|
|
Post by idle on Dec 12, 2023 21:55:09 GMT
Bonham 3 - he let in their only shot on target by making the blunder of the year. Pathetic Hoever 4 - (mostly) shit corners, shit FKs, and was partly at fault for their goal. McNally 6 - good defensively, lacking a bit of passing accuracy when he winds the ball Rose 6 - ditto, but should have scored at least one Gooch 7 - good game, lively, and wasn't bothered by Johnson being in the centre Pearson 6 - ok game, loved the falling over the adboard-thingy  Burger 6 - a bit sloppy at times, but gives us some forward momentum Junior 6 - started shaky in a wierd and unusual position, but got better and better. HE MUST START! Laurent 6 - worked hard, but wasn't really friendly with the ball today Johnson 6 - nice penalty, a bit too backwards with his passing. Got better in the 2nd Mmaee 6 - struggled as a single forward, but got into a few good positions and won the pen Junho 6 - he has such good control, just lacking the final ball Thompson 6 - did his job well enough Gallagher 7 - really wierd lineup, but it kinda worked. Swansea wasn't all that, but still Ref 5 - desperately one-sided against us in the first, better in the second (did they switch again?) All in all a good performance from the lads except for that one blunder. The xG shows that we should have battered them |
|
|
|
Post by redstriper on Dec 12, 2023 22:03:16 GMT
Bonham 4 - should have done better with the goal but he wasnt the only one.
Hoever 6 - saved a certain goal at least
McNally 6 - solid
Rose 6 - also solid, missed a sitter
Gooch 8 - always positive, covered a lot of ground and used the ball well
Pearson 6 - ok
Burger 6 - ok
Junior 6 - looked rusty but grew into it
Laurent 6 - ok
Johnson 7 - put himself about
Mmaee 6 - ok
Junho 6 - looked lively, appears to be getting stronger on the ball
Thompson 6 - did his job well enough
|
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Dec 12, 2023 22:47:47 GMT
Bonham 2 - fuck off
Hoever 3 - fuck off
McNally 7 - good defender
Rose 6 - scary as hell but used the ball well
Gooch 7 - probably MOM
Pearson 6 - did his job
Burger 6 - same
Junior 6 - driving presence, needs to use the ball better
Laurent 5 - better but just annoying
Johnson 4 - would have been a 3 bar scoring. Useless
Mmaee 4 - I like him for the stuff he does like winning the penalty but fuck me. Use the ball quicker and fucking shoot. Would have been a 3 bar for the peno win.
|
|
|
|
Post by AlbertTatlock on Dec 12, 2023 22:49:03 GMT
Bonham 4 Hoever 6 McNally 6 Rose 6 Gooch 8 Pearson 8 Burger 6 Junior 6 Laurent 6 Johnson 6 Mmaee 7 Junho 6 Thompson 6 Gouranga.  |
|
|
|
Post by cvillestokie on Dec 12, 2023 22:50:37 GMT
Gooch: 6.5
Hoever: 4
Bonham: 3
5 for the rest.
|
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Dec 12, 2023 22:52:54 GMT
Bonham 4 - had sod all to do then gave them the goal
Hoever 4 - rubbish corners and a few awful passes too
McNally 7 - didn't have much to do but I didn't spot any mistakes
Rose 5 - similar defensively to McNally but missed two sitters
Tchamadeu 6 - I think he'll make a very good RB, looked rusty but put the work in and helped going forward
Pearson 6 - would've been a 7 but for the booking that meant he couldn't tackle for the rest of the game
Burger 7 - much more of what we need to see
Gooch 7 - good going forward, looked very comfortable
Johnson 5 - gets an extra point for the goal, but way off it again, he's a poor player
Laurent 7.5 - best game in a loooooong time, put the work in and played a few decent passes
Mmaee 5 - seems low on confidence, a better striker and we could've won comfortably
|
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Dec 12, 2023 22:57:58 GMT
Bonham 5
Hoever 6
McNally 6
Rose 6
Gooch 7
Pearson 7
Burger 8
Junior 7
Laurent 6
Johnson 6
Mmaee 7
Junho 6
Thompson 6
Referee 4
|
|
|
|
Post by danmase on Dec 12, 2023 23:03:26 GMT
Bonham 3 - looked nervy all night. Cost us the game. He's nowhere near good enough.
Hoever 6 - decent defensively and combined well with Junior.
McNally 6 - not troubled all night
Rose 6 - so much better than Clark. Must play.
Tchamedau 6 - lots of energy and enthusiasm. Plays on the front foot. Hopefully we don't break him.
