|
Post by ukcstokie on Jan 5, 2016 23:38:23 GMT
Butland 7 Wooly 6 Ryan 7 Pieters 6 Johnson 7 Cameron 6 Whelan 6 Afelay 6 Bojan 5 Arnie 6 Shaq 6
Walter 7 Crouch 6 Joselu 6
|
|
|
Post by Trouserdog on Jan 5, 2016 23:40:56 GMT
Butland 7 Johnson 6 Ryan 8 Wolly 7 Peters 6
Afellay 6 Whelan 5 Cameron 5
Shaqiri 5 Bojan 4 Arnie 6
subs: Walters 6 Joselu 6 Crouch 6
|
|
|
Post by Kjones9 on Jan 5, 2016 23:42:09 GMT
Butland - 6 Johnson - 8 Ryan - 7 Wollscied -7 Pieters - 5 Whelan - 5 Cameron - 5 Affelay - 7 Bojan - 4 Shaqiri - 5 Arnautovic - 6
Subs.
Joselu - 7 Walters - 6 Crouch - 5
|
|
|
Post by StokieNath on Jan 5, 2016 23:45:02 GMT
Butland - 5 Johnson - 8 Ryan - 6 Wollschied- 7 Pieters - 4 Whelan - 4 Cameron - 4 Affelay - 6 Bojan - 2 Shaqiri - 4 Arnautovic - 5
Subs.
Joselu - 6 Walters - 5 Crouch - 5
|
|
|
Post by werrington on Jan 5, 2016 23:45:06 GMT
Butland 7 Johnson 6 Ryan 8 Wolly 7 Peters 6 Afellay 6 Whelan 5 Cameron 5 Shaqiri 5 Bojan 4 Arnie 6 subs: Walters 6 Joselu 6 Crouch 6 I don't think you can compare Johnson and Pieters mate Johnson was mom by a country mile and Pieters had possibly his worst game in a Stoke shirt He gave away possession on numerous occasions but he's got plenty in the bank
|
|
|
Post by Kjones9 on Jan 5, 2016 23:47:04 GMT
Butland 7 Johnson 6 Ryan 8 Wolly 7 Peters 6 Afellay 6 Whelan 5 Cameron 5 Shaqiri 5 Bojan 4 Arnie 6 subs: Walters 6 Joselu 6 Crouch 6 I don't think you can compare Johnson and Pieters mate Johnson was mom by a country mile and Pieters had possibly his worst game in a Stoke shirt He gave away possession on numerous occasions but he's got plenty in the bank Also Butland better than him. who imp very shaky with corners and was lucky with that kick when he hit thier player.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 5, 2016 23:50:59 GMT
Butland 6 Johnson 8 Ryan 8 Big Phil 7 Pieters 5 Whelan 6 Geoff 5 Afellay 8 mom Arnie 5 Shaq 5 Bojan 5
Joselu 6 Crouch 6 Walters 6
|
|
|
Post by StokeAz on Jan 5, 2016 23:51:48 GMT
Butland 6 some bad clearances and nearly caused a deflected goal, good save after. Decent first half saves Johnson 5 at should have been back post for the goal I thought. Good threat attacking wise Shawcross 5 elbowed player, played lallana onside Wholly 7 solid performance I thought pieters 2 messed up on many occasions, looked scared of attacking, worst Stoke performance Cameron 3 not a great day for him, kept losing it out of position Whelan 7 solid performance as usual Afellay 6 good passing, could have ran with it more Bojan 2 couldn't get passed the first man, tired perhaps Arnie 6 decent attack wise, missed a heading chance and didn't run down the wing enough, tracked back well in the first half Shaqiri 3 should have been running at them, too predictable
Walters 6 worked hard and we improved, but missed decent chance at the end Crouch 6 did his job and maybe should have started here or at west brim Joselu 5 did alright, lost the ball easily however...
