|
|
Post by knowles on Oct 3, 2015 16:07:33 GMT
So, what were your ratings? Butland 6 Johnson 7 Cameron 7 Wollscheid 7 Pieters 7 Whelan 8 Adam 7 Bojan 6 Arnautovic 8 Walters 6 Diouf 6 Afellay 6 Van Ginkel 6 |
|
|
|
Post by slother on Oct 3, 2015 16:13:23 GMT
Butland 8
Johnson 7
Cameron 7
Wollscheid 6
Pieters 9
Whelan 8
Adam 7
Bojan 6
Arnautovic 7
Walters 6
Diouf 6
Afellay 5
Van Ginkel 5
Joselu 6
|
|
|
|
Post by stokemanusa on Oct 3, 2015 16:22:13 GMT
Butland 7
Johnson 7
Cameron 8
Wollscheid 8
Pieters 7
Whelan 7
Adam 7
Bojan 7
Arnautovic 9
Walters 7
Diouf 8
Afellay 6
Van Ginkel 5
|
|
|
|
Post by ed5993 on Oct 3, 2015 16:24:34 GMT
Butland 7
Johnson 8
Cameron 8
Wollscheid 8
Pieters 9
Whelan 8
Adam 7
Diouf 7
Bojan 6
Arnautovic 8
Walters 6
Afellay 5
Van Ginkel 5
Joselu 6
Wanted to give Diouf more for his work rate again today
|
|
|
|
Post by stokecity4life on Oct 3, 2015 16:27:46 GMT
Feel i must add my scores here after watching the game there were some very big, decent performances today....
Butland 7
Johnson 8
Cameron 8
Wollscheid 8 (possibly even more but got done once for pace and showed his weakness)
Pieters 7
Whelan 7
Adam 7
Bojan 7
Arnautovic 9
Walters 7
Diouf 8
Afellay 7
Van Ginkel 6
Joselu 6
|
|
|
|
Post by cobhamstokey on Oct 3, 2015 16:30:43 GMT
Butland 6 Had nothing to do.
Johnson 8 Excellent today solid at the back and looked dangerous going forward.
Cameron 8 Great performance kept there threat to a minimum no panicky clearances either.
Wollscheid 8 Getting better and better. Looks a real confidence player. back 4 looks better with him in it.
Pieters 7 Very solid.
Whelan 8 Hardworking. Excellent.
Adam 7 Played well.
Bojan 6 Still not 100 percent. Did OK but gave the ball away too much.
Arnautovic 9 MOM On his days he's world class gave them so many problems. We didn't look the same after he went off.
Walters 6 Worked hard but too many mistakes when in possession.
Diouf 7 As always worked his socks off. Hope he's OK.
Afellay 6 Did OK
Van Ginkel 6 We look a better team without him. Hopefully he'll come good. Not sure if he's matchfit.
Joselu 6 Not on long enough.
|
|
|
|
Post by datguy on Oct 3, 2015 16:31:07 GMT
Butland 7
Johnson 8
Cameron 9
Wollscheid 8
Pieters 9
Whelan 8
Adam 8
Diouf 8
Bojan 6
Arnautovic 9
Walters 7
No one looked like they played 'bad'. Bojan just needs time, looked like he lacked pace.
|
|
|
|
Post by Robo10 on Oct 3, 2015 16:34:30 GMT
Butland 7 - not much to do but cant criticise him for that
Johnson 7 - decent but final ball not always great
Wolly 7 - strong against a good threat, although GCam supported him a lot
GCam 8 - trememdpus effort today
Pieters 7 - worked well with Arnie
Adam 6.5 - huffed and puffed, nearly nearly scored another specco!
Whelan 6.5 - worked his bollocks off but end quality not always there
Arnie 8.5 - teriffic all day, shit decision to disallow his first goal, cracker of a second
Bojan 7.5 - getting there, sparks the midfield
Walters 7 - good first half, had me shouting at the telly giving the ball away in the second, esp at the end when down the channel and passed it to their forwards twice!