Pearson 5 - idiotic booking
Laurent 6 - much better. Won the ball higher up, made things happen.
Burger 6 - there's a really good football player trying to break out of him
Johnson 6 - better. Good penalty.
Mmae 6 - he's a handful. Should have had 2 goals.
|
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Dec 12, 2023 23:08:47 GMT
For the first half alone, absolute garbage.
I switched off, sounds like the second half was better but I can’t watch this team at the moment
|
|
|
|
Post by dobber on Dec 12, 2023 23:18:52 GMT
Bonham: 5 - ok until that brain fart
Hoover: 5 - a couple of decent moments, but lots of guff
McNally: 6 - solid defending throughout
Rose: 6 - Ditto (but should have done better at the end)
Gooch: 7 - generally excellent, made things happen, bit lucky when he slipped and almost gave a goal away
Junior: 6 - looked lost in the first half, far better in the second
Pearson: 6 - decent mopping up and some excellent drives forward
Burger: 6 - apart from the one random pass back, looked decent. Decent movement and good ball retention.
Laurent: 7 - my MOTM. Thought he had a great game, solid all over, supported both attack and defence, added real energy to the team.
DJ: 7 - obviously some on here have an agenda (also see JL), but thought it was his best game for ages. He broke up the play high up the pitch, played some excellent fast progressive passes, and scored an excellent penalty.
Mmaee: 6 - there's definitely a player in there, some excellent interchanges, runs and passes...but please stay onside!!
Subs
Junho: 6 - looking stronger every game. Great energy, just needs the final ball.
JT: 6 good cameo.
Lowe: Not on long enough to mark
|
|
|
|
Post by Veritas on Dec 12, 2023 23:31:27 GMT
Bonham 3 Nothing to do until the howler for the goal
Hoever 5 Equal numbers of positives and errors
Mcnally 5 Reasonable but lost his man for the goal
Rose 6 Steady defensively, erratic going forward
Gooch 8 High energy throughout and mostly positive, exactly what we have been missing
Pearson 6 Mostly tidy and aggressive when needed, still needs to move the ball quicker
Burger 7 As with Pearson but did try to up the pace
Junior 6 Good energy but as many errors as positives, not quite the game changer some were claiming
Laurent 6 Mostly positive and showed more energy than of late
Johnson 5 Took his penalty well but too often failed to close down leaving their midfielders open to receive easy passes.
Maaee 3 Didn't press, didn't hold the ball, constantly offside, fluffed two great chances. Did win the penalty.
|
|
|
|
Post by staffordpotter78 on Dec 12, 2023 23:39:32 GMT
Bonham 4 - Little to do but did that poorly.
Hoever 4 - Shadow of last seasons player.
McNally 6 - Solid
Rose 6 - Almost as solid as McNally.
Gooch 7 - Energetic and tried to take the game by the balls.
Pearson 7 - Looked composed for once.
Burger 6 - Solid if not spectacular.
Junior 7 - Lots of effort and gusto but so raw
Laurent 6 - Same as Burger.
Johnson 7 - Best I've seen him play.
Mmaee 7 - Looked more promising with lots of effort but zero confidence in front of goal.
Junho 5 - He reminds me of a performing seal at the zoo, lots and lots of tricks with the ball but can't actually play football.
Thompson 6 - A typical "Meh" Thompson performance.
|
|
|
|
Post by Robo10 on Dec 13, 2023 0:20:41 GMT
People giving Mmaae more marks than others, a 7 from some, must be watching a different fucking game to me
Slow, cant control the ball, wants too long on it, doesnt shoot.
And worse, he doesnt attack the ball at all - countless crosses went in tonight and he is nowhere near, doesnt even make the run. At one point a cross came in from Gooch on the left, there was nobody there and our 'striker' had drifted onto the right wing!
Doeast jump for headers, weak as piss holding the ball up
His run for the pen was good, but I was glad he didnt take it!
Bonham 2 gash cost us 2 points
Hoever 3 just awful all night (/since August)
Rose 6 OK
McNally 6 OK - neither marked their dude for the goal
Gooch 7 - I enjoyed watching his effort and play
Junior 7 - iffy first half, brill 2nd
Pearson 6 all action, ridiculously booked
Laurent 7 best for a while
Burger 5 was OK but no real influence, falls over his own feet at times
Johnson 6 good pen, was involved, slows play down
Mmae 4 not good enough if we want to move up the league
In a game where scoring goals and not conceding is quite important, we have strikers not good enough at this level, and a keeper / parts of the defence worse still.
