|
Post by robwahlmann on Dec 15, 2020 19:48:47 GMT
Bursik 8, looks very solid and confident! MOM
Collins 7, Steady again! Souttar 8, very good player! Chester 7, a couple of dodgy actions, but all in all steady. Fox 7, difficult opponent in Samuel, but did well.
Tymon 6, OK, but a little too anonymous. Cousins 7, another good performance. Powell 6, not enough attacking contribution today.
Ince 7, without doubt our best attacking player today. McClean 6, works hard, but misses with too many crosses. Brown 4, I really struggle to see why we brought this player in. No vision, no ball controll and his decisons are simply woeful!
Fletcher 6, it didn't really happen for him today. Thompson 6, the midfield looked better when he replaced Tymon. TOB 6, did OK. Verlinden 7, not on for long, but really tried hard and showed some skills on the ball too.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2020 19:57:44 GMT
Bursik 6
Collins 5 Souttar 6 Chester 6 Fox 6
Tymon 6 Cousins 6 Powell 4
Ince 5 McClean 4
Brown 3
|
|
|
Post by thanksjon on Dec 15, 2020 20:10:59 GMT
Bursik 6 Collins 5 Souttar 6 Chester 6 Fox 6 Tymon 6 Cousins 6 Powell 4 Ince 5 McClean 4 Brown 3 Very harsh,how the keeper only gets six I don't know.
|
|
|
Post by terryconroysmagic on Dec 15, 2020 20:12:54 GMT
Bursik 8, looks very solid and confident! MOM Collins 7, Steady again! Souttar 8, very good player! Chester 7, a couple of dodgy actions, but all in all steady. Fox 7, difficult opponent in Samuel, but did well. Tymon 6, OK, but a little too anonymous. Cousins 7, another good performance. Powell 6, not enough attacking contribution today. Ince 7, without doubt our best attacking player today. McClean 6, works hard, but misses with too many crosses. Brown 4, I really struggle to see why we brought this player in. No vision, no ball controll and his decisons are simply woeful! Fletcher 6, it didn't really happen for him today. Thompson 6, the midfield looked better when he replaced Tymon. TOB 6, did OK. Verlinden 7, not on for long, but really tried hard and showed some skills on the ball too. Might have had Collins at an ā8ā but otherwise Iād agree
|
|
|
Post by RAF on Dec 15, 2020 20:12:59 GMT
Bursik 8
Collins 8 Souttar 8 Chester 7 Fox 5
Tymon 6 Cousins 7 Powell 5
Ince 6 McClean 4
Brown 3
H
|
|
|
Post by jarhead on Dec 15, 2020 20:13:34 GMT
Who gives a shit seriously
|
|
|
Post by scfcwebby on Dec 15, 2020 20:13:41 GMT
Bursik 8
Collins 6 Souttar 7 Chester 6 Fox 6
Tymon 5 Cousins 6 Powell 5
Ince 6 McClean 5
Brown 3
|
|
|
Post by crouchpotato1 on Dec 15, 2020 20:15:00 GMT
Bursik 8 Collins 8 Souttar 8 Chester 7 Fox 5 Tymon 6 Cousins 7 Powell 5 Ince 6 McClean 4 Brown 3 H Fox 5 š¤£š¤£
|
|
|
Post by Fred Merger on Dec 15, 2020 20:22:24 GMT
Bursik 8
Collins 7 Souttar 7 Chester 6 Fox. 7
Cousins 7 Tymon 6
Ince. 7 Powell. 6 McClean 5
Brown 5
Subs
Fletcher 6 Rob. 5 Verlinden 6
|
|
|
Post by numpty40 on Dec 15, 2020 20:25:36 GMT
Bursik 7, a very competent keeper
Collins 7, doing a great job at right back Souttar 8, a far better player than I ever thought he could be Chester 7, got skinned early on when he was easily turned but improved into the game Fox 8, had no support on the left but defended well and got forward to put a couple of decent crosses in.
