off a Cliff, very worrying downturn in form 5 Smallbone - As others have said, much improved but I’m not sure he’s cut out for this league 6 Powell - Good finish, looked to have a bit of mojo back 7 Fosu - Bull in a China shop, needs to think what he’s doing at the end of his latest head down charge 6 Delap - He’s very raw, which I did t expect. Thought he was alright overall 6 Gayle - He’s on his way out isnt he, shame 4 I guess this is how I saw it also. So many you'd think would be higher in tally but in reality ones who came straight in like Souttar or are off the bench like Smallbone did better. |
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Nov 8, 2022 22:19:38 GMT
Bonham 7 - the joys of having a competent keeper that comes for the ball
Clarke 6
Maldini 8
Wilmot 7
Fox 8 - two assists
Baker 6
Smallbone 7.5
Powell 8 - class and will improve
Fosu 6
Delap 7
Gayle 6
|
|
|
|
Post by wakeypotter on Nov 8, 2022 22:22:54 GMT
I know it’s your opinion mate but no way was Gayle any worse than delap. Sorry Opinions. To be fair I spent most of the second half cooking tea Yeh it’s funny how people see different things mate. I think scoring players can be influenced by if you rate them overall or not which I’ve been disappointed in delap. Hope you enjoyed your caviar |
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Nov 8, 2022 22:27:23 GMT
Opinions. To be fair I spent most of the second half cooking tea Yeh it’s funny how people see different things mate. I think scoring players can be influenced by if you rate them overall or not which I’ve been disappointed in delap. Hope you enjoyed your caviar I rate players as I see them bit some folk prioritise certain attributes over others I suppose which is fair enough. No caviar tonight, just a few grubs and a shrew from Hartshill Park😉 |
|
|
|
Post by tejstokie on Nov 8, 2022 22:29:56 GMT
Bonham 6 - Avg no nonsense keeping, oh how it can change fortunes
Clarke 6 - bleh, didn't create alot was defending avg, nothing noticeable eitherway
Wilmot 6 - Some good blocks and saves, poor touch and not defensive best today
Fox 7.5 - One assist and a forced OG from a power cross, nice tackling and up for it
Baker 5 - Worst on the pitch for me, such a drop in form its hard to not see.
Smallbone 8 - Motm for me, much improved, noticed his effort throughout well done.
Powell 7.5 - Better class than our strikers at reading the game. Only gonna get better.
Fosu 6 - Not his best but not the worst, put in a shift and had a great pass for our first.
Delap 6 - Tried to be cute instead of using his strength, wanted it at foot too much nearly got one when using his body for space.
Gayle 5.5 - Runs alot and tries atleast. Doesn't use his dribble for one twos to get open, but no support either. Underwhelming.
|
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Nov 8, 2022 22:31:39 GMT
Bonham 6 - Avg no nonsense keeping, oh how it can change fortunes Clarke 6 - bleh, didn't create alot was defending avg, nothing noticeable eitherway Wilmot 6 - Some good blocks and saves, poor touch and not defensive best today Fox 7.5 - One assist and a forced OG from a power cross, nice tackling and up for it Baker 5 - Worst on the pitch for me, such a drop in form its hard to not see. Smallbone 8 - Motm for me, much improved, noticed his effort throughout well done. Powell 7.5 - Better class than our strikers at reading the game. Only gonna get better. Fosu 6 - Not his best but not the worst, put in a shift and had a great pass for our first. Delap 6 - Tried to be cute instead of using his strength, wanted it at foot too much nearly got one when using his body for space. Gayle 5.5 - Runs alot and tries atleast. Doesn't use his dribble for one twos to get open, but no support either. Underwhelming. Souttar? |
|
|
|
Post by tejstokie on Nov 8, 2022 22:34:32 GMT
Bonham 6 - Avg no nonsense keeping, oh how it can change fortunes Clarke 6 - bleh, didn't create alot was defending avg, nothing noticeable eitherway Wilmot 6 - Some good blocks and saves, poor touch and not defensive best today Fox 7.5 - One assist and a forced OG from a power cross, nice tackling and up for it Baker 5 - Worst on the pitch for me, such a drop in form its hard to not see. Smallbone 8 - Motm for me, much improved, noticed his effort throughout well done. Powell 7.5 - Better class than our strikers at reading the game. Only gonna get better. Fosu 6 - Not his best but not the worst, put in a shift and had a great pass for our first. Delap 6 - Tried to be cute instead of using his strength, wanted it at foot too much nearly got one when using his body for space. Gayle 5.5 - Runs alot and tries atleast. Doesn't use his dribble for one twos to get open, but no support either. Underwhelming. Souttar? Oh, must had deleted him on accident. Souttar - 7.5 For someone coming back in out of a cannon he definitely was a huge lifting presence for Bonham, Clarke, Wilmot and Fox. Even if he was slower, missed some markings and wasn't motm he surely helped steady us. |
|
|
|
Post by willieeetmiout on Nov 8, 2022 22:35:03 GMT
Bonham 7 - the joys of having a competent keeper that comes for the ball Clarke 6 Maldini 8 Wilmot 7 Fox 8 - two assists Baker 6 Smallbone 7.5 Powell 8 - class and will improve Fosu 6 Delap 7 Gayle 6 He flapped at 2 and looked like a subutteo keeper on through balls |
|
|
|
Post by cobhamstokey on Nov 8, 2022 22:42:08 GMT
Bonham 6
Clarke 6
Souttar 7
Wilmot 7
Fox 7
Baker 5
Smallbone 8.5 MOTM
Powell 8
Fosu 7
Delap 7
Gayle 6
|
|
|
|
Post by RF10 on Nov 8, 2022 22:44:58 GMT
Bonham 6 Didn't really get tested to great deal but did fine on what he did have to do.
