|
|
Post by viewfromthecrowsnest on Oct 8, 2022 16:23:35 GMT
Bursik - Sublime save in 1st half, a couple of poor clearances and comedy, but generally with it and nice casually done shitehousing. 7
Sterling - Solid and looks a top player, defensively minded and has pace and power. 8
Wilmot - Another goal, unfussy performance and possibly formation helped limit his usual error prone self. 7
Jags - Class act. Steered the whole defence with calm authority and nice header for the goal. 9
Fox - Steady day today, some poor passing but improving. 6
Laurent - Could be the destroyer we’ve waited for. Some poor passes but pit in a shift. 7
Baker - Brilliant distribution and his pass to start the move for the 3rd goal was inspired. 7
Smallbone - very advanced role, better workrate and passing but not spectacular. 6
Fosu - A creative spark, everything he did was positive and Utd struggled to get him under control. Crucial goalline clearance. 9
Ty - Gradually getting back to his level, arrogance and control much better, workrate excellent for him. 8
Gayle - Selfless and efficient, led and linked well with Ty. 7
Delap - got a killer goal. Will this be the launch pad? 7
Clucas - Did his bit to keep pressure on defence. 7
Clarke - Like for like with Sterling 7
Thompson - Nice headgear.
|
|
|
|
Post by thepottypotter on Oct 8, 2022 16:25:12 GMT
Bursik 7
Sterling 8
Jagielka 8.5 how does he play so well at 40?!
Wilmot 7
Fox 7
Laurent 7.5
Smallbone 7
Baker 7
Campbell 7
Gayle 6
Fosu 9 (motm) excellent display and great goal line clearance! Goes over a bit too easily though
Delap 7
Clucas 6
Clarke 7
|
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Oct 8, 2022 16:26:00 GMT
Bursik 5 - still can’t kick, won’t command his area and puts us in trouble far too often
Wilmot 7 - nice finish
Jagielka 8 - great assist and nice header, solid and commanding
Fox 6 - better than normal, perhaps 6.5
Sterling 7 - amazing what playing a player in his natural position can do
Baker 7 - solid game, vocal
Laurent 7 - improved, put himself about
Smallbone 7 - much improved
Fosu 8 - see Sterling, absolutely brilliant, an 8 feels slightly harsh
Campbell 6 - shied out of a bit but needs games
Gayle 7 - connected with play well
Clucas 6 - did enough
Clarke 6 - love this guy
Delap 7 - was worried when he missed his chance but delighted when he scored a very similar one, hopefully the spark needed
Thompson n/a
I’ve sort of copied the club’s pre match line up but I think it was more 433 than 352
|
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Oct 8, 2022 16:27:01 GMT
Fosu 9
Jagielka, Wilmott, Laurent 8
Everyone else 7.5
|
|
|
|
Post by claytonscrubs on Oct 8, 2022 16:37:40 GMT
Jagielka … 9
Sterling, Laurent, Fosu, Baker … 8
The rest … 7
|
|
|
|
Post by theblackdeath on Oct 8, 2022 16:47:06 GMT
Fosu 100 One of the best individual displays I've seen since Ric. Even doing crucial goal line clearances
Everyone else 10
|
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Oct 8, 2022 16:51:55 GMT
Bursik 7 - comfortable
Sterling 8 - energetic and lively, promising
Jagielka 8 - Solid
Wilmot 8 - seems to be play better with Jagielka
Fox 7 - one of his best games for Stoke, good interceptions and more controlled with passing and positioning
Laurent 8 - broke down play well
Smallbone 7 - better, still needs to win more 50-50 balls, some nice passes
Baker 7 - controlled the midfield for the most part and played the ball around well
Campbell 8 - lovely assist for the 3rd goal, always look to have more goals in the team when he is on the pitch.
Gayle 7 - held up play well, linked up well, needs a goal
Fosu 9 - thought he was excellent. MOTM, so lively and energetic and good with the ball, important contribution for the 3rd goal, that volley would have been goal of the season!
