|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Aug 31, 2022 21:00:20 GMT
Bonham 7, very good! Wilmot 7, good game. Taylor 3, looked shit scared today! Flint 6, decent. Fox 6, decent Baker 6, OK. Clucas 6, OK. Thompson 5, weakest of our central 3 for me tonight! Gayle 5, lacks that goal! Delap 6, too anonymous for long spells for me. Brown 6. tries hard and often so close. Fosu 7, really made an impact. Campbell 7, got us that important equalizer! Smallbone 7, good! Good substitutions from Neil!  |
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Aug 31, 2022 21:05:29 GMT
Bonham 7
Fox 5
Taylor 4
Flint 7
Wilmot 6
Thompson 6
Baker 6
Clucas 6
Brown 7
Delap 6
Gayle 6
Fosu 7
Smallbone 6
Campbell 7
A work in progress and with the injured players back I reckon it’ll be plenty of 7s and 8s.
|
|
|
|
Post by strettonstokie on Aug 31, 2022 21:06:59 GMT
bonham 7 did his job well tonight
Wilmot 8 Mon for me looked great in both positions
Taylor 2 worst player on the pitch and needs a loan, his lack of pace is so scary
flint 6 did his job
fox 6 also did his job
baker 6 decent enough
clucas 4 2nd worst player on the pitch needs dropping
thompson 5 some nice set pieces but overall offered not much
gayle 6 tried hard and made some decent runs should of done better with the header
delap 7 big and strong looked a handful yet again his first goal isnt far off
brown 5 was more a left mid and didnt do it much justice
subs
fosu 7 has to start on sunday with wilmot replacing taylor was a live wire
smallbone 7.5 looked comfortable and wanted to move the ball forward
campbell 7 should have got 2 but his strikers instinct gets us a point needs to start sunday
the team that finished the game minus clucas needs to start on sunday
|
|
|
|
Post by Bojan Mackey on Aug 31, 2022 21:07:24 GMT
Bonham 6 - Still scares the shit out of me but slightly less than Bursik
Wilmot 4 - Shite tonight, he’s really out of form, too slow at releasing the ball
Taylor 4 - Again shite tonight, Swansea had him on toast
Flint 5 - Really doesn’t fill me with confidence at all and has literally no pace whatsoever
Fox 6 - Steady showing but looked to be blowing out of his arse.
Thompson - 5, anonymous, can’t think of anything he did of note at all
Baker 6, not his best game but was still by far and away the most capable of our midfielders on display
Clucas 4 - If he can’t even be arsed to turn up for Swansea now what is the point of keeping him here, fuck him off
Gayle 5 - Tried but didn’t really get anywhere, must bemoan the lack of urgency we have currently
Delap 6 - Worked his arse off but again he must wonder if he’s on his own up there sometimes, absolutely no support whatsoever.
Brown 5 - Anonymous today
Subs:
Smallbone 6, Busy and played some nice passes
Fosu 5 - He’s not a right back and every man in the stadium except Ben Wilmot could see him stood wide open wanting the ball
Campbell 7 - Extra mark for the goal and actually looking rapid again.
That was as bad as any of the shite we put out under O’Neill but at least a point was salvaged.
|
|
|
|
Post by stoke111 on Aug 31, 2022 21:11:44 GMT
Bonham 8
Wilmot 7
Taylor 4
Flint 6
Fox 5
Thompson 4
Clucas 5
Baker 6
Gayle 6
Delap 6
Brown 5
|
|
|
|
Post by fortressbritannia on Aug 31, 2022 21:15:27 GMT
Bonham 7.5 made 2 really smart saves to keep us in the game.
Wilmott 7 he had a really solid game both at rb and cb
Taylor 5 looked a bit shakey defensively but did help drive us forward at times
Flint 6 solid but unspectacular the assist for Campbell probably saved him from a lower score
Fox 4 was shocking at LB and Swansea targeted him massively first half. Looked slightly better in a 3.
