|
Post by robwahlmann on Mar 2, 2019 17:37:19 GMT
Butland 7, didn't have much to do actually.
Edwards 7, OK game, but nothing extraordinary. Shawcross, 8 very solid this afternoon. Batth 8.5, rock solid again! Indi 7.5, very solid, but limited going forward.
Ince 8.5, MOM in my opinion. Also a very good defensive contribution. Etebo 8.5, very good again! Allen 8, worked his socks off! Clucas 7.5, very solid display.
Bojan 6, our most anonymous player. Afobe 7.5, scored a very good goal and worked harder than in a long time.
Adam 7.5, very decent after coming on. McClean 6.5, worked hard without creating much.
|
|
|
Post by mickey4137 on Mar 2, 2019 17:43:29 GMT
Butland 7 Edwards 8 Shawcross 8 Batth 8 Indi 7 Ince 7 Etebo 9 Allen 8, Clucas 7 Bojan 6 Afobe 8
Adam 7 McClean 7
|
|
|
Post by terryconroysmagic on Mar 2, 2019 17:45:38 GMT
Butland 8 Edwards 7 Shawcross 7 Batth 8 Indi 8 Ince 7 Etebo 7 Allen 9 Clucas 7 Bojan 6 Afobe 8
Adam 7 McClean 7
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 17:46:41 GMT
Butland 7
Edwards 7 Shawcross 7 Batth 8 BMI 8
Ince 7 Etebo 9 Allen 8.5 Clucas 6 Bojan 6
Afobe 8
Adam 6 McClean 6
|
|
|
Post by maninasuitcase on Mar 2, 2019 17:52:34 GMT
Butland 7 steady Edwards 8 way better than against villa. Shawcross 7 Solid return Batth 7 good Indi 7 good Ince 6 gash until the last quarter of the game. Etebo 8 great goal and was my mom until his injury. Allen 8 took the mom of Etebo Clucas 6 no great shakes. Bojan 6 some glimpses of magic Afobe 7 bloody great finish.
Adam 6 good impact sub McClean 5 nothing special this time.
|
|
|
Post by humbersidepotter on Mar 2, 2019 17:58:55 GMT
Butland 7.5 2 or 3 good saves otherwise it was a quiet day
Edwards 7 turned up today, I was impressed even though I've been a big critic Shawcross 8 looked great, so much better when playing alongside somebody who has good positioning Batth 8 classy performance BMI 7, drifts inside too much - very solid and won the ball well though
Ince 6.5 did well for the assist, but gives the ball away cheaply and goes missing Etebo 8 did alright today, again poor decision making but took his goal well Allen 6 ran around... Clucas 6 - worked hard didn't do much Bojan 5.5 Massive fan of his but wasn't ever really in the game
Afobe 8.5 MOM
Adam 7 corner delivery was excellent and mixed it in the middle nice McClean 5 meh.
|
|
|
Post by camstoke10 on Mar 2, 2019 17:59:28 GMT
Disagree with these ratings, thought indi was the best out of the back 4, and thought clucas was the worst player ok the pitch, and thought afobe was fantastic, also thought jimmy Mac did decent when he cane on, and Adam didn’t really offer much.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 18:35:40 GMT
Butland 7, didn't have much to do actually. Edwards 7, OK game, but nothing extraordinary. Shawcross, 8 very solid this afternoon. Batth 8.5, rock solid again! Indi 7.5, very solid, but limited going forward. Ince 8.5, MOM in my opinion. Also a very good defensive contribution. Etebo 8.5, very good again! Allen 8, worked his socks off! Clucas 7.5, very solid display. Bojan 6, our most anonymous player. Afobe 7.5, scored a very good goal and worked harder than in a long time. Adam 7.5, very decent after coming on. McClean 6.5, worked hard without creating much. Ince assisted both goals.
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Mar 2, 2019 18:35:45 GMT
Cannot believe the high marks for Allen.
What did he do apart from run around a bit and play the ball backwards?
did he play one ball forwards?...ok maybe 1 then!!!
JB - 7 .....fine TE - 6 .....wish he could pass BMI - 6...thought the was ok but could have been better in possession RS - 7 .....looked on it DB - 6 ok but some useless punts from the back JA - 6 ....has he ever heard of passing a football forward? TI - 6 ...decided to turn up for the last 15 minutes to show us his glimpses...he's got talent when he feels like it. BK - 6 ...started ok but faded and lost confidence SC - 6 started well but faded then improved in the last 15 PE- 7.5...our best player by a mile....actually tries to go forward and great goal BA - 6 great finish for the goal, but not great at holding the ball generally
CA - 7.... looked decent when he came on JM - 6.....like his energy but can't match it with skill or technique
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 18:37:09 GMT
Disagree with these ratings, thought indi was the best out of the back 4, and thought clucas was the worst player ok the pitch, and thought afobe was fantastic, also thought jimmy Mac did decent when he cane on, and Adam didn’t really offer much. Thought Indi was a bit fortunate at times not to get booked today but played well generally. Batth and Shawcross very solid.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 18:38:46 GMT
Butland 7, didn't have much to do actually. Edwards 7, OK game, but nothing extraordinary. Shawcross, 8 very solid this afternoon. Batth 8.5, rock solid again! Indi 7.5, very solid, but limited going forward. Ince 8.5, MOM in my opinion. Also a very good defensive contribution. Etebo 8.5, very good again! Allen 8, worked his socks off! Clucas 7.5, very solid display. Bojan 6, our most anonymous player. Afobe 7.5, scored a very good goal and worked harder than in a long time. Adam 7.5, very decent after coming on. McClean 6.5, worked hard without creating much. Ince assisted both goals. But that doesn’t mean he played well throughout. Poor at times, good at times. 6 for me.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 18:39:06 GMT
Butland 7. Nowt to do
Edwards 7. Solid performance Shawcross 7 - Solid performance Baath 8 - Excellent. BMI 7 - Solid performance against an in form player in Lolley
Etebo 7 Good goal. Allen 6 Poor and not up to his usual standard Clucas 7 - Poor up until the Bojan sub, then improved late on.
