|
Post by robwahlmann on Dec 22, 2018 18:42:41 GMT
Butland 7, some bad kicking again + losing a cross, but all in all quite solid.
Martina 6, OK, but nothing more. Shawcross 6.5, great in the air, but almost scored an own goal. Williams 6.5, OK again, but struggles with pace. Pieters 5.5, too many mistakes and bad decisions made.
Allen 7, our best player this afternoon. Woods 7, a good game tonight. Clucas 6, more anonymous this afternoon.
Ince 6.5, a bit too quiet this afternoon. Berahino 6, scored the winner, but apart from that a weak game. McClean 6.5, a lot of effort, but again too predictable in my opinion.
Indi 6, did OK. Crouch 6, won some important headers late on. Afobe 4, not much impact.
|
|
|
Post by fazza90 on Dec 22, 2018 19:10:50 GMT
Butland 7 - solid performance but his distribution causes us problems on two or 3 occasions
Martina 5.5 - very lethargic going forwards, had nothing to do defensively Shawcross 5 - a massive liability unfortunately Williams 6.5 - did OK Pieters 6.5 - did OK apart from 3 miskicked clearances within a bizarre 2 minute period
Woods 7.5 - good defensively, good organising & kept us moving Clucas 6 - not near his usual high standards he's set recently Allen 8.5 - the man was everywhere and constantly a threat McClean 8 - immense first half, good second. Direct, aggressive & constantly putting the ball in dangerous areas Ince - 7.5 obvious quality but would like him to be more direct, the one cross he put in was perfect
Berahino 5 - offered sweet FA other than the goal
Happy with the win but we made hard work of a very bad Millwall team
|
|
|
Post by CBUFAWKIPWH on Dec 22, 2018 19:11:27 GMT
Butland 6 - 1 good save but poor distribution
Martina 7 decent performance and some good link up play with Ince Shawcross 5 hate to say it but just looks like there is a mistake waiting to happen Williams 7.5 - another assured performance Pieters 7 solid yet again from Eric
Allen 8 - everywhere - my MoM Woods 7.5 - after some dodgy performances kept and recycled the ball well today Clucas 6.5 - a bit anonymous, maybe still not be fully match fit
McClean 7 - worked hard and put in a couple of decent crosses Berahino 6.5 - took his goal well but relatively quiet Ince 8 - looked classy and great cross for the goal
BMI 6.5 - looked like a penalty to me but did ok to come on at that point in the game Crouch 6 - odd substitution but did ok Afobe 6.5 - actually made some good runs but wasn't picked out
|
|
|
Post by wuzza on Dec 22, 2018 19:36:54 GMT
Butland - 6 . He looks a nervous wreck with the ball at his feet but one great save. Martina - 6 . Saw a fair bit of the ball , didn’t achieve anything. Shawcross - 5 . Never really recovered from a shaky start. Williams- 6 . Caught flat footed a couple of times. Pieters - 6. No better or worse than the rest of a dodgy defence. Allen - 9. Energy and skill, outstanding. Woods - 6. Makes a regular contribution to our defensive meltdowns by dithering in or around the box. Clucas - 7 Not great but solid enough. Ince - 8. Along with Joe the only creative spark on the field. McLean - 7. Almost a good performance but lacked that bit of quality that would make him a really good player. Berahino - 5. Up until the goal a complete waste of a shirt (maybe a victim of tactics but still dreadful)
|
|
|
Post by claytonscrubs on Dec 22, 2018 19:41:32 GMT
Butland 6
Martina 5 Shawcross 5 Williams 6 Pieters 5
Woods 7 Allen 8 ..... MOTM again! Clucas 6
McClean 7 Ince 7 Berahino 6 for the goal ⚽️..... Take away his goal 2
|
|
|
Post by boskampsflaps on Dec 22, 2018 19:45:25 GMT
Butland -6
Martina -6 Shawcross -6 Williams -7 Pieters -6
Woods -7 Clucas -6 Allen -8 McClean -8 Motm for me Ince - 7
Berahino -6.5 (had very little to work with)
|
|
|
Post by ukcstokie on Dec 22, 2018 19:54:25 GMT
Butland - 7 Martina - 4 Shawcross - 7 Williams- 7 Pieters - 6 Allen - 8 Woods - 7 Clucas - 6 Ince - 6 McLean - 7 Berahino - 6
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 22, 2018 20:24:03 GMT
Butland 6 - kicking way too causal Martina 6 - can’t fault his energy up and down the line but he’s got no stand out attributes at all. Shawcross 6 - Better once his feet and brain started working in tandem after 20 mins. Williams 6 - See above Pieters 6 - See also above although in fairness he was playing with a knock according to Rowett Woods 6 - Needs to speed his passing up, much better 2nd half Allen 7 - Great energy, involved in most of our decent play. Clucas 6 - one game too far after his injury maybe? Ince 6 - played within himself but still looked lively at times. Berahino 6 - Little service but very stationary at times, good finish McClean 7 - very direct and some decent crosses, looked much better of late.
|
|
|
Post by luke45 on Dec 22, 2018 21:59:29 GMT
[quote author=" robwahlmann" source="/post/6274243/thread" Shawcross 6.5, great in the air, but almost scored an own goal. [/quote] I'd be interested to know how many aerial duels Ryan won today, I actually thought he lost a fair portion of them up against Tom Elliott. To be fair their game plan consisted of fighting for second balls off him and playing for set pieces, they didn't offer an awful lot apart from that!
|
|
|
Post by SneydGreenStokie on Dec 22, 2018 22:00:26 GMT
Christ there is some shite posted on here.