Baker 5 poor game for him but looked like he was told to hold position in from of the back 4 which isn't his game
Thompson 4 didn't really do a lot but should have been the one sitting rather then Baker
Clucas 5.5 pretty anonymous but helped drive us on in the last 15 mins.
Gayle 5 clearly not used in his best position
Delap 6 showed some brief moments to of quality and was a physical presence upfront which was handy.
Brown 7 great effort today. Looked.like our main threat for most of the match
Subs:
Smallbone 6 didn't do much but supported Fosu down the right well.
Fosu 7 dnagerous in his cameo really helped put the pressure on Swansea
Campbell 7 took his chance well probably should have scored before though
|
|
|
|
Post by chayseeoatcake on Aug 31, 2022 21:34:36 GMT
Bonham 7
Fox 5
Taylor 5
Flint 7
Wilmot 6
Thompson 5
Baker 6
Clucas 6
Brown 6
Delap 6
Gayle 5
Fosu 7
Smallbone 6
Campbell 7
|
|
|
|
Post by boskampsflaps on Aug 31, 2022 21:37:38 GMT
Bonham 6
Fox 6
Taylor 4
Flint 7
Wilmot 6
Thompson 6
Baker 5 ( feels generous)
Clucas 5
Brown 6
Delap 7
Gayle 5
Fosu 7
Smallbone 6
Campbell 7
|
|
|
|
Post by Timmy on Aug 31, 2022 21:47:05 GMT
Bonham 7
Fox 5
Taylor 4
Flint 7
Wilmot 6
Thompson 5
Baker 6 (sitting in cdm for most of the game)
Clucas 5
Brown 6
Delap 7
Gayle 5
Fosu 7
Smallbone 6
Campbell 7
Neil will have learnt a lot from that game tonight. Midfield needs sorting, we had two players who couldn't get on the ball at all. Smallbone when he came on was looking to get onto it and improved our side.
Removing Taylor from his inevitable sending off and moving wilmott inside was a masterclass. Fosu gave us a massive outlet on that side which made us more balanced.
Campbell and Delap linked up well and hopefully will be starting on Sunday.
|
|
|
|
Post by cobhamstokey on Aug 31, 2022 21:54:17 GMT
Bonham 7.5
Fox 6
Taylor 4
Flint 6
Wilmot 7
Thompson 5
Baker 6
Clucas 4
Brown 5
Delap 6
Gayle 6
Fosu 7
Smallbone 7
Campbell 7
|
|
|
|
Post by chuckrocky on Aug 31, 2022 21:57:14 GMT
Bonham 7 - Did the routine stuff well
Wilmot 7 - Got forward well and defended well
Taylor 3 - Had a shocker
Flint 7 - Won everything in both boxes but missed a sitter
Fox 4 - All over the place first half, improved slightly second half
Thompson 5 - Pretty anonymous
Baker 6 - Struggled to make an impact
Clucas 4 - Woeful
Gayle 5 - Has to score the early chance, not much else
Delap 6 - No service, made some decent runs
Brown 5 - Got in some great positions but atrocious quality
Fosu 7 - Great impact
Smallbone 7 - Got on the ball and made thing happen
Campbell 7 - Looked sharp
|
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Aug 31, 2022 22:02:28 GMT
Whilst I rated Fox badly, I think we may be being quite harsh. I noticed on many occasions in the first half Wilmot was playing more like a wing back, very high up the pitch and so the remaining three defenders would shuffle along to the right. This left more space down the left for them to exploit.
