|
|
Post by musik on Sept 24, 2023 13:19:20 GMT
Player points today, what do you think?
I will think about it as I go out to buy me some toilet paper ...
Travers - 7 saved us from a 1-6 loss
Gooch - 3 really poor passes, distribution
McNally - 2 statue
Rose - 4 not good enough today
Wilmot - 3 tried, but no
Johnson - 5 wrong position for him
Thompson - 3 clumsy player
Laurent - 4 has lost it
Burger - 3 weak, immobile
Haksabanovic - 7 definitely top 3
Campbell - 4 injured early on, asthma?
Moraes - my MoM - 7 wish more ran like him
Vidigal - 6 it showed he had been injured
Bae - 5 didn't get enough time to be involved
Hoever - 4 was better in August
|
|
|
|
Post by boniek on Sept 24, 2023 13:25:00 GMT
Travers 5
Gooch 5
McNally 4
Rose 4
Wilmot 3
Johnson 4
Thompson 5
Laurent 4
Burger 4
Haksabanovic 5
Campbell n/a
Wesley 6 motm
Vidigal 6
Bae n/a
Hoever n/a
It’s gonna be a long season. Different players same story…
|
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Sept 24, 2023 13:25:26 GMT
Travers 4 - the glue on his touchline is causing us so much pressure, time to give Bonham a go
Wilmot 4 - shouldn’t be the left sided of the three but that defence was woeful
Rose 4
McNally 4
Johnson 4 - expert on bottom half football in a bottom half team, must be heaven for the lad, how shit must Tchamadeu be
Thompson 6 - six might be generous as I was expecting much worse
Fanny 3 - a disgrace to the club and the fact he’s captain sets the mood
Burger 5
Gooch 6.5 - looks a step above us at the moment, but it’s one low step
Haks - 5
Campbell 4 - like Laurent, that he keeps being picked sets the mood
Vidigal 7 - six plus one for the goal
Wesley 6 - missed some headers he should have won but did what he could
Junho 6
Hoever 6
This one is well and truly on the manager. An awful appointment.
|
|
|
|
Post by musik on Sept 24, 2023 13:33:58 GMT
It’s gonna be a long season. Different players same story… I'm afraid you're right. |
|
|
|
Post by thepottypotter on Sept 24, 2023 13:38:37 GMT
Travers 6
Gooch 7
McNally 5
Rose 4
Wilmot 3
Johnson 5
Thompson 4
Laurent 3 (dire. Should be dropped. Shouldn’t be captain)
Burger 5
Haksabanovic 6
Campbell n/a
Wesley 6
Vidigal 7 motm
|
|
|
|
Post by chad on Sept 24, 2023 13:40:45 GMT
Travers 6
Vidigal 7
Wes/Haska 6
The rest were just too shit to mark
|
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Sept 24, 2023 13:42:34 GMT
Anyone that doesn’t make Thompson our highest scoring midfielder today is completely blinkered, and
Thompson wasn’t very good either…..
|
|
|
|
Post by maninasuitcase on Sept 24, 2023 13:45:14 GMT
Gooch, wesley, vidigal 7
The rest were wank out of 10 and not fit to wear the shirt.
And dont get me started on the fucking master tactician. 😤😤
|
|
|
|
Post by thepottypotter on Sept 24, 2023 13:46:12 GMT
Anyone that doesn’t make Thompson our highest scoring midfielder today is completely blinkered, and Thompson wasn’t very good either….. I didn’t understand why he subbed Burger. He was better than Thommo. |
|
|
|
Post by musik on Sept 24, 2023 13:46:46 GMT
Anyone that doesn’t make Thompson our highest scoring midfielder today is completely blinkered, and Thompson wasn’t very good either….. It's like sorting different kind of poo. Johnson was my best midfielder, and he wasn't even a midfielder today. |
|
|
|
Post by DansViews on Sept 24, 2023 13:52:04 GMT
Travers 4
Gooch 5 - he looked ok gojng forward but had no one around.
McNally - 3 - shocking
Rose 3 - shocking
Wilmot 4 - slightly less shocking some of the time
Johnson 4 - what can you expect from a midfielder playing full back
Thompson 5 - did what I expected of him
Laurent 2
Burger 2
To see 2 midfielders jogging back when Hull are running at us, made me sick.
