|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Oct 1, 2021 22:15:24 GMT
Davies 6.3 looked shaky and nervous. That decision to pick up the ball outside the box was comedy gold. Bursik should come back next game. Wilmot 8, good game but dodgy passing still. Souttar 9, he is a tank. MOTM for me. Chester 8.5, the best I have seen him play. A rock and I hope he gets a run in the team Smith 7, good to see him back Tymon 7.5 played well. Allen 8. I don’t remember a misplaced pass and he got stuck in, great game Thompson 7 - did ok but some sloppy passing at times Vrancic 8 - oozes skill and class Powell 9 - dodgy passing first half and struggled to get into the game. However gets bonus points for having one chance and getting one skilful goal. Shows the other strikers how it is Brown 7 - so much energy, great engine and i love the pressing. Such a shame his finishing is poor. Surridge 5 he missed a sitter from 6 yards and a pen. Good positioning however, Fletcher 7, held the ball up well. Doughty 6 did fine Davies 6.3 🤣 the most obscure score I’ve ever seen!
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Oct 1, 2021 22:17:34 GMT
Davies 6 - average keeping for their chances until the weird handball on the edge of the box for sub par 6. Wilmot 8 - Improved from last match, better passing and great marking. Souttar 9 - Was the top of the mountain again, great passing and lovely marking. Chester 8 - Motm for me, several goal saving blocks, clearances and overall great play. Smith 7 - Average smith performance gets forward and gets back. He's back, nice to see. Tymon 7 - Average for me, had a few great passes into the box to be missed by fwds. Was tough for him versus a good opponent. Allen 7 - Better second half, very poor first half, too many missed passes to WBA players for an 8, but that 50/50 over a taller defender got him the 7 instead of 6. Thompson 6 - Pedestrian a lot of the match, but better in second decent squad player in the making. Vrancic 8 - Playmaking alone, movement and that near goal from a free kick. Powell 9 - That goal alone 9-10 rating, tbh was below average at times then he had that 15-20 min second half spell where he turned it on! Brown 6 - Ran his socks off, but can't control a ball or finish Surridge 5 Oof poor missed sitter and a missed peno, expect better from him coming off the bench fresh. Fletcher 7 - Average, got into the game instantly but not a lot for or against so average rating. Nice to see him back. I’m usually in agreement with you but one glaring error in your scoring. Souttar 9 Chester 8 MOM
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Oct 1, 2021 22:19:07 GMT
I certainly did! Even if you are in a minority you don't have to be wrong you know! Think you can find several examples of that through history! That is certainly true. On this occasion I think I'll go with the majority. Respect your opinion though! Its true his lack of pace showed early on in the game with the guy who cut inside and got the shot in, but after that he never gave them a sniff. I thought he was excellent. Fair enough.
|
|
|
Post by starkerz14 on Oct 1, 2021 22:44:57 GMT
I’ve had a few beers granted. We’re a proper goal scorer from wiping this league. Enter Tyrese
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 1, 2021 22:58:13 GMT
Davies 9
Wilmot 9 Souttar 9 Chester 9
Smith 9.5 Tymon 10 Allen 10 Thompson 9.5 Vrancic 10
Powell 11 Brown 9 Surridge 9 Fletcher 0 Doughty 7
|
|
|
Post by AlbertTatlock on Oct 1, 2021 23:29:01 GMT
Davies 9 Wilmot 9 Souttar 9 Chester 9 Smith 9.5 Tymon 10 Allen 10 Thompson 9.5 Vrancic 10 Powell 11 Brown 9 Surridge 9 Fletcher 0 Doughty 7 Fletcher 0? Have you caught him shagging your girlfriend? Gouranga.
