|
|
Post by Milkie on Feb 16, 2024 14:23:49 GMT
Copied from facebook, but deserves its own thread. I can’t make my mind up if we have been unlucky, players developed after we went, or just incompetent in putting a winning formula together. There has to be a squad there that could have taken us back up in the last 6 years ??
Let's have a look at every player we've had since relegation... Can you pick a decent 11 here? 🤷
- Jack Butland
- Jack Bonham
- Joe Bursik
- Blondy Noukeu
- Frank Fielding
- Daniel Iversen
- Adam Davies
- Adam Federici
- Angus Gunn
- Mark Travers
- Tommy Simkin
- Cameron Carter-Vickers
- Ki-Jana Hoever
- Harry Clarke
- Ben Wilmot
- Josh Tymon
- Erik Pieters
- Bruno Martins Indi
- Ryan Shawcross
- Connor Taylor
- Harry Souttar
- Leo Østigård
- Nathan Collins
- Ashley Williams
- Stephen award
- Tarique Fosu
- Ben Pearson
- Cuco Martina
- Liam Lindsay
- James Chester
- Phil Jagielka
- Rhys Norrington-Davies
- Taylor Harwood-Bellis
- Dujon Sterling
- Jordan Cousins
- Ryan Woods
- John Obi Mikel
- Will Smallbone
- Peter Etebo
- Josh Laurent
- Jordan Thompson
- Bojan
- Morgan Fox
- Tom Ince
- James McClean
- Nick Powell
- Jacob Brown
- Tommy Smith
- Joe Allen
- Sam Clucas
- Danny Batth
- Tyrese Campbell
- Lewis Baker
- Steven Fletcher
- Benik Afobe
- Sam Vokes
- Tom Edwards
- Dwight Gayle
- Andre Vidigal
- Lee Gregory
- Mario Vrancic
- Romaine Sawyers
- Sadio Berahino
- Liam Delap
- Badou Ndiaye
- Josh Maja
- Aden Flint
- Mame Diouf
- Sam Surridge
- Matija Sarkic
- Wesley
- Moritz Bauer
- Jack Clarke
- D’Margio Wright Phillips
- Tashan Oakley-Boothe
- Jaden Philogene
- Rabbi Matondo
- Charlie Adam
- Scott Hogan
- Darren Fletcher
- Liam Moore
- Bersant Celina
- Will Forester
- Axel Tuanzebe
- Thibaud Verlinden
- Lasse Sorensen
- Demeaco Duhaney
- Tom Sparrow
- Mark Duffy
- Christian Norton
- Alfie Doughty
- Abdullah Sima
- Gavin Kilkenny
- Emre Tezgel
- Nathan Lowe
- Julian Ngoy
- Wouter Burger
- Bae Jun-Ho
- Ryan Mmaee
- Million Manhoef
- Luka Cundle
- Mehdi Leris
- Lyden Gooch
- Daniel Johnson
- Luke McNally
- Junior Tchamadeu
- Sead Hakšabanovic
- Ciaran Clark
- Liam McCarron
- Enda Stevens
- Michael Rose
- Sol Sidibe
- Chiquinho
|
|
|
|
Post by PotteringThrough on Feb 16, 2024 14:26:32 GMT
I can give you a decent 11 before they joined Stoke and a decent 11 after they left.
Just struggling on the bit in between.