Haksabanovic 5 - I like the look of him but couldn’t do much
Campbell - 1. Looked shit, and gave up - doubt he’s even injured
Wesley 6 - looked a handful when he came on
Vidigal 6 - got the goal and looked to do something
Bae n/a
Hoever n/a
|
|
|
|
Post by boskampsflaps on Sept 24, 2023 13:52:20 GMT
Travers 5
Gooch 5
McNally 2
Rose 4
Wilmot 2
Johnson 5
Thompson 4
Laurent 4
Burger 4
Haksabanovic 5
Campbell n/a
Wesley 6 motm
Vidigal 6
Bae n/a
Hoever n/a
|
|
|
|
Post by boskampsflaps on Sept 24, 2023 13:54:06 GMT
Anyone that doesn’t make Thompson our highest scoring midfielder today is completely blinkered, and Thompson wasn’t very good either….. All as crap as each other for me, Thompson needs to learn to time a tackle. |
|
|
|
Post by chad on Sept 24, 2023 13:54:06 GMT
Anyone that doesn’t make Thompson our highest scoring midfielder today is completely blinkered, and Thompson wasn’t very good either….. I didn’t understand why he subbed Burger. He was better than Thommo. A traffic cone is better than Thompson |
|
|
|
Post by brutus on Sept 24, 2023 13:58:57 GMT
Player points today, what do you think? I will think about it as I go out to buy me some toilet paper ... Travers - 7 saved us from a 1-6 loss Gooch - 3 really poor passes, distribution McNally - 2 statue Rose - 4 not good enough today Wilmot - 3 tried, but no Johnson - 5 wrong position for him Thompson - 3 clumsy player Laurent - 4 has lost it Burger - 3 weak, immobile Haksabanovic - 7 definitely top 3 Campbell - 4 injured early on, asthma? Moraes - my MoM - 7 wish more ran like him Vidigal - 6 it showed he had been injured Bae - 5 didn't get enough time to be involved Hoever - 4 was better in August Think thats harsh on gooch! |
|
|
|
Post by st3mark on Sept 24, 2023 13:59:42 GMT
My, my, my,
Travers 5 - I don't personally blame him for any of the goals. Positioning off on the first goal but with friends like wilmot who needs enemies. He did the basics of his job fine.
Wilmot 3 - first half was his worst 45mins in a stoke shirt. The pass he gave away to them was kamikaze and we were lucky they didn't capitalise and then how he let Bidace win that ball he had no right to win for the first goal was unforgivable.
Rose 3 - his passing is absolutely shite. He gives it away constantly, his positioning is like someone who has never played in defence before yet he is a defender. His last two performances have been a clown show.
Mcnally 3 - really disappointed with this player. I thought he was going to sort our defensive problems out but he's no better than Rose. How they achieved play offs last year I haven't figured out yet but from now on when we play a back three of Rose, mcnally and wilmot ill be referring to them as the suicide squad.
Gooch 7 - a very generous 7 when in terms of actual football he probably warranted a 6. I've bumped him up because he showed more heart than the rest of the team put together. He did beyond the basics of his role and was competing. He was also bollocking his team mates which laurent never bothered to do. Gooch gives his all and in games like that you really separate the men from the boys.
Johnson 4 - out of position. Why is he there when we've got full backs on the bench?
Burger 4 - didn't have time to prove himself, was off the pace but should not have been the one hooked.
Thompson 4 - got stuck in a few times. The most basic achievement in football. Offered nothing in a forward sense and offered very little in terms of his actual role.
Laurent 3 - it's like he's clinically depressed (I sincerely hope that he isnt), he is a mute on the pitch and does not lead by example either in performance or with encouragement. His reactions are so slow its like his mind is thinking about something else. His passing was atrocious for a midfielder yet again. He needs dropping.
Haksabanovic 4 - he clearly tried to be involved. Him and TC are never going to work as a front 2 and neither are him and vidigal. His final ball was woeful today. His ball across to Burger first half when we took the quick free kick was embarrassing.
Campbell ? - no point rating him.
Vidigal 5.5 - gets points for the goal and for the effort. Had little connection with his team mates. I personally felt he was as missing as everyone else for large parts of the game.
Wesley 4 - generous 4 because he did appear bothered. His misses were that bad that I could justify giving him a three. Just him and the keeper and the whole goal to aim at and he hits it in the easiest place possible for the keeper, next chance he has he never even looks up and just clouts it miles wide, then his headed chance was crap as well.
Hoever/Bae - I can't even be arsed to score them because they didn't get much time but we did look more fluid for a while once Hoever came on. He didn't do anything special but things ticked over for a brief spell. Bae looked lost in the headlights a little bit but then put a decent ball in that nearly caused problems.
If I've missed anybody off from my list, fuck them.
|
|
|
|
Post by cobhamstokey on Sept 24, 2023 14:03:04 GMT
Travers - 7 Did well
Gooch - 6 At least he tries and doesn’t hide. No decent final ball though.
McNally - 5 poor
Rose - 5 poor
Wilmot - 5 poor
Johnson - 5 He’s not a wingback
Thompson - 5 Try’s but not good enough
Laurent - 4 invisible. Should not be captain.
