|
|
Post by StokeBoy1988 on Jan 30, 2009 2:48:33 GMT
All not good enough in my opinion!
Amdy Faye is half decent but not better than Diao or Seyi in my opinion!
Soares and Tonge were evidently panic buys!
Cresswel is poor at this level, Pugh is nothing special
Pericard is dreadful!
Sonko is shocking!
|
|
|
|
Post by MilanStokie on Jan 30, 2009 3:24:33 GMT
All well and good but selling 2 strikers when we only have 5 fit strikers on the books isn't going to help us stay up. If we ever SELL Pericard I will run naked past Newcastle Guild Hall, into McDonald's and snog the first fat wench working behind the counter.
Pugh is useful and a really good backup.
Amdy is about the best centre midfielder we currently have. Occasional mare of a game and tends to jump into tackles early which then TP needs to sub him. However, with Diao injured, we can't just throw our midfielders out.
I would personally keep Sonko and all defenders at the club.
Who to get rid of? Sell Tonge (just hasn't cut it for me in any performances) and Cresswell (Wages for below par players are going to end up crippling us) and if possible get Pericard a loan to the conference. Get a young loanee in. Keep the rest.
I'd love to see 2 new players, a full back (either side) and a midfielder.
|
|
|
|
Post by The Occasional Man on Jan 30, 2009 3:29:29 GMT
Pugh should be in the 1st team in CM at this point in time - he's the only player whose shown any ability in that role when he's played there!
|
|
|
|
Post by evans1863 on Jan 30, 2009 3:40:30 GMT
Get rid of:
Pericard (well even if we have to pay him off)
Cresswell
Sonko
Olofijana
Phillips
Cort
Soares
Tongue
Davis (not impressed me one bit)
Diao (getting old now and I rate Whelan and Amdy Faye a lot higher than him, his distribution is far too slow and at times he seems lazy and happy to hover instead of putting a challenge in)
Should be able to bring in 4 or 5 players for the same amount that we'd recieve for moving these players on, hence a smaller but stronger squad.
|
|
|
|
Post by hutchstokie1 on Jan 30, 2009 8:04:47 GMT
keep pugh, amdy faye was awfull against spurs!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by Danstoke82 on Jan 30, 2009 8:19:13 GMT
Get rid of: Pericard (well even if we have to pay him off) Cresswell Sonko Olofijana Phillips Cort Soares Tongue Davis (not impressed me one bit) Diao (getting old now and I rate Whelan and Amdy Faye a lot higher than him, his distribution is far too slow and at times he seems lazy and happy to hover instead of putting a challenge in) Should be able to bring in 4 or 5 players for the same amount that we'd recieve for moving these players on, hence a smaller but stronger squad. If we sold all those we would have no squad?! I agree with selling: Pericard - crap Phillips - never really going to cut it here Oli - absolute dissapointment maybe a loan Tonge - maybe a loan deal also as we now have Ethers? However I dont agree with: Cresswell - Pulis would NEVER sell him Sonko - see above, plus he would be admitting he made a fook up by signing the oaf. Cort- A good back-up for us Soares - will come good soon, has glimpses of good play. Davies - not sure, havent seen enough of him. Diao - you cannot sell him, he's a decent holding midfielder. When fit. Pericard (well even if we have to pay him off) Cresswell Sonko Olofijana Phillips Cort Soares Tongue Davis (not impressed me one bit) Diao |
|