Tymon 4, none existant, had the one miss hit shot early second half, that was his contribution. Cousins 8.5, my MOM, he was everywhere across and in front of the back 4 Powell 5, should be taking games like these by the scruff of the neck with his ability, frustrating as fuck. Ince 8, the Ince we all thought we'd signed. McClean 5, crossing is absolutely fucking woeful for a wide player Brown 5, worked hard and ran his bolox off but need far more at this level
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Dec 15, 2020 20:25:56 GMT
Bursik 7: commands box well, confidence growing every game. Collins 7: Superb passer, doing a good job at right back. Souttar 8: Another solid display with some crisp long range passing. Chester 6: Shaky start but looked comfortable second half. Fox 6: So many missed placed passes but improved as the game went on. Cousins 8: Excellent job winning possession and passing simply. Tymon 6: Anonymous first half, better when more advanced second half. Ince 6: Started brightly, showed some intelligent passing. Faded a bit later on. Powell 6: Class player and wins free kicks, not much came off though. Brown 5: Doesnāt look comfortable up front at all, too lightweight. McClean 5: 100% again but some woeful crossing and decision making.
Fletcher 6: We looked far better in the final third when he came on. Thompson 6: One decent effort, otherwise didnāt have much time. Oakley Booth 6: Even less time but steady enough. Verlinden 6: Looked threatening and gives us another dimension.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2020 20:26:03 GMT
Bursik 7
Collins 7 Souttar 7 Chester 7 Fox 6
Tymon 5 Cousins 7 Powell 5
Ince 6 McClean 4 Brown 4
|
|
|
Post by boskampsflaps on Dec 15, 2020 20:30:45 GMT
Bursik 7
Collins 7 Souttar 7 Chester 7 Fox 6
Tymon 5 Cousins 8 Powell 6
Ince 7 McClean 4
Brown 4
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2020 20:31:56 GMT
All the back 5 deserve 8s at least. Absolutely solid as a rock.
Impressive again.
|
|
|
Post by RAF on Dec 15, 2020 20:37:23 GMT
Bursik 8 Collins 8 Souttar 8 Chester 7 Fox 5 Tymon 6 Cousins 7 Powell 5 Ince 6 McClean 4 Brown 3 H Fox 5 š¤£š¤£ Yeah very average. H
|
|
|
Post by toppercorner on Dec 15, 2020 20:39:39 GMT
Bursik 8 Collins 8 Souttar 8 Chester 8 Fox 6 Tymon 6 Cousins 8 Powell 6 Ince 7 McClean 6 Brown 5
Fletcher 6 Verlinden 7 TOB 6
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2020 20:42:34 GMT
Bursik 6 Collins 5 Souttar 6 Chester 6 Fox 6 Tymon 6 Cousins 6 Powell 4 Ince 5 McClean 4 Brown 3 Very harsh,how the keeper only gets six I don't know. He starts on a 6. He had nothing to do. No real saves made. Thats not his fault but can't justify giving him more.
