|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Dec 26, 2018 20:15:31 GMT
Butland 7 (couldn't do much about the two they scored(
Martina 3 (he simply isn't good enough)
Williams 6 (not too bad, but had some awfull passes=
Shawcross 6 (looked slow, but win his fair share of headers today as well)
Indi 5.5 (not bad, but isn't a fullback)
Allen 6.6 (our best midfielder today(
Woods 5 (not enough forward passes and was one of those at fault for their first as well)
Clucas 6 (made some good runs, but really should have scored)
Ince 5 (his worst performance for us)
Berahino 5 (a lot of work on his own, but almost no contribution)
McClean 4.4 (too primitive)
Crouch 3 (no postive contribution)
Afobe 3 (the same as Crouch)
Edwards 3 (showed again that he hasn't got the pace needed as a fullback)
|
|
|
|
Post by davejohnno1 on Dec 26, 2018 20:39:02 GMT
Butland 8
Allen 8
The rest 0
|
|
|
|
Post by gingerninja on Dec 26, 2018 20:45:12 GMT
Spot on Dave. There are too many players under performing too often.. we simply do not look like a top 10 side, let alone a top six side.
|
|
|
|
Post by scfcwebby on Dec 26, 2018 20:47:46 GMT
Butland 7 (couldn't do much about the two they scored( Martina 3 (he simply isn't good enough) Williams 6 (not too bad, but had some awfull passes= Shawcross 6 (looked slow, but win his fair share of headers today as well) Indi 5.5 (not bad, but isn't a fullback) Allen 6.6 (our best midfielder today( Woods 5 (not enough forward passes and was one of those at fault for their first as well) Clucas 6 (made some good runs, but really should have scored) Ince 5 (his worst performance for us) Berahino 5 (a lot of work on his own, but almost no contribution) McClean 4.4 (too primitive) Crouch 3 (no postive contribution) Afobe 3 (the same as Crouch) Edwards 3 (showed again that he hasn't got the pace needed as a fullback) You rate Edwards a 3??? The same as Martina??? Wow  |
|
|
|
Post by rorystowel on Dec 26, 2018 21:25:34 GMT
Butland 9 - made some great saves to keep us in the game for longer than we probably deserved
Martina 5 - played one good through ball to Ince but otherwise was mostly ineffective
Williams 6 - our best defender as usual, got stuck in
Shawcross 5 - won a few headers but looked off the pace again
Indi 4 - played out of position, not his fault
Allen 6 - below par, but gave his all
Woods 3 - poor distribution all game
Clucas 5 - missed a sitter, didn’t do a lot else
Ince 4 - a mostly anonymous performance, and if he doesn’t perform then there’s usually no other creative outlet to get us out the shit
Berahino 5 - made one good chance out of nothing, which was what he had to put up with all game
McClean 2 - touch deserted him at every turn, really dismal today
Crouch 1 - added nothing
Afobe 1 - hardly touched the ball
Edwards 1 - kept passing backwards when he needed to be getting down the wing and crossing for Crouch and Afobe
|
|
|
|
Post by terryconroysmagic on Dec 26, 2018 21:43:32 GMT
Keep playing like this and Butland and Allen will be off sharpish, if we’re not careful we’ll be watching a special kind of shit soon
|
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Dec 26, 2018 22:09:23 GMT
Butland 7 (couldn't do much about the two they scored( Martina 3 (he simply isn't good enough) Williams 6 (not too bad, but had some awfull passes= Shawcross 6 (looked slow, but win his fair share of headers today as well) Indi 5.5 (not bad, but isn't a fullback) Allen 6.6 (our best midfielder today( Woods 5 (not enough forward passes and was one of those at fault for their first as well) Clucas 6 (made some good runs, but really should have scored) Ince 5 (his worst performance for us) Berahino 5 (a lot of work on his own, but almost no contribution) McClean 4.4 (too primitive) Crouch 3 (no postive contribution) Afobe 3 (the same as Crouch) Edwards 3 (showed again that he hasn't got the pace needed as a fullback) You rate Edwards a 3??? The same as Martina??? Wow No attacking contribution as far as I could see. Only showed he lacked pace again for me. I'd really love Edwards to come good, but if he becomes a regular for Stoke we're probably not even an upper half team in this division any more.  |
|
|
|
Post by wilcopotter on Dec 26, 2018 22:12:29 GMT
Ashley Williams is a liability. Once the player/ball is passed himhe’s finished. Lucky my to be sent off (again).
|
|
|
|
Post by thehoof on Dec 26, 2018 23:00:10 GMT
Butland 9 - made some great saves to keep us in the game for longer than we probably deserved Martina 5 - played one good through ball to Ince but otherwise was mostly ineffective Williams 6 - our best defender as usual, got stuck in Shawcross 5 - won a few headers but looked off the pace again Indi 4 - played out of position, not his fault Allen 6 - below par, but gave his all Woods 3 - poor distribution all game Clucas 5 - missed a sitter, didn’t do a lot else Ince 4 - a mostly anonymous performance, and if he doesn’t perform then there’s usually no other creative outlet to get us out the shit Berahino 5 - made one good chance out of nothing, which was what he had to put up with all game McClean 2 - touch deserted him at every turn, really dismal today Crouch 1 - added nothing Afobe 1 - hardly touched the ball Edwards 1 - kept passing backwards when he needed to be getting down the wing and crossing for Crouch and Afobe Martina was the worst player in the whole of Central England today- yet you have given him a 5; I suspect looking at your other scores that you have missed the minus sign from in front of his points award? |
|
|
|
Post by terrorofturfmoor on Dec 27, 2018 0:19:05 GMT
Just for the sake of it....
Butland: 7, pulled off some outstanding saves, had no chance with both goals
Martina: fuck it.... I'm not gonna even bother
Martins Indi: 6, nothing outstanding, but nothing really bad either
Shawcross: 4, I think your time is long over due now Ryan
Williams: 6, possibly (in my opinion) our best defender, although he seemed hell bent on getting himself sent off in the first half
Woods: 5, can't say I bought into this Woods hysteria when he first come, but what he did have, is being kicked out of him by the tactics we're playing
Clucas: 6, not one of his better games, but hardly his fault, at least tried to get forward when possible....more so in the first half
Allen: 8, contiues his revival, but he can't keep carrying the rest of the team, so when he does have an off game, we should remember these games
Ince: 5, totally ineffective throughout, seemed to also look disinterested
McClean: 6, worked hard, but thats about it when it comes to his game, we need better
Berahino: 6, nobody knocked Berahino more than I did in the first few years, but now I actually feel sorry for him....he's being hung out to dry up top on his own, especially when we keep playing high balls up to him
Subs,
Afobe: 4, ineffective, and I can't believe we're forking out over £12M for this guy next month.....please someone tell me there's a get out clause
Edwards: 4, not a great deal he could do to improve the team today.....however, still better than Martina
Crouch: 3, I'm a big fan of Crouchy, but today (more so) I noticed the fouls that he does give away
|
|