Ince 7 Poor until the Bojan sub then sprang to life. Belting through ball for Afobe's goal
Bojan 6 Out of position and off the pace.
Afobe 8 Held the ball up well, intelligent movement in behind. Worked really hard. Where have you been all season?
|
|
|
Post by The Toxic Avenger on Mar 2, 2019 18:40:38 GMT
Butland 7.5 2 or 3 good saves otherwise it was a quiet day Edwards 7 turned up today, I was impressed even though I've been a big critic Shawcross 8 looked great, so much better when playing alongside somebody who has good positioning Batth 8 classy performance BMI 7, drifts inside too much - very solid and won the ball well though Ince 6.5 did well for the assist, but gives the ball away cheaply and goes missing Etebo 8 did alright today, again poor decision making but took his goal well Allen 6 ran around... Clucas 6 - worked hard didn't do much Bojan 5.5 Massive fan of his but wasn't ever really in the game Afobe 8.5 MOM Adam 7 corner delivery was excellent and mixed it in the middle nice McClean 5 meh. Way too harsh on Allen. Actually he didn’t do a lot of ‘running around’ today, he was disciplined and sat in. It was much more like his Wales performances, with a bit of the metronome of his Swansea days thrown in. Top of the shop by miles for passes completed, won more tackles than anyone else, recovered the ball more than anyone else. His best game for ages.
|
|
|
Post by The Toxic Avenger on Mar 2, 2019 18:41:29 GMT
Clucas had a decent game in terms of closing down and leading the press I thought.
|
|
|
Post by terrorofturfmoor on Mar 2, 2019 18:42:30 GMT
Butland 7 steady Edwards 8 way better than against villa. Shawcross 7 Solid return Batth 7 good Indi 7 good Ince 6 gash until the last quarter of the game. Etebo 8 great goal and was my mom until his injury. Allen 8 took the mom of Etebo Clucas 6 no great shakes. Bojan 6 some glimpses of magic Afobe 7 bloody great finish. Adam 6 good impact sub McClean 5 nothing special this time. That's how I saw it suity....practically word for word!!! Especially the Ince bit!!!
|
|
|
Post by henry on Mar 2, 2019 18:48:24 GMT
Cannot believe the high marks for Allen.
What did he do apart from run around a bit and play the ball backwards?did he play one ball forwards?...ok maybe 1 then!!! JB - 7 .....fine TE - 6 .....wish he could pass BMI - 6...thought the was ok but could have been better in possession RS - 7 .....looked on it DB - 6 ok but some useless punts from the back JA - 6 ....has he ever heard of passing a football forward? TI - 6 ...decided to turn up for the last 15 minutes to show us his glimpses...he's got talent when he feels like it. BK - 6 ...started ok but faded and lost confidence SC - 6 started well but faded then improved in the last 15 PE- 7.5...our best player by a mile....actually tries to go forward and great goal BA - 6 great finish for the goal, but not great at holding the ball generally CA - 7.... looked decent when he came on JM - 6.....like his energy but can't match it with skill or technique Fuck me drunk, i must have been to a different game Allen and Etebo gave monster performances today
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Mar 2, 2019 18:49:49 GMT
Butland 7 steady Edwards 8 way better than against villa. Shawcross 7 Solid return Batth 7 good Indi 7 good Ince 6 gash until the last quarter of the game. Etebo 8 great goal and was my mom until his injury. Allen 8 took the mom of Etebo Clucas 6 no great shakes. Bojan 6 some glimpses of magic Afobe 7 bloody great finish. Adam 6 good impact sub McClean 5 nothing special this time. That's how I saw it suity....practically word for word!!! Especially the Ince bit!!! 6 for Ince today is ridiculous in my opinion!
|
|
|
Post by crouchpotato1 on Mar 2, 2019 18:53:38 GMT
Butland 7. Nowt to do
Edwards 7. Solid performance Shawcross 7 - Solid performance Baath 8 - Excellent. BMI 7 - Solid performance against an in form player in Lolley
Etebo 7 Good goal. Allen 6 Poor and not up to his usual standard Clucas 7 - Poor up until the Bojan sub, then improved late on.
