|
Post by robwahlmann on Apr 6, 2019 17:17:35 GMT
Butland 7, apart from some awful kicking very good.
Edwards 7, solid again. Batth 8, he is a rock! Shawcross 8, very solid again. Indi 7, another solid performance.
Allen 8, MOM, was everywhere. Etebo 7.5, good again, fantastic goal, but lost too many balls when going forward for my liking today. Ince 7, again our most creative player. McClean 5. Tries so hard, but can't find a Stoke player with a single cross. Bojan 6, good first half up to that missed penalty, but disappeared after that. Rightly subbed as well.
Afobe 6, better today, but I'm still to be convinced he is the right player for us.
Clucas 5.5, did OK, but nothing exceptional. Williams 6, the defence was all over the place for a short period after Ryan went off, but Williams improved as the game went on. Vokes 6.5, we really needed someone to keep the ball up and Vokes did that. Went so close to score, only prevented by a wondersave.
|
|
|
Post by FullerMagic on Apr 6, 2019 17:18:36 GMT
What would it take for you give Ince less than a 7, Rob?
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Apr 6, 2019 17:40:46 GMT
What would it take for you give Ince less than a 7, Rob? A bad game?
|
|
|
Post by Robo10 on Apr 6, 2019 17:47:20 GMT
Rob you talk some shite!
Butland - 6 kicking was poor all day
Edwards - 8 good game. Baath - 8 dominant Shawcross - 7.5 solid BMI - 6.5 weak link at the back
Allen - 8 super Etobe - 7.5 great goal, sometimes holds on to the ball too long Bojan - 7.5 good 1st half, obvs had a knock from the shit being kicked out of him
Ince - 5 poor. One good cross, too slow Afobe - 6 another not great, too deep McClean - 5 poor...
Subs: Clucas - 6 ran lot Williams - 7 was solid Vokes - 6 didnt offer a lot bar a fantastic header that produced an amazing save
Thought NJ (7) missed a trick with subs to put Verlinden on for Ince and finish the game off
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 6, 2019 17:51:20 GMT
I thought McClean, Afobe and Clucas offered nothing.
Verlinden needs to get a run of consecutive games ahead of McClean.
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Apr 6, 2019 17:58:57 GMT
Rob you talk some shite! Butland - 6 kicking was poor all day Edwards - 8 good game. Baath - 8 dominant Shawcross - 7.5 solid BMI - 6.5 weak link at the back Allen - 8 super Etobe - 7.5 great goal, sometimes holds on to the ball too long Bojan - 7.5 good 1st half, obvs had a knock from the shit being kicked out of him Ince - 5 poor. One good cross, too slow Afobe - 6 another not great, too deep McClean - 5 poor... Subs: Clucas - 6 ran lot Williams - 7 was solid Vokes - 6 didnt offer a lot bar a fantastic header that produced an amazing save Thought NJ (7) missed a trick with subs to put Verlinden on for Ince and finish the game off I'll just quote Nathan Jones who said after the game that Tom Ince is in wonderful form at the moment. I guess you think he talks shite as well then as his words seem to be very close to my assessment.
|
|
|
Post by thehoof on Apr 6, 2019 18:00:39 GMT
Butland 7, apart from some awful kicking very good. Edwards 7, solid again. Batth 8, he is a rock! Shawcross 8, very solid again. Indi 7, another solid performance. Allen 8, MOM, was everywhere. Etebo 7.5, good again, fantastic goal, but lost too many balls when going forward for my liking today. Ince 7, again our most creative player. McClean 5. Tries so hard, but can't find a Stoke player with a single cross. Bojan 6, good first half up to that missed penalty, but disappeared after that. Rightly subbed as well. Afobe 6, better today, but I'm still to be convinced he is the right player for us. Clucas 5.5, did OK, but nothing exceptional. Williams 6, the defence was all over the place for a short period after Ryan went off, but Williams improved as the game went on. Vokes 6.5, we really needed someone to keep the ball up and Vokes did that. Went so close to score, only prevented by a wondersave. Agree with most of this Rob, but Ince was on the pitch for what 35 minutes? I don’t see how this makes him our most creative player? I’d have rated him and Bojan the same, other than that the marks are pretty fair.
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Apr 6, 2019 18:05:46 GMT
Butland 7, apart from some awful kicking very good. Edwards 7, solid again. Batth 8, he is a rock! Shawcross 8, very solid again. Indi 7, another solid performance. Allen 8, MOM, was everywhere. Etebo 7.5, good again, fantastic goal, but lost too many balls when going forward for my liking today. Ince 7, again our most creative player. McClean 5. Tries so hard, but can't find a Stoke player with a single cross. Bojan 6, good first half up to that missed penalty, but disappeared after that. Rightly subbed as well. Afobe 6, better today, but I'm still to be convinced he is the right player for us. Clucas 5.5, did OK, but nothing exceptional. Williams 6, the defence was all over the place for a short period after Ryan went off, but Williams improved as the game went on. Vokes 6.5, we really needed someone to keep the ball up and Vokes did that. Went so close to score, only prevented by a wondersave. Agree with most of this Rob, but Ince was on the pitch for what 35 minutes? I don’t see how this makes him our most creative player? I’d have rated him and Bojan the same, other than that the marks are pretty fair. Our best attacking 35 minutes of the game.
|
|
|
Post by Robo10 on Apr 6, 2019 18:09:15 GMT
Apart from the first 10 where they should have scored :-)
NJ isnt going to say Ince or McClean are shit, or Afobe, but we all have eyes!
