|
Post by robwahlmann on Jan 12, 2019 20:54:08 GMT
Butland 5, unnecessary corner for their first. Edwards 3, not convincing again, too slow. Shawcross 3, sorry Ryan Williams 4, not convincing. Pieters 4, another below par performance. Woods 3, what's happened to him? Allen 3, really terrible today! Clucas 3, same as Allen. Ince 4, at least an assist. Afobe 5, great goal, but apart from that hardly anything except stupid fouls. Berahino 3, a lot of running, but no end product again. Etebo 4, difficult game to come on at. Mr. Runs-a-lot 2, ineffective as usual. Crouch 4, too little time on the pitch today.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 12, 2019 21:01:37 GMT
Butland 6 - did nothing massively wrong.
Edwards 4 - seems slow and tired defending. Shawcross 2 - That yard in his legs seems to have gone, he can't read where opposition are going in 1 on 1s. Williams 3 - ditto but not as awful Pieters 5 - meh, let them in easily for the 2nd.
Woods 4 - out of sorts, not the worst midfielder Allen 0 - awful passing, awful on the ball, and I have no idea what position he thought he was playing. Clucas 3 - Anonymous Ince 6 - Best player on the pitch for us, drove with the ball relatively well
Berahino 4 - No service, anonymous Afobe 5 - ditto but scored a good goal, ran off the defenders quite a lot before we went 433, which I liked.
Etebo 4 - Anonymous but kept the ball okay McClean 3 - tried to run at them a bit but couldn't get past. Crouch N/A - did he touch the ball?
|
|
|
Post by Gary Hackett on Jan 12, 2019 21:19:22 GMT
The only players worth rating were Ince and Afobe.
|
|
|
Post by owdestokie2 on Jan 12, 2019 21:45:35 GMT
Butland 5, unnecessary corner for their first. Edwards 3, not convincing again, too slow. Shawcross 3, sorry Ryan Williams 4, not convincing. Pieters 4, another below par performance. Woods 3, what's happened to him? Allen 3, really terrible today! Clucas 3, same as Allen. Ince 4, at least an assist. Afobe 5, great goal, but apart from that hardly anything except stupid fouls. Berahino 3, a lot of running, but no end product again. Etebo 4, difficult game to come on at. Mr. Runs-a-lot 2, ineffective as usual. Crouch 4, too little time on the pitch today. As a point of interest did you go to Brentford today. Only asking because we have a number of posters who give their opinion but not appear to go t9 the game in question.
|
|
|
Post by owdestokie2 on Jan 12, 2019 21:46:54 GMT
Butland 6 - did nothing massively wrong. Edwards 4 - seems slow and tired defending. Shawcross 2 - That yard in his legs seems to have gone, he can't read where opposition are going in 1 on 1s. Williams 3 - ditto but not as awful Pieters 5 - meh, let them in easily for the 2nd. Woods 4 - out of sorts, not the worst midfielder Allen 0 - awful passing, awful on the ball, and I have no idea what position he thought he was playing. Clucas 3 - Anonymous Ince 6 - Best player on the pitch for us, drove with the ball relatively well Berahino 4 - No service, anonymous Afobe 5 - ditto but scored a good goal, ran off the defenders quite a lot before we went 433, which I liked. Etebo 4 - Anonymous but kept the ball okay McClean 3 - tried to run at them a bit but couldn't get past. Crouch N/A - did he touch the ball? As a point of interest did you go to Brentford today. Only asking because we have a number of posters who give their opinion but don’t appear to go to the game in question.
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Jan 12, 2019 21:55:24 GMT
3/10 for all of them.
apart from Allen who gets a 2
Worrying when there is zero impact with a new aspirational manager at the helm!!!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 12, 2019 23:53:31 GMT
Butland 6 - did nothing massively wrong. Edwards 4 - seems slow and tired defending. Shawcross 2 - That yard in his legs seems to have gone, he can't read where opposition are going in 1 on 1s. Williams 3 - ditto but not as awful Pieters 5 - meh, let them in easily for the 2nd. Woods 4 - out of sorts, not the worst midfielder Allen 0 - awful passing, awful on the ball, and I have no idea what position he thought he was playing. Clucas 3 - Anonymous Ince 6 - Best player on the pitch for us, drove with the ball relatively well Berahino 4 - No service, anonymous Afobe 5 - ditto but scored a good goal, ran off the defenders quite a lot before we went 433, which I liked. Etebo 4 - Anonymous but kept the ball okay McClean 3 - tried to run at them a bit but couldn't get past. Crouch N/A - did he touch the ball? As a point of interest did you go to Brentford today. Only asking because we have a number of posters who give their opinion but don’t appear to go to the game in question. No, I watched the game on the stream. Why does that matter?
|
|
|
Post by owdestokie2 on Jan 13, 2019 2:00:31 GMT
As a point of interest did you go to Brentford today. Only asking because we have a number of posters who give their opinion but don’t appear to go to the game in question. No, I watched the game on the stream. Why does that matter? No problem. But you’ll guess as much as I do that we’ll have posters passing comment/rating players who have done no more than listen to a game on the radio which I find bizarre
|
|
|
Post by RAF on Jan 13, 2019 8:03:03 GMT
No, I watched the game on the stream. Why does that matter? No problem. But you’ll guess as much as I do that we’ll have posters passing comment/rating players who have done no more than listen to a game on the radio which I find bizarre Does that mean that blind people should never be allowed an opinion on a match then? H
|
|
|
Post by Frogger Theft Auto on Jan 13, 2019 8:32:53 GMT
Ashley Williams was probably our MOTM. A few last-ditch tackles and blocks that kept us from an embarrassing scoreline, he came out with the ball with some gusto a few times too which seemed to give the other players a kick up the arse that got us back into the game at 2-0 down.
