|
Post by robwahlmann on Jan 19, 2019 17:30:09 GMT
Butland 8 (one fantastic save in the second half that won us the game in the end) Bauer 8.5 (how we have missed such a quality right back) Ryan 9 (really outstanding today, and I wrote him off after our last game!) Williams 8 (very good as well) Indi 8 (very good) Adam 9 (Outstanding again!) Etebo 8.5 (very good) Allen 9 (never stopped trying or working) Clucas 8 (great goal) Campbel 7 (a real threat with his pace, but tired early in the second half) Afobe 7.5 (never stopped trying) McClean 8 ( maybe his best performance for us)
|
|
|
Post by liathroid on Jan 19, 2019 17:36:49 GMT
Butland 8 (one fantastic save in the second half that won us the game in the end) Bauer 8.5 (how we have missed such a quality right back) Ryan 9 (really outstanding today, and I wrote him off after our last game!) Williams 8 (very good as well) Indi 8 (very good) Adam 9 (Outstanding again!) Etebo 8.5 (very good) Allen 9 (never stopped trying or working) Clucas 8 (great goal) Campbel 7 (a real threat with his pace, but tired early in the second half) Afobe 7.5 (never stopped trying) McClean 8 ( maybe his best performance for us) shouldn't laugh this could be a good thing
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Jan 19, 2019 17:37:54 GMT
Butland 8 (one fantastic save in the second half that won us the game in the end) Bauer 8.5 (how we have missed such a quality right back) Ryan 9 (really outstanding today, and I wrote him off after our last game!) Williams 8 (very good as well) Indi 8 (very good) Adam 9 (Outstanding again!) Etebo 8.5 (very good) Allen 9 (never stopped trying or working) Clucas 8 (great goal) Campbel 7 (a real threat with his pace, but tired early in the second half) Afobe 7.5 (never stopped trying) McClean 8 ( maybe his best performance for us) shouldn't laugh this could be a good thing Too happy to stop laughing tonight!
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Jan 19, 2019 17:40:01 GMT
They were all brilliant today!
Butland 8 - world class save and seemed somehow more assured Bauer 8 - really happy to see him play well. I had severe doubts about but love it when a player proves you wrong! Ryan 9 - he was on it today Williams 9 -very assured Indi 8 - Solid
Adam 9.5 - Awesome from Charlie. some of those passes were sublime and helped to break down their moves too. Etebo 9.5 - the player we saw in the World Cup! Allen 9.5 - epic performance, rewarded with a great goal (can't separate these 3!) Clucas 7 - was worried about him in early stages but he got better as the game went on. Very good goal.
Campbell 7 - well done lad, his inexperience showed a few times but made a great contribution Afobe 8 - got better and better as the game went on
McClean 8 - he was exactly what we needed. Great cross for the 2nd goal
|
|
|
Post by jarvinski on Jan 19, 2019 17:40:50 GMT
Totally agree with those ratingsp
|
|
|
Post by Vadiation_Ribe on Jan 19, 2019 17:43:02 GMT
Butland 8 Bauer 7.5 Shawcross 7 Williams 7 Indi 7.5 Clucas 7
Adam 8.5 Etebo 8 Allen 8
Campbell 7 Afobe 7
McClean 8
|
|
|
Post by cobhamstokey on Jan 19, 2019 17:52:51 GMT
Butland 8 great save second half. Bauer 8 very good after being out so long. Ryan 8 been critical but today he did what he does best. Great in the air. Williams 8.5 very good today. Composed. Indi 8 best game of season Clucas 8 better 2nd half after a difficult start Adam 9 outstanding his pass to Campbell in the second half was sublime. Allen 8.5 never stopped running Etebo 9.5 my MOTM was everywhere. He’s class. Afobe 8.5 didn’t score but best game in a Stoke shirt. Played to his strengths Campbell 8 great first half but faded. He’s good enough that’s for sure. McClean 8.5 brilliant when he came on. I think he’s found his best role. Impact sub.
|
|
|
Post by boskampsflaps on Jan 19, 2019 17:57:53 GMT
Not to sure about player ratings today as there was so many good performances but Adam has to be MOTM today.
|
|
|
Post by liathroid on Jan 19, 2019 17:59:14 GMT
|
|
|
Post by chesterfieldstokie on Jan 19, 2019 18:13:11 GMT
Butland 7 One great save but nothing much to do. Bauer 6 Shawcross 7 Williams 7 Indi 7 Clucas 6.5 poor first half but good second.
Adam 8 Etebo 8 Allen 8
Campbell 7 Afobe 7
McClean 7 Adam MoM just
|
|
|
Post by Scrotnig on Jan 19, 2019 18:19:16 GMT
They were all brilliant today! Butland 8 - world class save and seemed somehow more assured Bauer 8 - really happy to see him play well. I had severe doubts about but love it when a player proves you wrong! Ryan 9 - he was on it today Williams 9 -very assured Indi 8 - Solid Adam 9.5 - Awesome from Charlie. some of those passes were sublime and helped to break down their moves too. Etebo 9.5 - the player we saw in the World Cup! Allen 9.5 - epic performance, rewarded with a great goal (can't separate these 3!) Clucas 7 - was worried about him in early stages but he got better as the game went on. Very good goal. Campbell 7 - well done lad, his inexperience showed a few times but made a great contribution Afobe 8 - got better and better as the game went on McClean 8 - he was exactly what we needed. Great cross for the 2nd goal When did we sign this new team?
|
|
|
Post by stokecity4life on Jan 19, 2019 18:26:12 GMT
10 all round for me.