Delap 7 - great to see him pick up that goal, positioned himself well for it.
Everyone contributed.
|
|
|
|
Post by Staffsoatcake on Oct 8, 2022 16:55:18 GMT
Everyone an 8.
|
|
|
|
Post by ravey123 on Oct 8, 2022 17:22:56 GMT
Bursik 7
Fox 8
Jagielka 8
Wilmot 8
Sterling 8 (would have got 9 but tired at the end)
Laurent 7
Baker 7
Smallbone 6
Fosu 9 (MOM)
Campbell 8
Gayle 8
Clucas 7
Delap 7
Thompson n/a
|
|
|
|
Post by terryconroysmagic on Oct 8, 2022 17:33:04 GMT
Jags was class just proves a football brain always trumps pure pace. The difference since he’s been brought back has been startling.
MoM for me.
Fosu was a close second with Sterling not far behind (that lads as strong as a bull)
|
|
|
|
Post by Jimm on Oct 8, 2022 17:34:30 GMT
All solid 7's with Sterling and Fosu 8's. Subs 6's with Delap a 7
|
|
|
|
Post by thicknthin on Oct 8, 2022 17:37:17 GMT
Bursik 5 - still can’t kick, won’t command his area and puts us in trouble far too often Wilmot 7 - nice finish Jagielka 8 - great assist and nice header, solid and commanding Fox 6 - better than normal, perhaps 6.5 Sterling 7 - amazing what playing a player in his natural position can do Baker 7 - solid game, vocal Laurent 7 - improved, put himself about Smallbone 7 - much improved Fosu 8 - see Sterling, absolutely brilliant, an 8 feels slightly harsh Campbell 6 - shied out of a bit but needs games Gayle 7 - connected with play well Clucas 6 - did enough Clarke 6 - love this guy Delap 7 - was worried when he missed his chance but delighted when he scored a very similar one, hopefully the spark needed Thompson n/a I’ve sort of copied the club’s pre match line up but I think it was more 433 than 352 Harsh on young Joe, that save first half alone should make him a 7 |
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Oct 8, 2022 17:47:47 GMT
Bursik 5 - still can’t kick, won’t command his area and puts us in trouble far too often Wilmot 7 - nice finish Jagielka 8 - great assist and nice header, solid and commanding Fox 6 - better than normal, perhaps 6.5 Sterling 7 - amazing what playing a player in his natural position can do Baker 7 - solid game, vocal Laurent 7 - improved, put himself about Smallbone 7 - much improved Fosu 8 - see Sterling, absolutely brilliant, an 8 feels slightly harsh Campbell 6 - shied out of a bit but needs games Gayle 7 - connected with play well Clucas 6 - did enough Clarke 6 - love this guy Delap 7 - was worried when he missed his chance but delighted when he scored a very similar one, hopefully the spark needed Thompson n/a I’ve sort of copied the club’s pre match line up but I think it was more 433 than 352 Harsh on young Joe, that save first half alone should make him a 7 Standard save, we’d be going mad if that went in. |
|
|
|
Post by J-Roar on Oct 8, 2022 18:17:59 GMT
Bursik 5 - still can’t kick, won’t command his area and puts us in trouble far too often Wilmot 7 - nice finish Jagielka 8 - great assist and nice header, solid and commanding Fox 6 - better than normal, perhaps 6.5 Sterling 7 - amazing what playing a player in his natural position can do Baker 7 - solid game, vocal Laurent 7 - improved, put himself about Smallbone 7 - much improved Fosu 8 - see Sterling, absolutely brilliant, an 8 feels slightly harsh Campbell 6 - shied out of a bit but needs games Gayle 7 - connected with play well Clucas 6 - did enough Clarke 6 - love this guy Delap 7 - was worried when he missed his chance but delighted when he scored a very similar one, hopefully the spark needed Thompson n/a I’ve sort of copied the club’s pre match line up but I think it was more 433 than 352 Seriously? The best performance since before we were relegated and you're giving out 5s and 6s? |
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Oct 8, 2022 18:23:35 GMT