Diouf 7 - good game, worked his cotton ones off.
|
|
|
|
Post by cheekymatt71 on Oct 3, 2015 16:37:14 GMT
Butland 7 - not much to do but cant criticise him for that Johnson 7 - decent but final ball not always great
Wolly 7 - strong against a good threat, although GCam supported him a lot GCam 8 - trememdpus effort today Pieters 7 - worked well with Arnie Adam 6.5 - huffed and puffed, nearly nearly scored another specco! Whelan 6.5 - worked his bollocks off but end quality not always there Arnie 8.5 - teriffic all day, shit decision to disallow his first goal, cracker of a second Bojan 7.5 - getting there, sparks the midfield Walters 7 - good first half, had me shouting at the telly giving the ball away in the second, esp at the end when down the channel and passed it to their forwards twice! Diouf 7 - good game, worked his cotton ones off. strange explanation for Johnson after he got his 2nd assist in 2 games with a QUALITY through ball that Bojan would have been proud of |
|
|
|
Post by dudnostokie on Oct 3, 2015 16:44:44 GMT
Butland 7 - Didn't have all that much to do, but produced some good saves when called upon.
Johnson 7.5 - Did well getting forward, defensively not so good. Cracking ball to Arnie for the goal.
Cameron 8 - Solid, covered a few mistakes from the others well.
Wollscheid 7.5 - Did well today, got caught out at times.
Pieters 7 - Standard performance for Ekkers.
Whelan 7 - Played well, got caught a couple of times.
Adam 7 - Sprayed the ball about well, nearly scored another worldy.
Bojan 6 - Not at the races today, he'll get better the more he plays. Just needs time.
Arnautovic 9 - Superb again today, hope this spell of form continues. Did his defensive duties well, we didn't look the same when he came off.
Walters 7 - Typical SJW performance, ran his bollocks off. Thought he could have played the square ball earlier to Arnie.
Diouf 7 - Did well, looked a bit frustrated at times.
MVG 6.5 - Not bad, didn't see enough of him to judge fairly.
Affellay 7 - Thought he looked lively when he came on, can't blame him for having a shot at the end.
Joselu 6 - Didn't really see much of the lad.
|
|
|
|
Post by Robo10 on Oct 3, 2015 16:46:03 GMT
Its not that strange?
Yes that was a good ball, other times he delivers crud from the side
His ball in last weekend was amazing, but then he will put a duffer in
Still gave him a 7, wasnt having a go! I like him!
|
|
|
|
Post by whydelilah on Oct 3, 2015 16:47:46 GMT
So, what were your ratings? Butland 6 Johnson 7 Cameron 7 Wollscheid 7 Pieters 7 Whelan 8 Adam 7 Bojan 6 Arnautovic 8 Walters 6 Diouf 6 Afellay 6 Van Ginkel 6 Cameron 7? Jesus wept. What does he have to do to please some people. |
|
|
|
Post by kurt on Oct 3, 2015 16:56:44 GMT
Arnautovic 9 Cameron 9  7 for the rest |
|
|
|
Post by liathroid on Oct 3, 2015 17:01:44 GMT
|
|
jpsrsdff
Academy Starlet
A bit of optimism never hurt
Posts: 184 
|
Post by jpsrsdff on Oct 3, 2015 17:03:22 GMT
Overall:
GK - 8
Defence - 8
Midfield - 7
Attack - 7
Individual performances:
Butland - 8 - solid as ever but little to trouble him.
Johnson - 8 - very good going forward and not a liability at the back.
Cameron - 9 - very, very solid. Little got past him.
Wollscheid - 7 - played well and removed a lot of doubts about him, but nothing special about him.
Pieters - 8 - put in a great shift, working very hard at both ends.
Whelan - 8 - great at doing what he does.
Adam - 6 - I wouldn't call him a liability but he was very mediocre.
Bojan - 6 - shaky start so far, though he did show some pace and nice dribbling at times.
Arnautovic - 8 - as always, one of our best players. Scored a nice goal and one that shouldn't have been disallowed in addition to his usual pace, skills, and strength.
Walters - 6 - worked hard as always but it's clear he doesn't have the attacking flair that our other forwards do.
Diouf - 7 - fast and strong like usual but didn't look like scoring much today.
Subs:
Afellay - 7 - good at beating players but not much else, reminds me of Moses at the start of last season.
Van Ginkel - 5 - poor and uninspired, really not the start to the season that he'll have been looking for.
Joselu - 6 - had little to do.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 3, 2015 17:15:18 GMT
I think it was a good all round team performance with solid 8s all round. I'd push the boat out at 9s for the back 4 who were all superb today. Slight edge for Johnson motm
|
|