Not sure how 6 or 7 can be given for everyone, it was one of our worst performances all season...
|
|
|
Post by cousindupree on Jan 5, 2016 23:52:14 GMT
Butland - 5 Johnson - 8 Ryan - 6 Wollschied- 7 Pieters - 4 Whelan - 4 Cameron - 4 Affelay - 6 Bojan - 2 Shaqiri - 4 Arnautovic - 5 Subs. Joselu - 6 Walters - 5 Crouch - 5 This
|
|
|
Post by Sergeant Muttley on Jan 5, 2016 23:52:50 GMT
Butland 7 Johnson 6 Ryan 8 Wolly 7 Peters 6 Afellay 6 Whelan 5 Cameron 5 Shaqiri 5 Bojan 4 Arnie 6 subs: Walters 6 Joselu 6 Crouch 6 I don't think you can compare Johnson and Pieters mate Johnson was mom by a country mile and Pieters had possibly his worst game in a Stoke shirt He gave away possession on numerous occasions but he's got plenty in the bank Agree about Pieters mate and I'd say the same for the 2 games previous as well.He's been excellent all season though so hopefully is bad spell will end soon
|
|
|
Post by Kjones9 on Jan 5, 2016 23:53:03 GMT
Butland 6 some bad clearances and nearly caused a deflected goal, good save after. Decent first half saves Johnson 5 at should have been back post for the goal I thought. Good threat attacking wise Shawcross 5 elbowed player, played lallana onside Wholly 7 solid performance I thought Cameron 3 not a great day for him, kept losing it out of position Whelan 7 solid performance as usual Afellay 6 good passing, could have ran with it more Bojan 2 couldn't get passed the first man, tired perhaps Arnie 6 decent attack wise, missed a heading chance and didn't run down the wing enough, tracked back well in the first half Shaqiri 3 should have been running at them, too predictable Walters 6 worked hard and we improved, but missed decent chance at the end Crouch 6 did his job and maybe should have started here or at west brim Joselu 5 did alright, lost the ball easily however... Not sure how 6 or 7 can be given for everyone, it was one of our worst performances all season... Isn't it about opinions? Like my opinion that your ratings are baffling.
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Jan 5, 2016 23:54:31 GMT
Butland 7 Wooly 6 - ok, but he's no Franz Beckenbaur Ryan 7 - Solid enough Pieters 2 - Shocking, needs to learn how to cross a ball, and his link up play with Arnie was woeful Johnson 7 - Our best attacking option, bit suspect at back though Cameron 4 - FA screwed us over by reversing his 3 game ban Whelan 5 - Poor distribution and nearly cost us another penalty Affelay 6 - Didnt realise he was playing until the 30th minute Bojan 4 - I hope all the big teams were watching this one! Arnie 6 - Tried hard but got no help from anybody Shaq 4 - Didnt offer us anything
Walters 6 - at least ruffled a few feathers, but he's not the answer and poor miss at the end showed his limitations Crouch n/a Joselu 6
|
|
|
Post by StokeAz on Jan 5, 2016 23:56:38 GMT
Butland 6 some bad clearances and nearly caused a deflected goal, good save after. Decent first half saves Johnson 5 at should have been back post for the goal I thought. Good threat attacking wise Shawcross 5 elbowed player, played lallana onside Wholly 7 solid performance I thought Cameron 3 not a great day for him, kept losing it out of position Whelan 7 solid performance as usual Afellay 6 good passing, could have ran with it more Bojan 2 couldn't get passed the first man, tired perhaps Arnie 6 decent attack wise, missed a heading chance and didn't run down the wing enough, tracked back well in the first half Shaqiri 3 should have been running at them, too predictable Walters 6 worked hard and we improved, but missed decent chance at the end Crouch 6 did his job and maybe should have started here or at west brim Joselu 5 did alright, lost the ball easily however... Not sure how 6 or 7 can be given for everyone, it was one of our worst performances all season... Isn't it about opinions? Like my opinion that your ratings are baffling. Let's be realistic, 6 is pretty good, some of our players were tired and they knew what to expect, we were tired... i respect ur opinion but our better players on the night were decent and our poor ones never turned up