|
|
|
Post by walrus on Oct 1, 2021 23:33:24 GMT
Davies 6 - average keeping for their chances until the weird handball on the edge of the box for sub par 6. Wilmot 8 - Improved from last match, better passing and great marking. Souttar 9 - Was the top of the mountain again, great passing and lovely marking. Chester 8 - Motm for me, several goal saving blocks, clearances and overall great play. Smith 7 - Average smith performance gets forward and gets back. He's back, nice to see. Tymon 7 - Average for me, had a few great passes into the box to be missed by fwds. Was tough for him versus a good opponent. Allen 7 - Better second half, very poor first half, too many missed passes to WBA players for an 8, but that 50/50 over a taller defender got him the 7 instead of 6. Thompson 6 - Pedestrian a lot of the match, but better in second decent squad player in the making. Vrancic 8 - Playmaking alone, movement and that near goal from a free kick. Powell 9 - That goal alone 9-10 rating, tbh was below average at times then he had that 15-20 min second half spell where he turned it on! Brown 6 - Ran his socks off, but can't control a ball or finish Surridge 5 Oof poor missed sitter and a missed peno, expect better from him coming off the bench fresh. Fletcher 7 - Average, got into the game instantly but not a lot for or against so average rating. Nice to see him back. I’m usually in agreement with you but one glaring error in your scoring. Souttar 9 Chester 8 MOM 9 is a bang average Souttar performance though so Chester gets MOTM for being a pleasant surprise with how good he was.
|
|
|
Post by hyaduck on Oct 2, 2021 1:37:45 GMT
Davies 7 - clean sheet, didn't really have a save to make because the defence was outstanding, dodgy moment Smith 9 - really solid Chester 9.5 - faultless performance, managed their forwards perfectly. Souttar 9 - excellent, as we are coming to expect Wilmot 9 - some brilliant distribution and very tidy Tymon 8 - great cross which should have resulted in a goal, should have done better with his chance, worked hard Allen 8 some dodgy passing first half, but won the midfield battle Thompson 7.5 - the pass for Tymon was exquisite, needs a bit more consistency Vrancic 7 - struggled at times but always a threat, beautiful to watch at times Brown 6 - struggled though his work rate does upset defenders Powell 8 - would have been 6 without the goal which was fantastic finish. Surridge 5 - oh dear! Brown- Struggled though his work rate does upset defenders. The rest of his play upsets me!!
|
|
|
Post by PotterLog on Oct 2, 2021 2:57:46 GMT
Davies 6 - average keeping for their chances until the weird handball on the edge of the box for sub par 6. Smith 7 - Average smith performance Tymon 7 - Average for me Fletcher 7 - Average, got into the game instantly but not a lot for or against so average rating. I don’t mean to pick on you specifically here but the way people rate 1-10 is seriously fucking perverted sometimes. In what world does 7 out of ten equal an average performance? You gave your man of the match an 8! And you’ve given Davies a “sub-par” 6. How can a 6 be anything other than *above* par? Shouldn’t he be a 4? The media does it as well, it’s as if the scale is 6 to 10, what’s the fucking point in having the other numbers
|
|
|
Post by miltonstokienew on Oct 2, 2021 5:56:02 GMT
Davies 7 - clean sheet, didn't really have a save to make because the defence was outstanding, dodgy moment Smith 9 - really solid Chester 9.5 - faultless performance, managed their forwards perfectly. Souttar 9 - excellent, as we are coming to expect Wilmot 9 - some brilliant distribution and very tidy Tymon 8 - great cross which should have resulted in a goal, should have done better with his chance, worked hard Allen 8 some dodgy passing first half, but won the midfield battle Thompson 7.5 - the pass for Tymon was exquisite, needs a bit more consistency Vrancic 7 - struggled at times but always a threat, beautiful to watch at times Brown 6 - struggled though his work rate does upset defenders Powell 8 - would have been 6 without the goal which was fantastic finish. Surridge 5 - oh dear! Brown- Struggled though his work rate does upset defenders. The rest of his play upsets me!! Luckily no one gives a fuck if you're upset
|
|
|
Post by shrewspotter on Oct 2, 2021 6:22:38 GMT
Davies 7 Wilmot 9 Souttar 9 Chester 9 Smith 8 Allen 9 Vrancic 8 Thompson 8 Tymon 8 Brown 7 Powell 9
Subs Fletcher 8 Surridge 6
|
|
|
Post by hyaduck on Oct 2, 2021 7:05:46 GMT
Brown- Struggled though his work rate does upset defenders. The rest of his play upsets me!! Luckily no one gives a fuck if you're upset So you think Brown was decent? Dear o dear. We not here to make friends we’re here to get promotion. Simple!!