|
|
|
Post by crouchpotato1 on Dec 15, 2020 20:44:07 GMT
Thats me,Alan Parry and Lee Hendrie that thought differently then but each to their own mateš
|
|
|
Post by RAF on Dec 15, 2020 20:48:08 GMT
Thats me,Alan Parry and Lee Hendrie that thought differently then but each to their own mateš Oh well that's it then isn't it ? Conclusive your honour! Go and fucking wash my Ferrari! H :)
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Dec 15, 2020 20:59:23 GMT
Bursik 7 - very commanding again, marvellous stuff
Collins 7 - not an 8 because he could/should have been sent off/given away a penalty for unneccessary stupidity Souttar 7 - marked down because I thought his passing was off tonight, defended very well though Chester 6 - one really daft mistake but other than was sound Fox 6 - defended well, 1 lovely cross but his passing was shit
Cousins 7 - excellent defensively, good passing MOM Tymon 5 - came to life in the second half but wasn't noticeable in the 1st
Ince 6 - some good moments Powell 4 - sloppy passing, missed a sitter McClean 4 - just McClean really
Brown 4 - a lot of effort, minimal quality
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Dec 15, 2020 21:32:05 GMT
Bursik 8, looks very solid and confident! MOM Collins 7, Steady again! Souttar 8, very good player! Chester 7, a couple of dodgy actions, but all in all steady. Fox 7, difficult opponent in Samuel, but did well. Tymon 6, OK, but a little too anonymous. Cousins 7, another good performance. Powell 6, not enough attacking contribution today. Ince 7, without doubt our best attacking player today. McClean 6, works hard, but misses with too many crosses. Brown 4, I really struggle to see why we brought this player in. No vision, no ball controll and his decisons are simply woeful! Fletcher 6, it didn't really happen for him today. Thompson 6, the midfield looked better when he replaced Tymon. TOB 6, did OK. Verlinden 7, not on for long, but really tried hard and showed some skills on the ball too. Generally agree, I'm just querying how you can give Fletcher 6 and Brown 4 because I thought we were worse with Fletcher on, than with Brown. Our performance level went down after he came on I thought (though I think he's a top player). Brown is a very limited player technically and with decision making but he helps us to defend from the front, that seems to be his main role, does a lot of work for the team in that respect, closes down defenders, beats the defender to the ball very often in receiving the ball, and generally makes us harder to beat, I think that is why MON is picking him, any attacking threat would be a bonus it seems. For example, we would not have lost to Cardiff if Brown would have stayed up top and not got injured imho.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2020 21:41:30 GMT
3 standout players were Bursik, Collins and Souttar. Absolute top drawer.
The rest were pretty average IMO,
|
|
|
Post by AlbertTatlock on Dec 16, 2020 0:05:19 GMT
Just like the performance a boring 5 for the lot. Couldn't string 2 passes together ageing Nuns look more threatening and boy can we hoof it. Gouranga.
|
|
|
Post by nottsover60 on Dec 16, 2020 0:13:01 GMT
Thats me,Alan Parry and Lee Hendrie that thought differently then but each to their own mateš I always think it's interesting to hear what unprejudiced commentators think of players' performances. Fans of the club often see what they want to see rather than what actually happens and I swear for some people Fox starts on 5 and Collins on 8 and that doesn't change whatever they do. Another example is Chester being downgraded for his mistake early on but no mention of Souttar's mistake late on. I'm also surprised how good people thought Verlinden was in his 10 minutes. Did ok but I'm struggling to remember any danger he really caused QPR. I'm not criticising those young players just saying that a neutral sees things as they really are rather than how they think they should be.
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Dec 16, 2020 0:58:04 GMT
Thats me,Alan Parry and Lee Hendrie that thought differently then but each to their own mateš I always think it's interesting to hear what unprejudiced commentators think of players' performances. Fans of the club often see what they want to see rather than what actually happens and I swear for some people Fox starts on 5 and Collins on 8 and that doesn't change whatever they do. Another example is Chester being downgraded for his mistake early on but no mention of Souttar's mistake late on. I'm also surprised how good people thought Verlinden was in his 10 minutes. Did ok but I'm struggling toĀ remember anyĀ danger he really caused QPR. I'm not criticising those young players just saying that a neutral sees things as they really are rather than how they think they should be.Ā Everyone starts on a 5. Chester was pretty terrible first half imo
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Dec 16, 2020 6:08:47 GMT
Bursik 8, looks very solid and confident! MOM Collins 7, Steady again! Souttar 8, very good player! Chester 7, a couple of dodgy actions, but all in all steady. Fox 7, difficult opponent in Samuel, but did well. Tymon 6, OK, but a little too anonymous. Cousins 7, another good performance. Powell 6, not enough attacking contribution today. Ince 7, without doubt our best attacking player today. McClean 6, works hard, but misses with too many crosses. Brown 4, I really struggle to see why we brought this player in. No vision, no ball controll and his decisons are simply woeful! Fletcher 6, it didn't really happen for him today. Thompson 6, the midfield looked better when he replaced Tymon. TOB 6, did OK. Verlinden 7, not on for long, but really tried hard and showed some skills on the ball too. Generally agree, I'm just querying how you can give Fletcher 6 and Brown 4 because I thought we were worse with Fletcher on, than with Brown. Our performance level went down after he came on I thought (though I think he's a top player). Brown is a very limited player technically and with decision making but he helps us to defend from the front, that seems to be his main role, does a lot of work for the team in that respect, closes down defenders, beats the defender to the ball very often in receiving the ball, and generally makes us harder to beat, I think that is why MON is picking him, any attacking threat would be a bonus it seems. For example, we would not have lost to Cardiff if Brown would have stayed up top and not got injured imho. Fletcher is much better at using his body to fend defenders off, and his headers are aimed at someone. For me playing with Brown so far is the closest we have got to see a headless chicken on the pitch. I'm really disappointed with what Brown brings to the team so far.