Ince 7 Poor until the Bojan sub then sprang to life. Belting through ball for Afobe's goal
Bojan 6 Out of position and off the pace.
Afobe 8 Held the ball up well, intelligent movement in behind. Worked really hard. Where have you been all season?
Joe Allen🤔He was MOTM for me by a distance,all about opinions I suppose
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 18:53:45 GMT
Ince assisted both goals. But that doesn’t mean he played well throughout. Poor at times, good at times. 6 for me. Instrumental in the win though?
|
|
|
Post by nonameface on Mar 2, 2019 18:54:04 GMT
Butland 7 Edwards 7 Shawcross 7 Batth 8 BMI 7 Clucas 7 Allen 6 Etebo 8 Bojan 5 Ince 8 Afobe 7 Mclean 7 Adam 6
|
|
|
Post by maninasuitcase on Mar 2, 2019 18:54:06 GMT
That's how I saw it suity....practically word for word!!! Especially the Ince bit!!! 6 for Ince today is ridiculous in my opinion! I initially put him as a 5 but his cameo at the end got him an extra point.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 18:54:36 GMT
That's how I saw it suity....practically word for word!!! Especially the Ince bit!!! 6 for Ince today is ridiculous in my opinion! In mine too. Second half he was fantastic.
|
|
|
Post by stokesaint1 on Mar 2, 2019 19:14:11 GMT
6 for Ince today is ridiculous in my opinion! In mine too. Second half he was fantastic. But first half he was bloody awful. I would not have been surprised to see both Ince and Bojan subbed off at half time. However to his credit, last 30 minutes he looked a real footballer. More of the same for 90 minutes please.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 19:16:44 GMT
But that doesn’t mean he played well throughout. Poor at times, good at times. 6 for me. Instrumental in the win though? Agreed, but poor for long spells. It’s a difficult one isn’t it. If he was poor for 80 mins each week but we had two assists and we win, would you take it? I suspect most, including myself, would.
|
|
|
Post by lawrieleslie on Mar 2, 2019 19:18:13 GMT
Thought Bungy Edwards had a very good game and unlucky not to be given MoTM Award.
|
|
|
Post by terrorofturfmoor on Mar 2, 2019 19:22:14 GMT
That's how I saw it suity....practically word for word!!! Especially the Ince bit!!! 6 for Ince today is ridiculous in my opinion! Yeah, and that's fine...... It just wasn't rediculous in ours!!! People see things differently, personally I don't think he was worthy of anything higher than a 6, but that's my opinion!!!
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Mar 2, 2019 19:23:54 GMT
6 for Ince today is ridiculous in my opinion! Yeah, and that's fine...... It just wasn't rediculous in ours!!! People see things differently, personally I don't think he was worthy of anything higher than a 6, but that's my opinion!!! Which you are entitled to, but my God how differently people can see a game!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2019 19:26:00 GMT
Butland 7 steady Edwards 8 way better than against villa. Shawcross 7 Solid return Batth 7 good Indi 7 good Ince 6 gash until the last quarter of the game. Etebo 8 great goal and was my mom until his injury. Allen 8 took the mom of Etebo Clucas 6 no great shakes. Bojan 6 some glimpses of magic Afobe 7 bloody great finish. Adam 6 good impact sub McClean 5 nothing special this time. Nailed it.
|
|
|
Post by terrorofturfmoor on Mar 2, 2019 19:28:34 GMT
Yeah, and that's fine...... It just wasn't rediculous in ours!!! People see things differently, personally I don't think he was worthy of anything higher than a 6, but that's my opinion!!! Which you are entitled to, but my God how differently people can see a game! Weird innit!!!
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Mar 2, 2019 19:31:22 GMT
Cannot believe the high marks for Allen.
What did he do apart from run around a bit and play the ball backwards?did he play one ball forwards?...ok maybe 1 then!!! JB - 7 .....fine TE - 6 .....wish he could pass BMI - 6...thought the was ok but could have been better in possession RS - 7 .....looked on it DB - 6 ok but some useless punts from the back JA - 6 ....has he ever heard of passing a football forward? TI - 6 ...decided to turn up for the last 15 minutes to show us his glimpses...he's got talent when he feels like it. BK - 6 ...started ok but faded and lost confidence SC - 6 started well but faded then improved in the last 15 PE- 7.5...our best player by a mile....actually tries to go forward and great goal BA - 6 great finish for the goal, but not great at holding the ball generally CA - 7.... looked decent when he came on JM - 6.....like his energy but can't match it with skill or technique Fuck me drunk, i must have been to a different game Allen and Etebo gave monster performances today I just find that our game grinds to a halt when he gets the ball as he has got no confidence to move the ball forwards , it's always sideways or backwards, he doesn't look to link with players going forward. He was better today in that he didn't get knocked off the ball as easily as he usually does. Defensively he was fine today. But no link up play going forward, no creativity doesn't help our cause offensively. Etebo tries to move forward though that doesn't seem his natural game, but at least tries. Our game changed for the better when Adam came on. It was a good win, but a very poor game, 2 poor teams imho.
|
|