|
|
|
|
Post by crouchpotato1 on Aug 31, 2022 22:22:07 GMT
Bonham 7
Wilmot 7
Taylor 4 dreadful tonight sadly
Flint 8 my MOTM
Fox 6
Baker 6
Clucas 6
Thompson 5
Brown 7
Delap 6
Gayle 6
Smallbone 6
Fosu 6
Campbell 7
|
|
|
|
Post by leesandfordstoupe on Aug 31, 2022 22:25:37 GMT
Whilst I rated Fox badly, I think we may be being quite harsh. I noticed on many occasions in the first half Wilmot was playing more like a wing back, very high up the pitch and so the remaining three defenders would shuffle along to the right. This left more space down the left for them to exploit. Found that tactic confusing along with quite a lot of what we were doing. Brown on the Left haven’t we been here before. I always thought decent teams control the centre of the pitch not vacate it. Bonham 6.5 Wilmot 7 Flint 7 Taylor 4 Fox 5 Baker 6 Thompson 5 Clucas 5 Gayle 5 Delap 6 Brown 5 Fosu 6 Smallbone 6 Campbell 7 Neil 6.5 Slightly more going on than a MON performance but it didn’t seem any more coherent. Hopefully more time and players coming back will see something much better. |
|
|
|
Post by CBUFAWKIPWH on Aug 31, 2022 22:33:10 GMT
Whilst I rated Fox badly, I think we may be being quite harsh. I noticed on many occasions in the first half Wilmot was playing more like a wing back, very high up the pitch and so the remaining three defenders would shuffle along to the right. This left more space down the left for them to exploit. That's how I saw it - when we had the ball we went 3 at the back and when we lost the ball we went 4 at the back. Fox was playing LCB/LB and Wilmott RWB/RB. I thought both of them did pretty well in the circumstances - hardly conventíonal roles. |
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Aug 31, 2022 22:58:13 GMT
Bonham 7
Wilmot 7
Taylor 4
Flint 7
Fox 6
Baker 6
Clucas 5
Thompson 6
Gayle 6
Delap 6
Brown 7
Fosu 6
Campbell 7
Smallbone 6
Referee 2
|
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Aug 31, 2022 23:00:27 GMT
bonham 7 did his job well tonight Wilmot 8 Mon for me looked great in both positions Taylor 2 worst player on the pitch and needs a loan, his lack of pace is so scary flint 6 did his job fox 6 also did his job baker 6 decent enough clucas 4 2nd worst player on the pitch needs dropping thompson 5 some nice set pieces but overall offered not much gayle 6 tried hard and made some decent runs should of done better with the header delap 7 big and strong looked a handful yet again his first goal isnt far off brown 5 was more a left mid and didnt do it much justice subs fosu 7 has to start on sunday with wilmot replacing taylor was a live wire smallbone 7.5 looked comfortable and wanted to move the ball forward campbell 7 should have got 2 but his strikers instinct gets us a point needs to start sunday the team that finished the game minus clucas needs to start on sunday If we start without Clucas, we will only have 10 on the pitch. |
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Aug 31, 2022 23:40:53 GMT
Bonham 6
Wilmott 7
Taylor 5
Flint 8
Fox 6
Baker 6
Clucas 5
Thompson 5
Gayle 5
Delap 5
Brown 7
Smallbone 6
Campbell 7
Fosu 7
|
|
|
|
Post by J-Roar on Sept 1, 2022 0:09:47 GMT
I'd have hooked Connor Taylor at half time. He was being targeted and was having a nightmare. It didn't get much better in the second.
Think he's been watched and noted that his first touch can be clumsy and that gets worse when he's pressed.
|
|
|
|
Post by terrorofturfmoor on Sept 1, 2022 0:21:01 GMT
Bonham - 7, made some important saves that kept us in it (I feel disappointed having to say that).
Wilmot - 7, had a good game, steady in both positions.
Taylor - 4, don't want to be hard on the lad as he's still young and learning, but he had a stinker tonight, everything he touched just didn't come off.
Flint - 7, started a bit shaky, but grew into the game, finished it as my MotM, special mention for Campbell's assist 😏.
Fox - 6, looked very uncomfortable against their man on the right in the first half, but got a bit more to grips with him in the second.