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Apr 6, 2019 18:10:46 GMT
Butland 7, apart from some awful kicking very good. Edwards 7, solid again. Batth 8, he is a rock! Shawcross 8, very solid again. Indi 7, another solid performance. Allen 8, MOM, was everywhere. Etebo 7.5, good again, fantastic goal, but lost too many balls when going forward for my liking today. Ince 7, again our most creative player. McClean 5. Tries so hard, but can't find a Stoke player with a single cross. Bojan 6, good first half up to that missed penalty, but disappeared after that. Rightly subbed as well. Afobe 6, better today, but I'm still to be convinced he is the right player for us. Clucas 5.5, did OK, but nothing exceptional. Williams 6, the defence was all over the place for a short period after Ryan went off, but Williams improved as the game went on. Vokes 6.5, we really needed someone to keep the ball up and Vokes did that. Went so close to score, only prevented by a wondersave. I'm baffled by these marks......our midfield was awful for the second half hence why our defenders had to bail them out, so how come Allen and Etebo get such high marks? They were very good 1st half but they went completely awol second half and couldn't keep possession
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Apr 6, 2019 18:17:26 GMT
Butland 7, apart from some awful kicking very good. Edwards 7, solid again. Batth 8, he is a rock! Shawcross 8, very solid again. Indi 7, another solid performance. Allen 8, MOM, was everywhere. Etebo 7.5, good again, fantastic goal, but lost too many balls when going forward for my liking today. Ince 7, again our most creative player. McClean 5. Tries so hard, but can't find a Stoke player with a single cross. Bojan 6, good first half up to that missed penalty, but disappeared after that. Rightly subbed as well. Afobe 6, better today, but I'm still to be convinced he is the right player for us. Clucas 5.5, did OK, but nothing exceptional. Williams 6, the defence was all over the place for a short period after Ryan went off, but Williams improved as the game went on. Vokes 6.5, we really needed someone to keep the ball up and Vokes did that. Went so close to score, only prevented by a wondersave. I'm baffled by these marks......our midfield was awful for the second half hence why our defenders had to bail them out, so how come Allen and Etebo get such high marks? They were very good 1st half but they went completely awol second half and couldn't keep possession I really thought Allen was awesome the whole game, but I've given Etebo less points despite winning the game for us. This is my opinion anyway.
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Apr 6, 2019 19:25:14 GMT
JB - 8 another clean sheet
Edwards 8 - solid enough and should be taking penalties, one of only 2 players (with Etebo) we have who can hit a footballer properly Indi 8 - good defensive display Baath 9 - superb Shawcross 8 - doing well until injured
Allen 6 - v.good first half, went missing the second half when our midfield was overrun, was wasteful with possession and got knocked off the ball too easily by wanting too long on the ball. Etebo 7 - extra mark for a great goal, but was poor second half when I thought when he disappeared Ince 6 - when he went off all our creative outlets disappeared, we miss him when he is not playing, that is the problem. he still looks our most dangerous player McClean 5 - alot of effort but needs to be able to look up when he has possession, his first touch is poor, as well as his 2nd and 3rd one if he keeps it long enough
Bojan 6 - thought our midfield deteriorated when he went off because he gives them passing options by dropping deep and his movement is good. Afobe - 6 gets knocked off the ball too easily, great cross for Vokes header
Clucas 5 - I think he's a nothing player tbh Vokes 6 - good header but that was about it, didnt help much but no service from midfield Williams 8 - i thought he held us together when he came on.
|
|
|
Post by spongebobflathead on Apr 6, 2019 19:56:00 GMT
The marks are a little high for etebo and bojan imo, they both gave the ball away (uncharacteristically) far too much today !
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Apr 6, 2019 19:59:02 GMT
Apart from the first 10 where they should have scored :-) NJ isnt going to say Ince or McClean are shit, or Afobe, but we all have eyes! Are you 100% certain about that "eye thing"?
|
|
|
Post by thehoof on Apr 6, 2019 20:01:49 GMT
Agree with most of this Rob, but Ince was on the pitch for what 35 minutes? I don’t see how this makes him our most creative player? I’d have rated him and Bojan the same, other than that the marks are pretty fair. Our best attacking 35 minutes of the game. Again, probably right- you are not related to Tom are you?😉
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Apr 6, 2019 20:30:44 GMT
Our best attacking 35 minutes of the game. Again, probably right- you are not related to Tom are you?😉 No, not as I know. Any Norwegian blood in young Tom?
|
|
|
Post by maine on Apr 7, 2019 2:23:23 GMT
Butland -= 7
Edwards - 8 Baath - 7.5 Shawcross - 7.5 BMI - 8
Allen - 8 Etobe - 7.5 Bojan - 7.5
Ince - 6 Afobe - 6 McClean - 6
Subs: Clucas - 4 Williams - 7.5 Vokes - 7
|
|
|
Post by shrewspotter on Apr 7, 2019 6:55:30 GMT
Butland 6 Edwards 7 Batth 8 Shawcross 7 Martins-Indi 7
Allen 7 Etebo 7 Bojan 7
McClean 6 Afobe 6 Ince 8
Clucas 7 Williams 8 Vokes 7
I don't think McClean was all that bad, he ran a lot, harried and chased down, but his crossing was white
Batth was excellent as was Williams when he came on
|
|