|
|
|
Post by crouchpotato1 on Dec 16, 2020 8:01:31 GMT
Thats me,Alan Parry and Lee Hendrie that thought differently then but each to their own mateš I always think it's interesting to hear what unprejudiced commentators think of players' performances. Fans of the club often see what they want to see rather than what actually happens and I swear for some people Fox starts on 5 and Collins on 8 and that doesn't change whatever they do. Another example is Chester being downgraded for his mistake early on but no mention of Souttar's mistake late on. I'm also surprised how good people thought Verlinden was in his 10 minutes. Did ok but I'm struggling toĀ remember anyĀ danger he really caused QPR. I'm not criticising those young players just saying that a neutral sees things as they really are rather than how they think they should be.Ā Spot onš
|
|
|
Post by nottsover60 on Dec 16, 2020 9:01:42 GMT
I always think it's interesting to hear what unprejudiced commentators think of players' performances. Fans of the club often see what they want to see rather than what actually happens and I swear for some people Fox starts on 5 and Collins on 8 and that doesn't change whatever they do. Another example is Chester being downgraded for his mistake early on but no mention of Souttar's mistake late on. I'm also surprised how good people thought Verlinden was in his 10 minutes. Did ok but I'm struggling to remember any danger he really caused QPR. I'm not criticising those young players just saying that a neutral sees things as they really are rather than how they think they should be. Everyone starts on a 5. Chester was pretty terrible first half imo For you perhaps but not everyone. I know only one player risked throwing a point away not for a genuine mistake but for an impetuous use of his arms which if the referee had seen it would have been a penalty and yellow card. I wish he would cut that side of his game out. Having seen what he did playing for Ireland and last night I wonder if we got away with one on our appeal of his sending off. When he gets into the Premier spotlights that sort of thing will be highlighted and he will get a reputation. Yet people on here are saying he was faultless. His passing wasn't that good last night either.
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Dec 16, 2020 9:09:48 GMT
Bursik 7
Collins 7 Souttar 8 Chester 7 Fox 6
Cousins 7 Tymon 6
Ince 7 Powell 6 McClean 6
Brown 5
Fletcher 6 Verlinden 6 TOB 6 Thompson 6
|
|
|
Post by mickstupp on Dec 16, 2020 9:15:21 GMT
Bursik 8: Very good again. Heās Stoke Cityās first ever āsweeper keeperā. Superb kicking and handling.
Collins 8: Rock Solid. Needs to cut out occasional moments of ill discipline.
Fox 8: Also solid. Clearly playing with a head injury and shows real determination. Never gave Samuel a kick.
Chester 8: Another excellent outing for āMr Clean Sheetā. MOTM
Souttar 8: As per the other defenders.
Tymon 6: Could/should have scored, didnāt really notice him other than that.
Cousins 7: Neat and tidy. His shielding of the back four has played a huge part in our defensive success recently.
Powell 6: Disappointed he didnāt score with that header in the second half. I get the feeling heās playing whilst injured.
Ince 6: Not great, but not crap either. Slows down play by constantly wanting to cut in onto his left. Heās got to deliver now, we really need him to step up. Letās see if heās up to it.
Brown 5: Full of running but no quality.
McLean 5: Same as Brown.
All subs 6.
|
|