|
|
|
Post by boniek on Oct 2, 2021 7:50:26 GMT
Davies 6
Smith 8 Motm Wilmot 8 Souttar 8 Chester 8 Tymon 7
Thompson 7 Allen 7 Vrancic 7 Powell 7
Brown 5 ——————- Surridge 5 Fletcher 6 Doughty N/A
Although I think Brown had a bad game he helps the team a lot by disrupting the opponents build up play. I fully understand why MON want to play him in spite of his other shortcomings (although very much improved from last season).
|
|
|
Post by roylandstoke on Oct 2, 2021 8:06:44 GMT
Davies 6 ok on crosses very average distribution bizarre handball
Wilmot 9 Souttar 9 Chestet 9 his best game by a country mile
Smith 9 Thompson 9 Allen 9 strong shout for most Tymon 8 not quite at his best going forward
Vrancic 9 Powell 9
Brown 9
|
|
|
Post by ravey123 on Oct 2, 2021 9:28:27 GMT
Davies - 6 (didn't really have to do a lot - did he actually have to make a save?) Smith - 8 Wilmot - 7 Souttar - 9 (we are seeing something really special with this lad) Chesters - 9 MOM his best game for Stoke by an absolute mile Tymon - 7 Allen - 8 Thompson - 8 Vrancic - 7 Powell - 8 Brown - 6
Surridge - 5 Dougherty - 5 (would have had 1 more but that decision to make an early cross very late in the game rather than go to the corner flag was a very pooor decision) Fletcher - 6
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Oct 3, 2021 12:04:35 GMT
Davies 7
Wilmot 7 Souttar 8 Chester 7
Smith 7 Tymon 7
Allen 7 Thompson 7 Vrancic 7.5
Powell 8 Brown 7
Surridge 6 Fletcher 6 Doughty, 6
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Oct 3, 2021 12:06:02 GMT
I’m usually in agreement with you but one glaring error in your scoring. Souttar 9 Chester 8 MOM 9 is a bang average Souttar performance though so Chester gets MOTM for being a pleasant surprise with how good he was. What a load of bollox. Admit you got it wrong.
|
|
|
Post by walrus on Oct 3, 2021 15:39:07 GMT
9 is a bang average Souttar performance though so Chester gets MOTM for being a pleasant surprise with how good he was. What a load of bollox. Admit you got it wrong. I wasn’t the original poster.
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Oct 3, 2021 16:14:51 GMT
Davies 5
Smith 8 Wilmot 8 Souttar 8 Chester 8 Tymon 7
Allen 6 Thompson 7
Vrancic 8 Brown 5 Powell 8
Fletcher 7 Surridge 5 Doughty n/a
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Oct 3, 2021 16:15:41 GMT
Davies 6 - average keeping for their chances until the weird handball on the edge of the box for sub par 6. Smith 7 - Average smith performance Tymon 7 - Average for me Fletcher 7 - Average, got into the game instantly but not a lot for or against so average rating. I don’t mean to pick on you specifically here but the way people rate 1-10 is seriously fucking perverted sometimes. In what world does 7 out of ten equal an average performance? You gave your man of the match an 8! And you’ve given Davies a “sub-par” 6. How can a 6 be anything other than *above* par? Shouldn’t he be a 4? The media does it as well, it’s as if the scale is 6 to 10, what’s the fucking point in having the other numbers Which is why I give people 3s and 4s and get battered for it 😂
|
|
|
Post by thepottypotter on Oct 3, 2021 16:26:34 GMT
Davies 5 Smith 8 Wilmot 8 Souttar 8 Chester 8 Tymon 7 Allen 6 Thompson 7 Vrancic 8 Brown 5 Powell 8 Fletcher 7 Surridge 5 Doughty n/a Doughty n/a? 5 for Brown is too harsh. He deserved a 6 with his engine, stretching their backline and high pressing. 6 for Allen is too low as well. I thought he had, rarely, one of his best games I have seen for Stoke. At least a 7. Otherwise the rest of the ratings seem fine to me
|
|
|
Post by scfc75 on Oct 3, 2021 16:35:25 GMT