Burger - 5 Not great
Haksabanovic - 7 I like him because he plays like he cares. Decent player but needs a goal.
Campbell - 4 Didn’t feel like a big loss when he came off
Moraes - my MoM - 7 did ok. Clearly not a natural finisher
Vidigal - 7 Good goal. Needs to get his fitness back
Bae - 6
Hoever - 6
|
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Sept 24, 2023 14:07:44 GMT
Anyone that doesn’t make Thompson our highest scoring midfielder today is completely blinkered, and Thompson wasn’t very good either….. All as crap as each other for me, Thompson needs to learn to time a tackle. He was the only midfielder who played forwards and broke the lines. And it’s the other who were meant to provide some semblance of creativity……. |
|
|
|
Post by Fred Merger on Sept 24, 2023 14:09:11 GMT
Travers 6
Gooch 6
McNally 5
Rose 5
Wilmot 3
Johnson 5
Thompson 4
Burger 4
Laurent 4
Habsabanovic 6
Campbell 4
Wesley 7
Vidigal 6
Junho 5
Hoever 6
|
|
|
|
Post by mrrine on Sept 24, 2023 14:09:35 GMT
Travers 6.5 - Think he did everything he could as well as he could. needs to release the ball earlier
Wilmot 3 - Absolute shocker
Rose 1.5 - I thought he'd come as back up. I wish he had.
Mcnally 2.5 - Not at all what we need. Crap again today.
Gooch 6 - Saw his limitations today, but he still plugged on
Johnson 4 - Agree with the poster above - why was he playing there. Did we buy Junior T for a laugh?
Burger 3 - looked very very weak, wanted too much time again today.
Thompson 4 - less than the bare minimum for his job role. Swamped in midfeild, his teammates didn't help him and he didnt help them.
Laurent 2 - "Captain"...
Haksabanovic 4 - Had a go, tried to beat his man 3 times in a row instead of releasing. Poor but not the worst.
Campbell 2 - Sick of the sight of him, if he isnt signing this contract, he shouldnt ever be playing for us again.
Vidigal 6.5 - Took quite something to score in that team today. kept plugging, clearly not totally match fit.
Wesley 5.5 - Sometimes worked sometimes didnt. His job was to hold the ball up, think he did that bit quite well, just seemed to be on a different wavelength to everyone. Didn't help that he had to drop super deep to get the ball and always had his back to goal.
|
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Sept 24, 2023 14:12:08 GMT
Travers - 7 Did well Gooch - 6 At least he tries and doesn’t hide. No decent final ball though. McNally - 5 poor Rose - 5 poor Wilmot - 5 poor Johnson - 5 He’s not a wingback Thompson - 5 Try’s but not good enough Laurent - 4 invisible. Should not be captain. Burger - 5 Not great Haksabanovic - 7 I like him because he plays like he cares. Decent player but needs a goal. Campbell - 4 Didn’t feel like a big loss when he came off Moraes - my MoM - 7 did ok. Clearly not a natural finisher Vidigal - 7 Good goal. Needs to get his fitness back Bae - 6 Hoever - 6 Sorry for picking on you here Cobham (as you are one of my favourite posters usually!) but Travers did not do well. He doesn’t come of his line for through balls or corners and it puts us under loads more pressure than an already rubbish team does. The save he made 2nd half was a save any half decent Champ goalkeeper makes. If Neil had put Bonham in goal today and he had the same performance folk would be ripping him to bits. Because we’ve been so bad between the sticks for six years or so Travers gets off lightly on here. He isn’t that good. |
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Sept 24, 2023 14:13:02 GMT
Travers 4 - should have come for the first
Wilmot 2 - absolutely fucking garbage. Just welly it for the first
McNally 3 - wank
Rose 2 - weak and wank
Gooch 6 - was ok
Johnson 4 - poor on the ball
Thompson 4 - be brave on the ball
Laurent 1 - did he touch it? Utter cunt
Burger 6 - didn’t do much wrong
Celtic dude 5 - tried
Campbell n/a
Wesley 7 - held it up nicely
Vidigal 6 - good goal
Bae 6 - really liked the look of him, has to start centrally
|
|
|
|
Post by svengaliinplatforms on Sept 24, 2023 14:34:21 GMT
Travers 5 - conceded 3, can't give him any more
Wilmot 2 - totally lost. Tripe
McNally 3 - Marginally less wank than the other two
Rose 2 - appalling, he looks shit, frankly
Gooch 5 - worked hard, found it tough in an insipid team performance
Johnson 5 - a fucking CAM at LWB. Enough said
Thompson 5 - tidy enough, but wayyy too negative when you're chasing a game
Laurent 2 - total shit. Abject. Seems to want too much time on the ball all the time, and games pass him by, he plays like he needs smelling salts. Captain? Not a chance. Footballer? Not convinced by that, either
Burger 4 - didn't think he was very good at all, before he went off
Habsa 5 - decent flashes. Looks a player. Maybe not upfront under this manager though
Campbell - not on long enough
Wesley 6 - made a bit of difference
Vidigal 6 - our best striker
Bae 5 - need to see more of him
|
|
|
|
Post by HarryTheHat on Sept 24, 2023 14:44:30 GMT
Travers 5 average performance
Gooch 6.5 never gave up
McNally 3 piss-poor (becoming his usual standard)
Rose 2 don't rate him at all, the worst of 3 very poor CB's today
Wilmot 3.5 I'm a big Wilmot fan but he was pretty awful today
Johnson 4 meh
Thompson 5 best of a bunch of wank midfield performances
Laurent 1 just fuck off please
Burger 2.5 rubbish today, starting to look a poor investment at this rate
Haksabanovic 6 same as Gooch, never gave up
Campbell 3 but you can almost guarantee he would probably have ended up as a 2 if he'd not gone off
Wesley 5 did his best but it's not really good enough is it?