Bar all that we are good 😂
|
|
|
|
Post by NassauDave on Dec 13, 2023 0:29:35 GMT
For the first half alone, absolute garbage. I switched off, sounds like the second half was better but I can’t watch this team at the moment Did the same here. Boring as fuck at the moment. |
|
|
|
Post by Pottersfan on Dec 13, 2023 0:32:25 GMT
Bonham 2 - fuck off Hoever 3 - fuck off McNally 7 - good defender Rose 6 - scary as hell but used the ball well Gooch 7 - probably MOM Pearson 6 - did his job Burger 6 - same Junior 6 - driving presence, needs to use the ball better Laurent 5 - better but just annoying Johnson 4 - would have been a 3 bar scoring. Useless Mmaee 4 - I like him for the stuff he does like winning the penalty but fuck me. Use the ball quicker and fucking shoot. Would have been a 3 bar for the peno win. How come you come back on here mate? Most people were hoping you fucked off for good ? |
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Dec 13, 2023 0:34:17 GMT
Bonham 2 - fuck off Hoever 3 - fuck off McNally 7 - good defender Rose 6 - scary as hell but used the ball well Gooch 7 - probably MOM Pearson 6 - did his job Burger 6 - same Junior 6 - driving presence, needs to use the ball better Laurent 5 - better but just annoying Johnson 4 - would have been a 3 bar scoring. Useless Mmaee 4 - I like him for the stuff he does like winning the penalty but fuck me. Use the ball quicker and fucking shoot. Would have been a 3 bar for the peno win. How come you come back on here mate? Most people were hoping you fucked off for good ? I never left, what the hell are you on about 🤣 And why? Don’t like the truth? |
|
|
|
Post by boniek on Dec 13, 2023 9:41:08 GMT
Bonham 4
Hoever 5
McNally 6
Rose 6
Gooch 7 motm
Pearson 5
Burger 5
Junior 6 (at a stretch)
Laurent 6
Johnson 7
Mmaee 5
—————————————-
Junho 5
Thompson n/a
Lowe n/a
|
|
|
|
Post by devondumpling on Dec 13, 2023 12:41:20 GMT
Bonham 2 - fuck off Hoever 3 - fuck off McNally 7 - good defender Rose 6 - scary as hell but used the ball well Gooch 7 - probably MOM Pearson 6 - did his job Burger 6 - same Junior 6 - driving presence, needs to use the ball better Laurent 5 - better but just annoying Johnson 4 - would have been a 3 bar scoring. Useless Mmaee 4 - I like him for the stuff he does like winning the penalty but fuck me. Use the ball quicker and fucking shoot. Would have been a 3 bar for the peno win. How come you come back on here mate? Most people were hoping you fucked off for good ? Most people just block him for a sane life. Easy. |
|
|
|
Post by stokie223 on Dec 13, 2023 13:14:39 GMT
Crazy how one man's 4 is another man's 7 when watching the same game!
Personally, when judging DJ's performance, I lean more towards those giving him a 4.
I really don't see what tangible effect he has on the team - complete nothing player.
He's nowhere near forward-thinking or creative enough to warrant taking up that role, and offers little defensively.
I must admit - prior to signing him I didn't really know too much about him but I find myself very unimpressed.
Bae should be in there and given a good run of games to allow himself to fully bed in. He's infinitely better than Johnson.
|
|
|
|
Post by biddulphchav on Dec 13, 2023 15:02:02 GMT
Crazy how one man's 4 is another man's 7 when watching the same game! Personally, when judging DJ's performance, I lean more towards those giving him a 4. I really don't see what tangible effect he has on the team - complete nothing player. He's nowhere near forward-thinking or creative enough to warrant taking up that role, and offers little defensively. I must admit - prior to signing him I didn't really know too much about him but I find myself very unimpressed. Bae should be in there and given a good run of games to allow himself to fully bed in. He's infinitely better than Johnson. I agree, I think Johnson is crap. He has zero awareness when he receives the ball - he’ll only ever play one touch if that pass is backwards. To play a forward pass he needs 2,3,4 touches and time to look up and assess. Way to slow with it and he’s not good enough at this level in terms of his vision. Cannot be a starter if we want to progress and I’m fairly sure the new man will see that. |
|
|
|
Post by numpty40 on Dec 13, 2023 18:05:27 GMT
Crazy how one man's 4 is another man's 7 when watching the same game! Personally, when judging DJ's performance, I lean more towards those giving him a 4. I really don't see what tangible effect he has on the team - complete nothing player. He's nowhere near forward-thinking or creative enough to warrant taking up that role, and offers little defensively. I must admit - prior to signing him I didn't really know too much about him but I find myself very unimpressed. Bae should be in there and given a good run of games to allow himself to fully bed in. He's infinitely better than Johnson. But you've already stated he's a 'complete nothing player' so you're only going to see the mistakes he makes to confirm your view. We all do it, I like Johnson so I see the good things he does in a game. Some get a little entrenched in their opinions of players. |
|
|
|
Post by nott1 on Dec 13, 2023 18:08:14 GMT
Not worth the effort!