Next to him Shawcross looks finished and was a liability yesterday. He was moving like an oil tanker while everybody else on the pitch was jet skis. The OG was unlucky but he was so easy to beat for their third, any player in all 4 leagues could have breezed past his challenge there to have a free shot on goal.
|
|
|
Post by PottersBrim on Jan 13, 2019 9:01:46 GMT
No doubt they’ll all get 6’s and 7’s in the Sentinel.
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Jan 13, 2019 9:03:56 GMT
Butland 5, unnecessary corner for their first. Edwards 3, not convincing again, too slow. Shawcross 3, sorry Ryan Williams 4, not convincing. Pieters 4, another below par performance. Woods 3, what's happened to him? Allen 3, really terrible today! Clucas 3, same as Allen. Ince 4, at least an assist. Afobe 5, great goal, but apart from that hardly anything except stupid fouls. Berahino 3, a lot of running, but no end product again. Etebo 4, difficult game to come on at. Mr. Runs-a-lot 2, ineffective as usual. Crouch 4, too little time on the pitch today. As a point of interest did you go to Brentford today. Only asking because we have a number of posters who give their opinion but not appear to go t9 the game in question. No, unfortunately this is impossible for me as I live in Norway, but I watch every game anyway.
|
|
|
Post by FullerMagic on Jan 13, 2019 9:11:19 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Gary Hackett on Jan 13, 2019 9:13:40 GMT
You're being way too kind there with some of those ratings. There wasn't anyone worthy of more than a 6.
|
|
|
Post by Mr_DaftBurger on Jan 13, 2019 9:15:33 GMT
Ashley Williams was probably our MOTM. A few last-ditch tackles and blocks that kept us from an embarrassing scoreline, he came out with the ball with some gusto a few times too which seemed to give the other players a kick up the arse that got us back into the game at 2-0 down. Next to him Shawcross looks finished and was a liability yesterday. He was moving like an oil tanker while everybody else on the pitch was jet skis. The OG was unlucky but he was so easy to beat for their third, any player in all 4 leagues could have breezed past his challenge there to have a free shot on goal. I thought Williams did play like he gave a shit then the cynic in me thought he's playing for a new (last) contract!
|
|
|
Post by FullerMagic on Jan 13, 2019 9:16:10 GMT
You're being way too kind there with some of those ratings. There wasn't anyone worthy of more than a 6. I agree, Gary. They're Martin Spinks' ratings. And he's on record as not wanting to put any player noses out of joint when he does them, so never rocks the boat.
|
|
|
Post by Gary Hackett on Jan 13, 2019 9:19:25 GMT
You're being way too kind there with some of those ratings. There wasn't anyone worthy of more than a 6. I agree, Gary. They're Martin Spinks' ratings. And he's on record as not wanting to put any player noses out of joint when he does them, so never rocks the boat. Well if that's the reason he gives those scores he shouldn't be doing the job he's doing.
|
|
|
Post by Laughing Gravy on Jan 13, 2019 9:22:48 GMT
Ashley Williams was probably our MOTM. A few last-ditch tackles and blocks that kept us from an embarrassing scoreline, he came out with the ball with some gusto a few times too which seemed to give the other players a kick up the arse that got us back into the game at 2-0 down. Next to him Shawcross looks finished and was a liability yesterday. He was moving like an oil tanker while everybody else on the pitch was jet skis. The OG was unlucky but he was so easy to beat for their third, any player in all 4 leagues could have breezed past his challenge there to have a free shot on goal. That would be the Ashley Williams who ducked under the ball from the corner leading up to their first goal. Any half competent defender simply clears that easily thus averting the early goal boost it handed them on a plate. Agreed Shawcross has gone. Nothing he could do about the OG but the third, he looked about 50 when he lunged in on the goal scorer. I think all three centre halves need clearing out, keep Indi, at a push, if he can get back anything like. At least 2 new ones required this window. As for ratings none above 4 and most much lower. PS Owdstokie2 I too watched it on a stream if that's ok?
|
|
|
Post by albundy on Jan 13, 2019 9:52:18 GMT
I went to the game today but would probably be able to rate the players better with the view from a stream rather than being in the terrace. Difficult to judge through balls etc Butland 6 - did nothing massively wrong. Edwards 4 - seems slow and tired defending. Shawcross 2 - That yard in his legs seems to have gone, he can't read where opposition are going in 1 on 1s. Williams 3 - ditto but not as awful Pieters 5 - meh, let them in easily for the 2nd. Woods 4 - out of sorts, not the worst midfielder Allen 0 - awful passing, awful on the ball, and I have no idea what position he thought he was playing. Clucas 3 - Anonymous Ince 6 - Best player on the pitch for us, drove with the ball relatively well Berahino 4 - No service, anonymous Afobe 5 - ditto but scored a good goal, ran off the defenders quite a lot before we went 433, which I liked. Etebo 4 - Anonymous but kept the ball okay McClean 3 - tried to run at them a bit but couldn't get past. Crouch N/A - did he touch the ball? As a point of interest did you go to Brentford today. Only asking because we have a number of posters who give their opinion but don’t appear to go to the game in question.
|
|