Bursik 5 - still can’t kick, won’t command his area and puts us in trouble far too often Wilmot 7 - nice finish Jagielka 8 - great assist and nice header, solid and commanding Fox 6 - better than normal, perhaps 6.5 Sterling 7 - amazing what playing a player in his natural position can do Baker 7 - solid game, vocal Laurent 7 - improved, put himself about Smallbone 7 - much improved Fosu 8 - see Sterling, absolutely brilliant, an 8 feels slightly harsh Campbell 6 - shied out of a bit but needs games Gayle 7 - connected with play well Clucas 6 - did enough Clarke 6 - love this guy Delap 7 - was worried when he missed his chance but delighted when he scored a very similar one, hopefully the spark needed Thompson n/a I’ve sort of copied the club’s pre match line up but I think it was more 433 than 352 Seriously? The best performance since before we were relegated and you're giving out 5s and 6s? Yeah, that’s how I saw the game. We won a match where we were the better team but on another day, if they’re shot where Bursik was well beaten hit the post and came out had hit the post and gone in we’d have been 2-1 down. It didn’t and we won, but we’ve beaten a Championship team where the standard isn’t great, not Man City in the cup. If I did half points I’d have given Fosu 8.5 and Campbell 6.5. |
|
|
|
Post by stokerstayinup on Oct 8, 2022 18:29:52 GMT
Bursik 5 - still can’t kick, won’t command his area and puts us in trouble far too often Wilmot 7 - nice finish Jagielka 8 - great assist and nice header, solid and commanding Fox 6 - better than normal, perhaps 6.5 Sterling 7 - amazing what playing a player in his natural position can do Baker 7 - solid game, vocal Laurent 7 - improved, put himself about Smallbone 7 - much improved Fosu 8 - see Sterling, absolutely brilliant, an 8 feels slightly harsh Campbell 6 - shied out of a bit but needs games Gayle 7 - connected with play well Clucas 6 - did enough Clarke 6 - love this guy Delap 7 - was worried when he missed his chance but delighted when he scored a very similar one, hopefully the spark needed Thompson n/a I’ve sort of copied the club’s pre match line up but I think it was more 433 than 352 Seriously? The best performance since before we were relegated and you're giving out 5s and 6s? We played well today but come on,steady on. |
|
|
|
Post by a on Oct 8, 2022 18:39:27 GMT
Bursik - Sublime save in 1st half, a couple of poor clearances and comedy, but generally with it and nice casually done shitehousing. 7 Sterling - Solid and looks a top player, defensively minded and has pace and power. 8 Wilmot - Another goal, unfussy performance and possibly formation helped limit his usual error prone self. 7 Jags - Class act. Steered the whole defence with calm authority and nice header for the goal. 9 Fox - Steady day today, some poor passing but improving. 6 Laurent - Could be the destroyer we’ve waited for. Some poor passes but pit in a shift. 7 Baker - Brilliant distribution and his pass to start the move for the 3rd goal was inspired. 7 Smallbone - very advanced role, better workrate and passing but not spectacular. 6 Fosu - A creative spark, everything he did was positive and Utd struggled to get him under control. Crucial goalline clearance. 9 Ty - Gradually getting back to his level, arrogance and control much better, workrate excellent for him. 8 Gayle - Selfless and efficient, led and linked well with Ty. 7 Delap - got a killer goal. Will this be the launch pad? 7 Clucas - Did his bit to keep pressure on defence. 7 Clarke - Like for like with Sterling 7 Thompson - Nice headgear. Campbell wasn’t an 8. Lazy for large spells. Great for the assist and great vision, so glad he didn’t shoot. Wilmot was better than Campbell. Great goal aided by a superb ball. Gayle was non-existent. Can’t argue with the rest. Good solid team performance and the effort was evident mostly. |
|
|
|
Post by stokesupporter on Oct 8, 2022 18:54:51 GMT
Bursik 6 a bit suspect again, why cant they coach him to kick properly? Was OK otherwise.