I don’t mean to pick on you specifically here but the way people rate 1-10 is seriously fucking perverted sometimes. In what world does 7 out of ten equal an average performance? You gave your man of the match an 8! And you’ve given Davies a “sub-par” 6. How can a 6 be anything other than *above* par? Shouldn’t he be a 4? The media does it as well, it’s as if the scale is 6 to 10, what’s the fucking point in having the other numbers Which is why I give people 3s and 4s and get battered for it 😂 Surely the logical interpretation would be 1-2 = Very poor 3-4 = Below average 5-6 = Average 7-8 = Good 9-10 = Excellent
|
|
|
Post by theonlooker on Oct 3, 2021 16:47:43 GMT
Davies 7
Smith 8 Wilmot 8 Souttar 9 Chester 8 Tymon 7
Thompson 8 Allen 8 Vrancic 8
Powell 8 Brown 7
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Oct 3, 2021 16:49:42 GMT
Which is why I give people 3s and 4s and get battered for it 😂 Surely the logical interpretation would be 1-2 = Very poor 3-4 = Below average 5-6 = Average 7-8 = Good 9-10 = Excellent Seems fair to me yeah.
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Oct 3, 2021 16:51:13 GMT
Davies 5 Smith 8 Wilmot 8 Souttar 8 Chester 8 Tymon 7 Allen 6 Thompson 7 Vrancic 8 Brown 5 Powell 8 Fletcher 7 Surridge 5 Doughty n/a Doughty n/a? 5 for Brown is too harsh. He deserved a 6 with his engine, stretching their backline and high pressing. 6 for Allen is too low as well. I thought he had, rarely, one of his best games I have seen for Stoke. At least a 7. Otherwise the rest of the ratings seem fine to me Don’t think he was on for long enough was he? I disagree. Allen’s passing annoyed me. Thought there was times where he made us nervous unnecessarily so marked him down for that.
|
|
|
Post by thepottypotter on Oct 3, 2021 16:58:48 GMT
Doughty n/a? 5 for Brown is too harsh. He deserved a 6 with his engine, stretching their backline and high pressing. 6 for Allen is too low as well. I thought he had, rarely, one of his best games I have seen for Stoke. At least a 7. Otherwise the rest of the ratings seem fine to me Don’t think he was on for long enough was he? I disagree. Allen’s passing annoyed me. Thought there was times where he made us nervous unnecessarily so marked him down for that. Including the injury time, I think Doughty was on for 10 mins.
|
|
|
Post by PotterLog on Oct 4, 2021 2:41:33 GMT
Which is why I give people 3s and 4s and get battered for it 😂 Surely the logical interpretation would be 1-2 = Very poor 3-4 = Below average 5-6 = Average 7-8 = Good 9-10 = Excellent 1 disastrous 2 awful 3 poor 4 well under par 5 one side of average 6 the other side of average 7 decent 8 good 9 excellent 10 outstanding
|
|
|
Post by hotterpotter on Oct 4, 2021 7:51:15 GMT
Which is why I give people 3s and 4s and get battered for it 😂 Surely the logical interpretation would be 1-2 = Very poor 3-4 = Below average 5-6 = Average 7-8 = Good 9-10 = Excellent Perhaps should be put in the OP of each ratings thread.
|
|
|
Post by hardcastle on Oct 4, 2021 12:10:47 GMT
You're right. It's easy to get into the habit of just using a 5,6,7 or 8 and ignoring the other six numbers.
Guilty as charged !
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Oct 4, 2021 12:22:11 GMT
Doughty n/a? 5 for Brown is too harsh. He deserved a 6 with his engine, stretching their backline and high pressing. 6 for Allen is too low as well. I thought he had, rarely, one of his best games I have seen for Stoke. At least a 7. Otherwise the rest of the ratings seem fine to me Don’t think he was on for long enough was he? I disagree. Allen’s passing annoyed me. Thought there was times where he made us nervous unnecessarily so marked him down for that. First half Allen's passing was awful. Improved the second half.
|
|