|
|
|
|
Post by smallthorner on Dec 13, 2023 18:51:54 GMT
I think Burger is wank.
|
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Dec 13, 2023 21:04:08 GMT
Congratulations, next week we will try longer sentences, and introduce commas. |
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Dec 13, 2023 21:10:50 GMT
Bonham 5 Hoever 6 McNally 6 Rose 6 Gooch 7 Pearson 7 Burger 8 Junior 7 Laurent 6 Johnson 6 Mmaee 7 Junho 6 Thompson 6 Lowe 6 Referee 4 |
|
|
|
Post by smallthorner on Dec 13, 2023 21:18:07 GMT
Congratulations, next week we will try longer sentences, and introduce commas. Why would I need commas? |
|
|
|
Post by stokie223 on Dec 13, 2023 21:54:14 GMT
Crazy how one man's 4 is another man's 7 when watching the same game! Personally, when judging DJ's performance, I lean more towards those giving him a 4. I really don't see what tangible effect he has on the team - complete nothing player. He's nowhere near forward-thinking or creative enough to warrant taking up that role, and offers little defensively. I must admit - prior to signing him I didn't really know too much about him but I find myself very unimpressed. Bae should be in there and given a good run of games to allow himself to fully bed in. He's infinitely better than Johnson. But you've already stated he's a 'complete nothing player' so you're only going to see the mistakes he makes to confirm your view. We all do it, I like Johnson so I see the good things he does in a game. Some get a little entrenched in their opinions of players. Perfectly capable of being objective and not suffering from confirmation bias… he’s just useless. No agenda, just my opinion. I’d have no problem congratulating him if he’d played well but he doesn’t affect the game, albeit scoring a penalty last night. His general play is poor in terms of being an attacking threat. No problem with him being in the squad as a backup as it’s not like he’s making mistake after mistake, but he’s a sensationally average footballer and we won’t achieve much with him starting as an attacking midfielder. |
|
|
|
Post by roscoepcoltrane on Dec 13, 2023 22:11:13 GMT
People giving Mmaae more marks than others, a 7 from some, must be watching a different fucking game to me Slow, cant control the ball, wants too long on it, doesnt shoot. And worse, he doesnt attack the ball at all - countless crosses went in tonight and he is nowhere near, doesnt even make the run. At one point a cross came in from Gooch on the left, there was nobody there and our 'striker' had drifted onto the right wing! Doeast jump for headers, weak as piss holding the ball up His run for the pen was good, but I was glad he didnt take it! Bonham 2 gash cost us 2 points Hoever 3 just awful all night (/since August) Rose 6 OK McNally 6 OK - neither marked their dude for the goal Gooch 7 - I enjoyed watching his effort and play Junior 7 - iffy first half, brill 2nd Pearson 6 all action, ridiculously booked Laurent 7 best for a while Burger 5 was OK but no real influence, falls over his own feet at times Johnson 6 good pen, was involved, slows play down Mmae 4 not good enough if we want to move up the league In a game where scoring goals and not conceding is quite important, we have strikers not good enough at this level, and a keeper / parts of the defence worse still. Bar all that we are good 😂 This….just this !! |
|
|
|
Post by numpty40 on Dec 13, 2023 22:24:03 GMT
But you've already stated he's a 'complete nothing player' so you're only going to see the mistakes he makes to confirm your view. We all do it, I like Johnson so I see the good things he does in a game. Some get a little entrenched in their opinions of players. Perfectly capable of being objective and not suffering from confirmation bias… he’s just useless. No agenda, just my opinion. I’d have no problem congratulating him if he’d played well but he doesn’t affect the game, albeit scoring a penalty last night. His general play is poor in terms of being an attacking threat. No problem with him being in the squad as a backup as it’s not like he’s making mistake after mistake, but he’s a sensationally average footballer and we won’t achieve much with him starting as an attacking midfielder. There's not one stoke player who affects the game in a positive way at the moment but Johnson is one player who does try and play early forward balls and defends high up the pitch. He's no world beater but is an easy target for people who seem to prefer a safer sideways and backwards passer of the ball in midfield. |
|
|
|
Post by terrorofturfmoor on Dec 14, 2023 0:29:26 GMT
Burger, Gooch and Laurent all 7
The rest 6 and under!!!
|
|