Sterling 8 great def and att.
Jagielka 8 scored and was solid
Wilmot 8 got +1 for scoring the opener
Fox 7 had a good game again almost 8
Laurent 7
Smallbone 7 His best game for us
Baker 7 Little quiet but was OK
Campbell 7
Gayle 6
Fosu 9 *MOTM superb display, wish we could sign him permanently
Delap 7 scored his first, more to come?
Clucas 6
Clarke 7 Fast and direct, good defensively too
|
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Oct 8, 2022 18:57:37 GMT
Bursik 7
Sterling 8
Jagielka 8
Wilmot 7
Fox 7
Laurent 7
Smallbone 6
Baker 7
Campbell 7
Gayle 7
Fosu 8
Delap 6
Clucas 6
Clarke 6
Referee 3
|
|
|
|
Post by crouchpotato1 on Oct 8, 2022 18:59:42 GMT
No player deserves less than 8 in my opinion
Jags and Fosu outstanding both 9’s
|
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Oct 8, 2022 19:01:07 GMT
Harsh on young Joe, that save first half alone should make him a 7 Standard save, we’d be going mad if that went in. 🤣🤣🤣🤣 don't be ridiculous, it was a stunning save. |
|
|
|
Post by J-Roar on Oct 8, 2022 19:01:53 GMT
Seriously? The best performance since before we were relegated and you're giving out 5s and 6s? We played well today but come on,steady on. Name me a better home performance under Lambert, Rowett, Jones or MON. Possibly Leeds under Jones or WBA under MON. That's how shit the last few years have been. |
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Oct 8, 2022 19:18:36 GMT
Harsh on young Joe, that save first half alone should make him a 7 Standard save, we’d be going mad if that went in. 🤣🤣🤣🤣 don't be ridiculous, it was a stunning save. |
|
|
|
Post by proudstokie on Oct 8, 2022 19:28:06 GMT
Seriously? The best performance since before we were relegated and you're giving out 5s and 6s? Yeah, that’s how I saw the game. We won a match where we were the better team but on another day, if they’re shot where Bursik was well beaten hit the post and came out had hit the post and gone in we’d have been 2-1 down. It didn’t and we won, but we’ve beaten a Championship team where the standard isn’t great, not Man City in the cup. If I did half points I’d have given Fosu 8.5 and Campbell 6.5. That’s just nonsense tbf mate. Bursik’s kicking was poor at times but he made a crucial save, reacted well to the ball hitting the post and made some really decisive handling decisions from corners in the 2nd half. As for Campbell it was probably his best game since his injury, he put himself about, could easily have had a goal with a good effort on goal and twice put a goal on a plate for Delap. Sounds all bit more like preconceived opinions vs what actually happened! |
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Oct 8, 2022 19:39:55 GMT
Yeah, that’s how I saw the game. We won a match where we were the better team but on another day, if they’re shot where Bursik was well beaten hit the post and came out had hit the post and gone in we’d have been 2-1 down. It didn’t and we won, but we’ve beaten a Championship team where the standard isn’t great, not Man City in the cup. If I did half points I’d have given Fosu 8.5 and Campbell 6.5. That’s just nonsense tbf mate. Bursik’s kicking was poor at times but he made a crucial save, reacted well to the ball hitting the post and made some really decisive handling decisions from corners in the 2nd half. As for Campbell it was probably his best game since his injury, he put himself about, could easily have had a goal with a good effort on goal and twice put a goal on a plate for Delap. Sounds all bit more like preconceived opinions vs what actually happened! No, just my initial reaction to the game. Having watched the highlights in case I missed bits, I’ll concede that Campbell deserved a better score. Probably his best game since injury yes, though unfortunately that’s not saying a lot as he’s really struggled at times. Bursik’s kicking was poor nearly all the time, he caught balls that were crossed into his reach without him moving which I would expect, but there were times he could have come out to claim the ball (not off crosses but through balls) instead of forcing a defender to put the ball out for a throw. He made a good save in the first half but it was nothing special and as I said if it had gone in we’d all be going mad about positioning and timing. Admittedly my opinion of Bursik is that he’s not a very good keeper, maybe my expectations are a little too high and I understand he’s a young lad who can, and I really hope like we all do, will get much better. Keepers often mature well anyway. |
|
|
|
Post by boniek on Oct 8, 2022 19:45:14 GMT
Bursik 8
Wilmot 7
Jagielka 7
Fox 7
Sterling 7
Laurent 6
Smallbone 7
Baker 7
Fosu 8 Motm
Campbell 7
Gayle 6
—————————————————
Subs - too short playing time to rate. Great to see Delap score though!