Baker - 6, best of the midfield 3, but totally wasted for a player of his ability as a holding midfielder.
Clucas - 6, don't want to be to hard on him as he seemed to WANT to put the effort in, whether it's because it's Swansea or not, I don't know....but he plays so far out of the middle, he may as well play on the left wing.... There were acres and acres of space in that centre circle left by Clucas and Thompson all night.
Thompson - 6, similar to Clucas as he also left acres of space for the opposition in that centre circle area. Personally, I thought he was hung out to dry a little playing him on the inside RIGHT of midfield when he's only left footed.... I think he should have been the holding midfielder, and Baker in Tommo's position myself.
Gayle - 6, gotta feel sorry for Gayle being played out on the right, he's a box player, playing off a target man, and he's proved it by banging goals in in the championship before.
Delap - 6, we can see what a good player he is, and what he's capable of doing, like Gayle, he needs a goal.
Brown - 6, not his kind of game tonight playing out on the left, however, he still did what he does best, and worked his knackers off..... His first touch doesn't half let him down sometimes.
Subs...
Fosu - 6, looked lively down that right hand side.
Smallbone - 6, did well when he came on
Campbell - 7, finally, someone in the right place at the right time, only took nigh on 90 minutes for someone to do it.
|
|
|
|
Post by maine on Sept 1, 2022 1:55:48 GMT
Bonham 7
Wilmot 7
Taylor 5
Flint 6
Fox 6
Baker 7
Clucas 6
Thompson 5
Gayle 7
Delap 6
Brown 8
Fosu 7
Campbell 7
Smallbone 7
Allen 9
|
|
|
|
Post by strettonstokie on Sept 1, 2022 11:42:56 GMT
bonham 7 did his job well tonight Wilmot 8 Mon for me looked great in both positions Taylor 2 worst player on the pitch and needs a loan, his lack of pace is so scary flint 6 did his job fox 6 also did his job baker 6 decent enough clucas 4 2nd worst player on the pitch needs dropping thompson 5 some nice set pieces but overall offered not much gayle 6 tried hard and made some decent runs should of done better with the header delap 7 big and strong looked a handful yet again his first goal isnt far off brown 5 was more a left mid and didnt do it much justice subs fosu 7 has to start on sunday with wilmot replacing taylor was a live wire smallbone 7.5 looked comfortable and wanted to move the ball forward campbell 7 should have got 2 but his strikers instinct gets us a point needs to start sunday the team that finished the game minus clucas needs to start on sunday If we start without Clucas, we will only have 10 on the pitch. I would probably take that to be honest |
|
|
|
Post by jontimmis on Sept 1, 2022 11:50:30 GMT
The first goal was Taylor’s fault, he never gets anywhere near him, really really poor. The guy is always a yard or two in front and the right side for the goal. That goal is so avoidable, he gets touch tight and get in front he doesn’t score it’s that simple.
He never anticipated the ball coming in and only 5 mins into the game he already looked out of puff.
|
|
|
|
Post by wakefieldstokie on Sept 1, 2022 11:58:09 GMT
Bonham 7
Fox 6
Taylor 3.5 (looked completely out of place last night)
Flint 7
Wilmot 7.5
Thompson 4 (I just dont get what he offers - 'beige' qualities with no notable area of skill)
Baker 6
Clucas 6
Brown 7
Delap 7
Gayle 6
Fosu 7
Smallbone 7
Campbell 7
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 1, 2022 12:45:04 GMT
Bonham 6
Fox 6
Taylor 4.5
Flint 7
Wilmot 6.5
Thompson 5
Baker 6
Clucas 5 (6 after the subs. Seemed to be more involved with the movement of Campbell, and found more space as the opposition were drawn more to our right and Fosu.)
Brown 6.5
Delap 6.5
Gayle 6
Fosu 7
Smallbone 7
Campbell 7
|
|