SGS
|
|
|
Post by SneydGreenStokie on Dec 22, 2018 22:01:40 GMT
Butland 6 - kicking way too causal Martina 6 - can’t fault his energy up and down the line but he’s got no stand out attributes at all.
Shawcross 6 - Better once his feet and brain started working in tandem after 20 mins. Williams 6 - See above Pieters 6 - See also above although in fairness he was playing with a knock according to Rowett Woods 6 - Needs to speed his passing up, much better 2nd half Allen 7 - Great energy, involved in most of our decent play. Clucas 6 - one game too far after his injury maybe? Ince 6 - played within himself but still looked lively at times. Berahino 6 - Little service but very stationary at times, good finish McClean 7 - very direct and some decent crosses, looked much better of late. His stamina perhaps? SGS
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 22, 2018 22:06:54 GMT
Butland 6 - kicking way too causal Martina 6 - can’t fault his energy up and down the line but he’s got no stand out attributes at all.
Shawcross 6 - Better once his feet and brain started working in tandem after 20 mins. Williams 6 - See above Pieters 6 - See also above although in fairness he was playing with a knock according to Rowett Woods 6 - Needs to speed his passing up, much better 2nd half Allen 7 - Great energy, involved in most of our decent play. Clucas 6 - one game too far after his injury maybe? Ince 6 - played within himself but still looked lively at times. Berahino 6 - Little service but very stationary at times, good finish McClean 7 - very direct and some decent crosses, looked much better of late. His stamina perhaps? SGS Should be expected from a professional footballer. It doesn't stop me from wanting him dropped. The attributes of passing, tackling and heading are certainly missing from his game.....
|
|
|
Post by jarhead on Dec 22, 2018 22:30:32 GMT
Butland 4 Martina 4 Pieters 4 Ash 4 Ryan 4 Woods 6 Ince 7 Clucas 6 Allen 7 Saido 6 Sympathiser 5
Pretty awful stuff in all truth.
Merry Christmas
|
|
|
Post by wilcopotter on Dec 22, 2018 23:35:07 GMT
Butland, if he’s going anywhere in January not sure where. Never a top 6 keeper. Shite a kicking, doesn’t command his box. Good shot stopper, never anywhere near penalties. Sorry folks, England’s no.1 my arse. He needs to reflect, not as good as he might think he is.
|
|
|
Post by rawli on Dec 23, 2018 0:21:53 GMT
Butland 6. Great save from Ryan. Terrible kicking. Need to stop trying to be Pickford. Flapped at the end. Martina 4. Slowed everything down and looked for easy negative pass rather than being proactive. Pieters 5. Shocking for 15 mins in first half. If he was injured should have said he needed to come off earlier. Williams 6. Started poorly but improved. Ryan 5. Poor again. So immobile. Woods 6. Bit slow. Some fannying around in our defensive 3rd Ince 7. Needed to run at their full backs more. Clucas 6. Didn't really notice him. Allen 7. Thought he had a good game. Tried to get the team going. Saido 6. Good finish. Didn't do too much apart from that. Mclean 6. Tried to get things moving with little effect.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 23, 2018 0:24:46 GMT
Butland 4 Martina 4 Pieters 4 Ash 4 Ryan 4 Woods 6 Ince 7 Clucas 6 Allen 7 Saido 6 Sympathiser 5 Pretty awful stuff in all truth. Merry Christmas 'sympathiser' ffs ??? You couldn't write the stupidity on this board I swear
|
|
|
Post by AlbertTatlock on Dec 23, 2018 0:47:21 GMT
Butland 5, 1 good save from Shawcross but nothing else to do apart from kick it and he was awful at that, slowed the game when we wanted quicker movement and was too quick when we needed to run the clock down. Martina 5, stopped and slowed the play down took too many touches and didn't cross enough. Shawcross 6, apart from alost scoring an own goal had little trouble to deal with. Williams 6, lack of pace almost cost us in the second half but apart from that wasn't really troubled. Pieters 5, not his best game but he was missed when he went off. Allen 7, huffed and puffed a lot but gave 100% can't fault his effort MOM. Woods 6, too many sideways and backward passes but didn't give the ball away too much today. Clucas 6, a quiet game today. Ince 6, in and out of the game today but a great cross for the goal and having Martina behind him wasn't helpful I lost count how many times he made a run and Martina didn't pass to him . Berahino 6, scored the winner and that was about his only contribution but as long as he can do that on a regular basis I'd be happy. McClean 7, looked our main threat in the first half but faded in the second a solid if not exciting performance. Indi 5, not a LB but deputised as a stop gap did OK but Milwaal seemed to target him and most of the threat came on our left. Crouch 5, a good clearance from a corner but that's about it. Afobe 4, did he actually touch teh ball? Gouranga.
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Dec 23, 2018 8:24:58 GMT
[quote author=" robwahlmann" source="/post/6274243/thread" Shawcross 6.5, great in the air, but almost scored an own goal. I'd be interested to know how many aerial duels Ryan won today, I actually thought he lost a fair portion of them up against Tom Elliott. To be fair their game plan consisted of fighting for second balls off him and playing for set pieces, they didn't offer an awful lot apart from that![/quote] I really think you should start counting and be in for a surprise if you thought he lost many headers.
|
|