favourite of the 3

[big bea]

olofinjana amdy faye or diao

got be amdy faye for me for some reason i just prefer have him in before squad before the other 2

[Carrot]

Diao when on form imo ;D

[crashbandicoot]

Think Seyi pushes forward more than Salif or Faye so cant compare them.

Would have faye in tbh, just dont rate Salif at the moment

[luke45]

I agree, an in-form Diao wins hands down.

[thevue]

Can i pick Alan Hudson?

[Miniman]

AMDY FAYE!!!! He is the worst Centre mid we have! I would give David Oldfield a better reception! Utter Rubbish midfielder, complete tosspot. ;D

My favourite is Oli but I also like how Diao has improved this season, except for the odd blip in a few games such as giving away possession so cheaply against Manure as did Amdy faye.

Oli just seems immense down the wing or in the mid, supporting Fuller and Sidders.

[visunitafortior]

Oli is my fave, then Faye then Diao who was Shit at OT

[robchicken]

diao, he's been quality this season....then olofinjana

[swampySCFC]

Nov 21, 2008 20:39:15 GMT thevue said:

Can i pick Alan Hudson?

Shrewd post.

The others are too much akin for me.

[ratter1107]

Diao has bin like a new signing this season, allthough of late he hasnt bin upto scratch think its time for Whelan to a have a chance

[sgtpotter89]

difficult one.

olly and diao have both shown their quality at various times this season but have also had some bad moments this season as well

[arniepieinthesky]

I think these all showe at times what they are made of, but they all lack consistency. I'd at this time give it Oli...just. Potentially he is the better player for me, also had chipped in with a couple of goals so far.

[expectedtoulouse]

Diao wins hands down everytime. Amdy Faye has done nothing other than get himself sent off and miss a complete sitter. Other than his goals and the pass into Lawrence before our second goal vs Aston Villa, Olofinjana has been nothing short of terrible. He gives the ball away time and time again(can he strike the ball cleanly when its on the ground?), and at Wigan he wasn't even tackling.

[Rebelliousjukebox]

Oli for me - as others have said, can chip in with a goal.

[ti]

diao by quite a way, oli has more creativity but i believe that the only reason he hasnt lost is place because of giving away the ball is his physical presence compared to whealan (he is better than faye though). having said that when hes playing well hes fantastic

[Mr Rottweiler]

I've never seen anyone lose the ball as much as Diao has recently.

[sheikhmomo]

I quite like Olofinjana and can't understand some of the stick he gets. Then again i don't make many away games these days so can only presume he's wank in them?

[Olgrligm]

Olofinjana is too docile in central midfield and looks like a central midfield player playing out of position when he plays on the right. It worked against Arsenal because Clichy is 3 feet tall and crap. Whenever I watch Olofinjana though, he's just giving the ball away. Watching Portsmouth on Football First was bloody frustrating, because we got penned back due to Olofinjana's insistence on giving the ball away. First half vs Tottenham was the same.

Diao for me is easily the best of the three. Very, very classy in defence, even this season. Can't understand why people have been on his back so much, he's easily been the best of the central midfield players we've used this season.

Faye...meh. Take him or leave him. Not as good as Diao, probably better than Olofinjana. I'd rather Delap in his place and a winger on the left.

[trebor63]

Nov 21, 2008 20:39:15 GMT thevue said:

Can i pick Alan Hudson?

There isn't too much to choose between Hudson Diao faye and Olifinjana but to be fair Hudsons age is against him a bit. He must be about thirty years older than the others.