|
|
|
|
Post by AlbertTatlock on Oct 8, 2022 19:57:05 GMT
Bursik 8 Sterling 8 Jagielka 8 Wilmot 8 Fox 8 Laurent 8 Smallbone 8 Baker 8 Campbell 8 Gayle 8 Fosu 9 MOM Delap 7 Clucas 7 Clarke 7 Gouranga.  |
|
|
|
Post by lordb on Oct 8, 2022 21:48:56 GMT
Seriously? The best performance since before we were relegated and you're giving out 5s and 6s? We played well today but come on,steady on. It was right up there I think Leeds at home under Jones and Albion at home last season were better Not a big list, especially at home, of good games is there? Amazed anyone has been giving out 5's and 6's |
|
|
|
Post by iglugluk on Oct 8, 2022 22:39:43 GMT
Bursik - Sublime save in 1st half, a couple of poor clearances and comedy, but generally with it and nice casually done shitehousing. 7 Sterling - Solid and looks a top player, defensively minded and has pace and power. 8 Wilmot - Another goal, unfussy performance and possibly formation helped limit his usual error prone self. 7 Jags - Class act. Steered the whole defence with calm authority and nice header for the goal. 9 Fox - Steady day today, some poor passing but improving. 6 Laurent - Could be the destroyer we’ve waited for. Some poor passes but pit in a shift. 7 Baker - Brilliant distribution and his pass to start the move for the 3rd goal was inspired. 7 Smallbone - very advanced role, better workrate and passing but not spectacular. 6 Fosu - A creative spark, everything he did was positive and Utd struggled to get him under control. Crucial goalline clearance. 9 Ty - Gradually getting back to his level, arrogance and control much better, workrate excellent for him. 8 Gayle - Selfless and efficient, led and linked well with Ty. 7 Delap - got a killer goal. Will this be the launch pad? 7 Clucas - Did his bit to keep pressure on defence. 7 Clarke - Like for like with Sterling 7 Thompson - Nice headgear. Campbell wasn’t an 8. Lazy for large spells. Great for the assist and great vision, so glad he didn’t shoot. Wilmot was better than Campbell. Great goal aided by a superb ball. Gayle was non-existent. Can’t argue with the rest. Good solid team performance and the effort was evident mostly. A bit harsh to call Ty lazy I reckon, he put himself around pretty well and his game is never going to be a Jacob Brown type approach.. nor should it be. |
|
|
|
Post by a on Oct 9, 2022 8:28:50 GMT
Campbell wasn’t an 8. Lazy for large spells. Great for the assist and great vision, so glad he didn’t shoot. Wilmot was better than Campbell. Great goal aided by a superb ball. Gayle was non-existent. Can’t argue with the rest. Good solid team performance and the effort was evident mostly. A bit harsh to call Ty lazy I reckon, he put himself around pretty well and his game is never going to be a Jacob Brown type approach.. nor should it be. There were spells where he let players past him and should’ve tracked, but he did track on a few occasions tbf, but I think he does sometimes go missing, but not a bad performance today. |
|