Clarke 6 Did fine
Wilmott 6 did fine
Souttar 7 given it was his first game back very pleased and like he hadn't been away
Fox 7 Two good assists
Smallbone 8 thought he really got stuck in when it mattered
Fosu 5 worked hard but feel he could get at opposition more
Powell 7 he was up for it tonight great header for goal, always draws fouls when on form
Delap 6 - would have 5 if not for shot at end. He looks to battle with opposition way too much at times probably as worked so well at u23 level
Gayle 5 not really sure what he offered tonight
|
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Nov 8, 2022 22:49:16 GMT
Bonham 7 - the joys of having a competent keeper that comes for the ball Clarke 6 Maldini 8 Wilmot 7 Fox 8 - two assists Baker 6 Smallbone 7.5 Powell 8 - class and will improve Fosu 6 Delap 7 Gayle 6 He flapped at 2 and looked like a subutteo keeper on through balls Came and collected a few times where Bursik wouldn’t have and we’d have conceded possession. |
|
|
|
Post by dwr17477 on Nov 8, 2022 22:49:59 GMT
Bonham 6 - just felt more confident with him there but we need a keeper in January.
Fosu 6
Fox 7
Souttar 7 - seemed untroubled.
Wilmot 5
Clarke 6
Baker 5
Smallbone 8 - his best game, lots of closing down.
Powell 7
Gayle 6
Delap 6
Brown 5
Tyson n/a
Felt on edge all game and another night Luton would have got something.
|
|
|
|
Post by shrewspotter on Nov 8, 2022 22:50:27 GMT
Bonham 6
Wilmot 4
Souttar 6
Fox 7 mom
Clarke 6
Baker 5
Smallbone 7
Powell 7
Fosu 6
Delap 6
Gayle 5
|
|
|
|
Post by roylandstoke on Nov 8, 2022 23:25:59 GMT
Bonham. 4 poor - better than Bursik
Wilmott 5
Souttar 6 good to have him back
Fox 7
Clarke 6
Baker 4
Smallbone 7
Fosu 6
Powell 7
Delap 5
Gayle 5
Tymon 6
Brown 6
We were second best all over the pitch. We played better against Blues, Coventry and Rotherham.
|
|
|
|
Post by walrus on Nov 8, 2022 23:49:24 GMT
We were second best all over the pitch. We played better against Blues, Coventry and Rotherham. I don’t agree. We did what we have allowed so many teams to do to us, get a goal or two up then get men behind the ball, effectively challenging the opposition to break down the defence, which they were unable to do. Souttar is such an asset in those sort of situations. It isn’t the most fun tactic to watch as a fan but having had a flying start we were for the most part well-organised, solid, and professional for the rest of the match. Luton really struggled to break us down. Their two decent sights of goal came from a corner and after a suicidal pass from Fox to Wilmot. In general play we more than had their measure. Not a game that will live long in the memory but a decent team performance for me. Far better than Coventry or Birmingham. |
|
|
|
Post by CBUFAWKIPWH on Nov 8, 2022 23:53:16 GMT
Bonham 6 pretty solid, way more reliable than Bursik
Fosu 7 always looking to take his man on
Fox 8 MoM 2 great crosses and solid in defence
Souttar 6 good in the air but looked stiff and a bit rusty
Wilmott 4 mistake waiting to happen
Clarke 6 ok
Smallbone 7 always available, tidy game
Baker 6 ok
Powell 6 good first half not really in the game in the second
Delap 7 put himself about and cracking shot best game for us
Gayle 6 put in a shift
Brown 5 didn't add much
Tymon NA
|
|
|
|
Post by roylandstoke on Nov 9, 2022 0:10:44 GMT
We were second best all over the pitch. We played better against Blues, Coventry and Rotherham. I don’t agree. We did what we have allowed so many teams to do to us, get a goal or two up then get men behind the ball, effectively challenging the opposition to break down the defence, which they were unable to do. Souttar is such an asset in those sort of situations. It isn’t the most fun tactic to watch as a fan but having had a flying start we were for the most part well-organised, solid, and professional for the rest of the match. Luton really struggled to break us down. Their two decent sights of goal came from a corner and after a suicidal pass from Fox to Wilmot. In general play we more than had their measure. Not a game that will live long in the memory but a decent team performance for me. Far better than Coventry or Birmingham. Luton missed 2 absolute sitters and wasted several other good chances. We were lucky.; it was a nice change. |
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Nov 9, 2022 0:19:16 GMT
Bonham 6
Wilmot 6
Souttar 7
Fox 7
Clarke 7
Baker 6
Smallbone 7
Powell 8
Fosu 6
Gayle 6
Delap 6
Brown 6
Tymon n/a
|
|
|
|
Post by crouchpotato1 on Nov 9, 2022 0:23:36 GMT
Bonham 7
Clarke 7
Wilmot 6
Souttar 7
Fox 7
Baker 6
Smallbone 8 ( MOTM)
Fosu 6
Powell 7
Gayle 6
Delap 7
Brown 6
|
|
|
|
Post by terrorofturfmoor on Nov 9, 2022 0:43:33 GMT
I know it’s your opinion mate but no way was Gayle any worse than delap. Sorry Opinions. To be fair I spent most of the second half cooking tea Not sure why, but this just cracked me up!!! 😂👍🏼 |
|