Vidigal 6.5 looked a little ring-rusty and lightweight but you can't deny he knows where the net is
|
|
|
|
Post by foxxy on Sept 24, 2023 14:45:22 GMT
Travers 5 - not really his fault but yet to see if he’s any better than what we have had before up to now.
Wilmot 4 - doesn’t work in a 3 at the back
McNally 3 - poor
Rose 2 - the worse one of the 3
Gooch 6 - at least he was having a go and had a few good moments
Johnson 5 - unbelievable he is playing LWB
Thompson 5 - no worse than Pearson would have been. Best of the midfield 3
Laurent 2 - captain? What a joke
Burger 4 - was meh before being subbed
Habsa 5 - ok, not a striker
Campbell 4 - not sure he would have been the answer had he stayed on
Wesley 6 - I quite like him tbh. Needs support around him though.
Vidigal 6 - scored again
Bae 5 - needs to start in midfield. Centrally!
|
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Sept 24, 2023 14:52:58 GMT
Travers 5 (at fault for the first goal, why oh why did he not come out?)
McNally 3 (we have enough of our own crap without developing other peoples)
Rose 4 (Cannot play at the heart of a back 3)
Wilmot 5 (the left sided scapegoat due to our amazing recruitment)
Gooch 6 (ran out of ideas but kept plugging away at least)
Laurent 3 (a painful watch)
Thompson 6 (tried to break the lines and play the ball forwards and at least wanted possession)
Burger 4 (way off the pace)
Johnson 3 (as bad today as he was good on Wednesday)
Haksabanovic 5 (some good signs but wasteful)
Campbell 5 (didn’t really feature)
Wesley 6 (battles well but won’t score whilst I have a hole in my arse)
Vidigal 6 (our only goal threat)
Bae & Hoever 5 (too late to make an impact)
|
|
|
|
Post by Staffsoatcake on Sept 24, 2023 15:21:12 GMT
1 for Vidigal for scoring.
The rest can just fuck off.
|
|
|
|
Post by shrewspotter on Sept 24, 2023 15:31:25 GMT
Travers 6...not a lot to do bar picking the ball out of the net
McNally 3... looks nervy, maybe he'd be better in a 4
Rose 3... doesn't pick up the nan he should be marking, worrying
Wilmot 2... philogehe rinsed him, played higher for some parts of the 2nd half, no idea why but terrible
Gooch 5... not the worst out there but certainly not great
Johnson 3... played out of position, their manager got his tactics suit in against him, felt sorry for him
Thompson 5...did nothing, kept the ball but didn't go forward
Laurent 2...when you need your skipper to step up he instead goes hiding, pathetic
Burger 5... shouldn't have got hooked, terrible management
Campbell N/A
Haksobanovic 6...looked tricky but lacked final ball
Vidigal 7... took the goal well and beat touches.
Wes...7 held the ball up well I though
|
|
|
|
Post by jontimmis on Sept 24, 2023 15:34:06 GMT
In my opinion no one should get above a 7.
Most players were 3 today, give Gooch for effort a 6 and Vidigal for his goal.
It’s going to be a long season. 😩😩
|
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Sept 24, 2023 15:54:07 GMT
Travers 6
McNally 5
Rose 4
Wilmot 4
Gooch 7
Johnson 5
Thompson 6
Laurent 3
Burger 5
Campbell 5
Haks 5
Wesley 6
Vidigal 6
|
|