|
|
|
Post by chrisparker on Jan 6, 2016 0:05:46 GMT
Butland 6 (Didn't need to do an awful lot in the second half but in the first half he made some important saves) Johnson 8 (Our best attacking outlet) Ryan 8 (Without him, this game could've been 2-3 nil) Wooly 6 (Meh) Pieters 4 (Hopeless in possession when he doesn't have Arni in support. Needs to improve his distribution.) Cameron 3 (Did he play one forward pass? Needlessly gave away possession more than once and didn't offer anything going forward) Whelan 4 (Another player who couldn't cope with pressure from Liverpool players. Gave the ball away countless times) Afelay 5 (Like Cameron, he just kept passing it backwards. Really need more creativity in midfield.) Arnie 7 (Tried stuff all game but it's a shame everyone around him was underperforming) Shaq 5 (Was completely anonymous for much of the game but he did have his moments) Bojan 1 (Couldn't pass, couldn't shoot, couldn't hold the ball, couldn't bring others in the game. His worst performance in a Stoke shirt)
Walter 7 (Hade an immediate impact & should've scored in added time) Joselu 6 (Deserves to start next week) Crouch n/a
|
|
|
Post by johnnysoul60 on Jan 6, 2016 0:19:38 GMT
Butland 6 Johnson 8 Pieters 4 new contract blues ???? Ryan 6 Wololly 6 Whelan. 6 Affelay 7 Cameron 5 Bojan 4 Shaq6 Arnie. 6 Walters 6 Joselu 7 Crouch 6
|
|
|
Post by thestokielad on Jan 6, 2016 0:27:24 GMT
Am i the only one that thinks whelan was outstanding tonight?
|
|
|
Post by roylandstoke on Jan 6, 2016 0:28:04 GMT
Butland 7- couldn't be faulted for the goal and tidy with everything else Johnson7- probably our best outlet all game Ryan 7- solid display from the skipper Wolly 7- another decent showing Pieters 6- OK, but not at his best with his link up with Arnie
Cameron 6-OK Whelan 6-good cover but not much else Afelay 7- most creative player for us by miles Bojan 3-very poor, very weak in possession, just as he was at Albion. Looks very tired. Arnie 6- Should have buried that header first half. Didn'y really click tonght/ Shaq 6- impressed with his effort, but like Arnie didn't really click
Walter 8-easy to say now but should have started. Shame he couldn't get more on the late chance with his left foot. Crouch 6- did what you'd expect Joselu 7- another promising cameo, must be pushing for a start soon.
|
|
|
Post by scfcwebby on Jan 6, 2016 0:37:15 GMT
Butland 6
Johnson 6 Ryan 7 Wolly 6 Pieters 4
Whelan 4 Cameron 4
Affelay 7 Arnie 7 Shaqiri 5 Bojan 4
Walters 4 (- points for that miss at the end) Crouch 5 Joselu 6
|
|
|
Post by scfcwebby on Jan 6, 2016 0:37:45 GMT
Am i the only one that thinks whelan was outstanding tonight? Yes
|
|
|
Post by davejohnno1 on Jan 6, 2016 0:41:14 GMT
Butland - 5 very shaky Johnson - 7 decent game but too casual at times tonight Pieters 4 worst I've ever seen him play. Needs to chop that stupid fucking pony tail off Ryan 7 some good, some very good but was he at fault for their goal? Wooly - the big man was great I thought. 8 Whelan 3 toss Cameron 3 toss Affelay 7 good effort and played on his own at times Bojan - 2 awful. Absolutely awful. Didn't do a single thing right Shaqiri - I honestly don't know what to make of his performance. Sideways, backwards, anywhere except forward Arnie 7 our only threat and at least tried to make things happen.
Cant be bothered to rate the subs but they weren't very good either. I only really wanted to say that Erik needs to cut that stupid fucking pony tail off! :-)
|
|
|
Post by ashleyscfc on Jan 6, 2016 0:46:54 GMT
Butland 6 Johnson 7 Ryan 7 Wolly 6 Peters 5
Afellay 6 Whelan 4 Cameron 5
Shaqiri 5 Bojan 4 Arnie 6
subs: Walters 6 Joselu 6 Crouch 6
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 6, 2016 0:50:22 GMT
The lot of them shit themselves tonight.