When you consider what has gone before......
The confidence levels....
The lack of time with the team.....
Who we were playing....
This was incredible.
Simply incredible.
Probably the most amazing performance, result and belief since our first season in the Prem.
After that i am totally bought into Nathan, the picture of him, his reaction at the end, the players effort.
Bravo.
Simply BRILLIANT.
|
|
|
Post by anarchicalan on Jan 19, 2019 23:46:18 GMT
Butland 7 - brilliant save, but his kicking still lets him down. Didn't have a lot to do Bauer 8 - played well, will hopefully be consistent Ryan 8 - attacked the ball well, did what he's good at, defending. Williams 8 - I'm his biggest critic, but no faults today Indi 8 - looked comfortable at left back for the first time
Adam 8.5 - superb, till he ran out of energy with 15 mins to go. Etebo 9 - best game all season from him Allen 8.5 - very good today, played in the right position Clucas 9 - my MoM, such a change from Tuesday when he was our worst player
Campbell 7.5 - needs to improve his decision making, but that will come, played well Afobe 8 - best game all season from him
McClean 8 - played well, made the 2nd goal, we lost nothing from the formation when he came on
|
|
|
Post by AlbertTatlock on Jan 19, 2019 23:53:39 GMT
Butland 8 Bauer 7 Shawcross 7 Williams 7 Indi 6 Clucas 5 Adam 8 MOM Etebo 8 Allen 7 Campbell 7 Afobe 7 McClean 7 Gouranga.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 20, 2019 0:03:35 GMT
Butland 8 - Unbelievable save, didn't do too much wrong apart from the odd kick and not being confident enough on crosses.
Bauer 7 - Not a fan but he did well today.
Ryan 9 - Ryan of 09' Mint.
Williams 7 - Knew his role well - Shoddy headers that invited pressure on more than once, needs ryan to shout at him more.
Indi 8.5 - Really really solid, whipped a savage ball in and I really didnt know he had that in the locker. Undroppable like that.
Adam 9 MOM - Said it for a while, this bloke could take the champ by the scruff of the neck and wreck it. Woods a very distant second on the bench I think...
Etebo 8 - Very good, needs to believe in himself more and drive forward, what an engine!
Allen 9 - Very very good, put a real shift in and did not stop.
Clucas 7 - Excellent technique for the strike did well to get in the position if a little fortunate. His passing and wayward passing was probably the weakest bit of today.
Campbell 8 - The ball stuck to him, very very impressed - very strong for his size and really got stuck into what was a tough game for a forward, will learn to work well with Afobe
Afobe 6.5 - I'd like to see him be more direct, often too weak in going up for the ball, needs it into feet more and needs to shoot more.
Mclean 7 Put a good shift in, great cross in, felt the ball bounced off him a bit too much and he needs to calm down a little and start to process what he's doing.
|
|
|
Post by thanksjon on Jan 20, 2019 12:08:46 GMT
I'm still not convinced on Bauer his defending is ropey.Leeds played some nice football but we worked very hard to stop them getting any real clear chances.I actually thought Indi was outstanding.
|
|
|
Post by numpty40 on Jan 20, 2019 17:46:06 GMT
I do love a player rating thread as it shows how differently everyone sees the same game.
Butland - 8 A super save that arguably won us the game, his distribution is poor though.
Bauer - 7 super cross for the first goal, a bit dodgy defensively Shawcross - 8 did what he used to do brilliantly, blocks, heading clear and tackling. Williams - 7 always seemed to get a foot in and anticipate passes. Bruno - 8 best game from Bruno for a while. Clucas - 7 grew into the game but was poor for the first 20 mins, took his goal superbly Adam - 9, Mom, his range of passing and execution of the passing was a different level and I'll be honest I thought he was finished. A clear Mom. Allen - 8 he did what he does best, ran and closed all over the pitch and then pops up with a goal. Etebo - 8 fantastic second half when we were under pressure he carried the ball deep into their half to relieve the pressure, ran Adam close for MOM, Campbell - 8 really impressed me, held the ball up really well and surprisingly quick feet, one of the big plusses for me yesterday. Afobe - 7 thought he was poor until Campbell went off and then he looked a real handful!!
Special mention for James McC, excellent when he came on.
|
|
|
Post by desman2 on Jan 20, 2019 17:50:51 GMT
I think James McClean looked alot more comfortable not having to pick the ball up by the half way line and had the freedom to basically play across the front getting into space. Closing down the goalkeeper with pace. Seemed like a transformation from the rigid setup under Rowatt.
|
|
|
Post by Miles Offside on Jan 20, 2019 18:30:22 GMT
Butland 8 (one fantastic save in the second half that won us the game in the end) Bauer 8.5 (how we have missed such a quality right back) Ryan 9 (really outstanding today, and I wrote him off after our last game!) Williams 8 (very good as well) Indi 8 (very good) Adam 9 (Outstanding again!) Etebo 8.5 (very good) Allen 9 (never stopped trying or working) Clucas 8 (great goal) Campbel 7 (a real threat with his pace, but tired early in the second half) Afobe 7.5 (never stopped trying) McClean 8 ( maybe his best performance for us) Other than an 8 for Bauer and a 7 for Clucas, I'll go with that.
|
|