|
|
|
|
Post by Veritas on Feb 16, 2024 14:27:33 GMT
Copied from facebook, but deserves its own thread. I can’t make my mind up if we have been unlucky, players developed after we went, or just incompetent in putting a winning formula together. There has to be a squad there that could have taken us back up in the last 6 years ?? Let's have a look at every player we've had since relegation... Can you pick a decent 11 here? 🤷 - Jack Butland - Jack Bonham - Joe Bursik - Blondy Noukeu - Frank Fielding - Daniel Iversen - Adam Davies - Adam Federici - Angus Gunn - Mark Travers - Tommy Simkin - Cameron Carter-Vickers - Ki-Jana Hoever - Harry Clarke - Ben Wilmot - Josh Tymon - Erik Pieters - Bruno Martins Indi - Ryan Shawcross - Connor Taylor - Harry Souttar - Leo Østigård - Nathan Collins - Ashley Williams - Stephen award - Tarique Fosu - Ben Pearson - Cuco Martina - Liam Lindsay - James Chester - Phil Jagielka - Rhys Norrington-Davies - Taylor Harwood-Bellis - Dujon Sterling - Jordan Cousins - Ryan Woods - John Obi Mikel - Will Smallbone - Peter Etebo - Josh Laurent - Jordan Thompson - Bojan - Morgan Fox - Tom Ince - James McClean - Nick Powell - Jacob Brown - Tommy Smith - Joe Allen - Sam Clucas - Danny Batth - Tyrese Campbell - Lewis Baker - Steven Fletcher - Benik Afobe - Sam Vokes - Tom Edwards - Dwight Gayle - Andre Vidigal - Lee Gregory - Mario Vrancic - Romaine Sawyers - Sadio Berahino - Liam Delap - Badou Ndiaye - Josh Maja - Aden Flint - Mame Diouf - Sam Surridge - Matija Sarkic - Wesley - Moritz Bauer - Jack Clarke - D’Margio Wright Phillips - Tashan Oakley-Boothe - Jaden Philogene - Rabbi Matondo - Charlie Adam - Scott Hogan - Darren Fletcher - Liam Moore - Bersant Celina - Will Forester - Axel Tuanzebe - Thibaud Verlinden - Lasse Sorensen - Demeaco Duhaney - Tom Sparrow - Mark Duffy - Christian Norton - Alfie Doughty - Abdullah Sima - Gavin Kilkenny - Emre Tezgel - Nathan Lowe - Julian Ngoy - Wouter Burger - Bae Jun-Ho - Ryan Mmaee - Million Manhoef - Luka Cundle - Mehdi Leris - Lyden Gooch - Daniel Johnson - Luke McNally - Junior Tchamadeu - Sead Hakšabanovic - Ciaran Clark - Liam McCarron - Enda Stevens - Michael Rose - Sol Sidibe - Chiquinho Yes, next question |
|
|
|
Post by datguy on Feb 16, 2024 14:30:31 GMT
Gunn
Sterling Souttar Collins Tymon
Mikel Burger
Campbell Powell Brown
Fletcher
When at their very best for SCFC.
Mikel's legs went though.
Powell too injury prone, huge shame for us and him.
Fletcher was a bit of class I thought, very good striker at this level when he came in, but surprise surprise buy a mid-30s player, expect their legs to go.
|
|
|
|
Post by LL Cool Dave on Feb 16, 2024 14:30:41 GMT
Forgot about Fosu, thought he was pretty good. Free agent now.
|
|
|
|
Post by tommycarlsberg on Feb 16, 2024 14:33:43 GMT
Travers
Clarke Collins Souttar Pieters
Mikel Burger
Ince Bojan Campbell
Powell
|
|
|
|
Post by cvillestokie on Feb 16, 2024 14:35:02 GMT
Butland (first season)
Sterling Souttar Collins Pieters
Baker Burger
Brown Powell Campbell
Fletcher
It’s a sad state of affairs though when we’ve changed the squad so much and that’s the best I can come up with.
|
|
|
|
Post by datguy on Feb 16, 2024 14:37:01 GMT
Andy Lonergan is not on that list and played in the Carabao Cup quarter final vs Tottenham.
|
|
|
|
Post by stiggerstackle on Feb 16, 2024 14:40:26 GMT
Forgot about Fosu, thought he was pretty good. Free agent now. That surprises me - he was pretty tricky down the left as I remember, and pacy. |
|
|
|
Post by mickstupp on Feb 16, 2024 14:41:31 GMT
Christ there’s some dross on that list.
|
|
|
|
Post by cvillestokie on Feb 16, 2024 14:42:09 GMT
I can’t believe that we didn’t use Diouf in the Championship up front. Sheer stupidity.
|
|
|
|
Post by dirtygary69 on Feb 16, 2024 14:55:01 GMT
Mark Travers
Tommy Smith
Leo Østigård
Harry Souttar
Alfie Doughty
Wouter Burger
Bojan
Nick Powell
Bae Jun Ho
Tyrese Campbell
Steven Fletcher
Maybe something like that, based on their time here and how some of them have done since?
|
|
|
|
Post by PotterLog on Feb 16, 2024 15:24:17 GMT
I can give you a decent 11 before they joined Stoke and a decent 11 after they left. Just struggling on the bit in between. So thinking of these players *at their peak* (not necessarily with us), I think this would be a good Prem team: Butland Sterling Jags Ryan Pieters Mikel Adam Berahino Bojan Doughty Diouf Subs Iversen Bruno Collins Burger Etebo Ince Clarke Gayle Powell |
|
|
|
Post by thedeadlyshart on Feb 16, 2024 17:31:38 GMT
You could create a solid squad from just the players who are currently on other teams in the Championship from this list. With multiple proven options at every position… except striker. We really can’t get that one right
|
|