Considering some of the things that this group have won, inexcusable.
|
|
|
Post by cooper67 on Jan 6, 2016 0:53:56 GMT
Thought Affelay had a good game but for God's sake pass it forwards sometimes especially when you have men available.
|
|
|
Post by scfcwebby on Jan 6, 2016 1:18:35 GMT
Am i the only one that thinks whelan was outstanding tonight? Am I the only one that thinks Johnson had a poor game?
|
|
|
Post by riccyfuller93 on Jan 6, 2016 2:48:37 GMT
Am i the only one that thinks whelan was outstanding tonight? Yes he's bang average at times.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 6, 2016 8:08:09 GMT
Butland 6 some bad clearances and nearly caused a deflected goal, good save after. Decent first half saves Johnson 5 at should have been back post for the goal I thought. Good threat attacking wise Shawcross 5 elbowed player, played lallana onside Wholly 7 solid performance I thought pieters 2 messed up on many occasions, looked scared of attacking, worst Stoke performance Cameron 3 not a great day for him, kept losing it out of position Whelan 7 solid performance as usual Afellay 6 good passing, could have ran with it more Bojan 2 couldn't get passed the first man, tired perhaps Arnie 6 decent attack wise, missed a heading chance and didn't run down the wing enough, tracked back well in the first half Shaqiri 3 should have been running at them, too predictable Walters 6 worked hard and we improved, but missed decent chance at the end Crouch 6 did his job and maybe should have started here or at west brim Joselu 5 did alright, lost the ball easily however... Not sure how 6 or 7 can be given for everyone, it was one of our worst performances all season... Crouch over Joselu. Dear Lord.
|
|
|
Post by nutterpotter on Jan 6, 2016 8:22:51 GMT
Butland 6
Johnson 8 Shawcross 7 Wolly 7 Pieters 5
Whelan 6 Cameron 5 Afellay 7
Shaq 6 Bojan 5 Arnie 6
|
|
|
Post by cheadlepotter on Jan 6, 2016 8:23:52 GMT
Butland 7 Johnson 7 Wollscheid 7 Shawcross 7 Pieters 6 Cameron 5 Whelan 5 Affelay 6 Shaqiri 5 Bojan 4 Arnautovic 6
Walters 5 Crouch 6 Joselu 6
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 6, 2016 9:02:30 GMT
Butland - 5 Johnson - 8 Ryan - 6 Wollschied- 7 Pieters - 4 Whelan - 4 Cameron - 4 Affelay - 6 Bojan - 2 Shaqiri - 4 Arnautovic - 5 Subs. Joselu - 6 Walters - 5 Crouch - 5 This but take 1 off Johnson and Wolly . Can't believe how shaky Butland was
|
|
|
Post by foster on Jan 6, 2016 9:27:22 GMT
Butland 6 (Didn't need to do an awful lot in the second half but in the first half he made some important saves) Johnson 8 (Our best attacking outlet) Ryan 8 (Without him, this game could've been 2-3 nil) Wooly 6 (Meh) Pieters 4 (Hopeless in possession when he doesn't have Arni in support. Needs to improve his distribution.) Cameron 3 (Did he play one forward pass? Needlessly gave away possession more than once and didn't offer anything going forward) Whelan 4 (Another player who couldn't cope with pressure from Liverpool players. Gave the ball away countless times) Afelay 5 (Like Cameron, he just kept passing it backwards. Really need more creativity in midfield.) Arnie 7 (Tried stuff all game but it's a shame everyone around him was underperforming) Shaq 5 (Was completely anonymous for much of the game but he did have his moments) Bojan 1 (Couldn't pass, couldn't shoot, couldn't hold the ball, couldn't bring others in the game. His worst performance in a Stoke shirt) Walter 7 (Hade an immediate impact & should've scored in added time) Joselu 6 (Deserves to start next week) Crouch n/a Same, but with Arnie down to 6 and Afellay up to 7.
|
|