|
Post by cobhamstokey on Nov 20, 2010 18:45:37 GMT
After an average first half much improved in the second. A great win.
Bego - 8 - Faultless performance gets better and better Wilko - 7 - Skinned a few times but kept at it Ryan - 9 - Class won everything in the air Huth - 8 - As above Collins - 7 - Steady Ethers - 7 - Always looked dangerous poor final ball Whitehead - 8 - Worked his socks off shame about his passing Rory - 7 - Good game Pennant - 7 - Started well hopefully he wont be out long Ric - 7 - Worked hard but nothing quite came off today KJ - 7 - Lazy at times but still won the penalty and set up the 3rd
subs Tuncay - 8 - Like a little general didn't miss Pennant says it all Walters - 8 - 2 goals can't ask for anymore Wilson - 6 - Not on long enough
|
|
|
Post by Laughing Gravy on Nov 20, 2010 19:17:40 GMT
I'd give Bego 9 but Shawcross 7. Yes he's a class defender but an infuriating footballer. He's son of Higgy when it comes to unnecessarily hoofing the ball back to the opposition. So for me only a 7. Other than that a pretty fair assessment.
|
|
|
Post by RICH68 on Nov 20, 2010 19:23:05 GMT
I'd give Bego 9 but Shawcross 7. Yes he's a class defender but an infuriating footballer. He's son of Higgy when it comes to unnecessarily hoofing the ball back to the opposition. So for me only a 7. Other than that a pretty fair assessment. I agree with 9 for Begovic (He`s a lot better than Sorro IMO),but 7 for Shawcross ???? Name me another CB in the Premiership who plays the ball out of defence.
|
|
|
Post by PickSCFC on Nov 20, 2010 19:29:31 GMT
bego - 7 wilko - 7 huth - 7 ryan - 8 collins - 5 tunny - 7 delap - 7 whead - 7 ethers - 6 fuller - 6 jones - 6
|
|
|
Post by Beardy200 on Nov 20, 2010 19:31:36 GMT
bego - 7 wilko - 7 huth - 7 ryan - 8 collins - 5 tunny - 7 delap - 7 whead - 7 ethers - 6 fuller - 6 jones - 6 I'll go with that fella. We win 3-0 and people are very quick to throw 8's and 9's around when in truth it was a very average performance against a West Brom team who didn't turn up.
|
|
|
Post by bettsy on Nov 20, 2010 19:32:07 GMT
bego - 7 wilko - 7 huth - 7 ryan - 8 collins - 5 tunny - 7 delap - 7 whead - 7 ethers - 6 fuller - 6 jones - 6 it was 3 nil you know and collins 5 ??? 2 clean sheets on the trot, we shouldn't change a winning team, he's better than hoofman higgy all the way
|
|
|
Post by PickSCFC on Nov 20, 2010 19:32:55 GMT
bego - 7 wilko - 7 huth - 7 ryan - 8 collins - 5 tunny - 7 delap - 7 whead - 7 ethers - 6 fuller - 6 jones - 6 I'll go with that fella. We win 3-0 and people are very quick to throw 8's and 9's around when in truth it was a very average performance against a West Brom team who didn't turn up. if we had lost chances are they would have got 3's and 4's ;D
|
|
|
Post by PickSCFC on Nov 20, 2010 19:33:57 GMT
bego - 7 wilko - 7 huth - 7 ryan - 8 collins - 5 tunny - 7 delap - 7 whead - 7 ethers - 6 fuller - 6 jones - 6 it was 3 nil you know and collins 5 ??? 2 clean sheets on the trot, we shouldn't change a winning team, he's better than hoofman higgy all the way collins was awful today, hes lucky to get a 5, hopefully he will be dropped next week and higgy will be put back in
|
|
|
Post by Caerwrangonpotter on Nov 20, 2010 19:34:26 GMT
Bego was super & is getting better with more and more games.
|
|
|
Post by french toast on Nov 20, 2010 19:37:23 GMT
After an average first half much improved in the second. A great win. Bego - 9 Wilko - 6 Ryan - 8 Huth - 8 Collins - 5 Ethers - 7 - Always looked dangerous poor final ball Whitehead - 8 - Worked his socks off shame about his passing Rory - 6 Pennant - no score 10 mins aint long enough Ric - 7 KJ - 7 subs Tuncay - 8 - Like a little general didn't miss Pennant says it all Walters - 8 - 2 goals can't ask for anymore Wilson - not on long enough
|
|
|
Post by nickscfc on Nov 20, 2010 19:38:07 GMT
it was 3 nil you know and collins 5 ??? 2 clean sheets on the trot, we shouldn't change a winning team, he's better than hoofman higgy all the way collins was awful today, hes lucky to get a 5, hopefully he will be dropped next week and higgy will be put back in Picky from these ratings i get the impression you were impressed with Sir Sanli?
|
|
|
Post by bettsy on Nov 20, 2010 19:38:10 GMT
it was 3 nil you know and collins 5 ??? 2 clean sheets on the trot, we shouldn't change a winning team, he's better than hoofman higgy all the way collins was awful today, hes lucky to get a 5, hopefully he will be dropped next week and higgy will be put back in to be fair you'd say that if he had agood game, he was average but he's part of a back 4 which is immense so would be silly to change it
|
|
|
Post by PickSCFC on Nov 20, 2010 19:42:56 GMT
collins was awful today, hes lucky to get a 5, hopefully he will be dropped next week and higgy will be put back in Picky from these ratings i get the impression you were impressed with Sir Sanli? yes he played well today as he has done in the previous games he has played in.
|
|
|
Post by PickSCFC on Nov 20, 2010 19:45:19 GMT
collins was awful today, hes lucky to get a 5, hopefully he will be dropped next week and higgy will be put back in to be fair you'd say that if he had agood game, he was average but he's part of a back 4 which is immense so would be silly to change it No i wouldnt, he started off well this season and i didnt have a problem that he was getting picked, why would i if hes playing well ??? but he has been preety shit of late and dropping him wouldnt be the worst idea
|
|
|
Post by lordb on Nov 20, 2010 20:02:47 GMT
Bego: 8 Wilko : 5 Collins: 5 Huth 7 Ryan:7 Whitehead: 6 Rory: 6 JP n/a Tuncay: 6 Ethers: 5 (worst game for Stoke - good penno though) Jones: 6 Ric: 7 Walters: 7
honestly I thought its the worst we've played for ages
overall passing was shocking
still good attitude throughout
|
|
|
Post by Gunslinger on Nov 20, 2010 20:07:36 GMT
Bego: 8 Wilko: 7 Huth: 8 Ryan: 8 Collins: 6 Tuncay: 7 Delap: 7 Whitehead: 7 Ethers: 6 Fuller: 6 Jones: 6 Walters: 8 Wilson: 7
|
|
|
Post by fromafar07 on Nov 20, 2010 20:11:49 GMT
Begovic - 9 Wilkinson - 6 Huth - 8 Shawcross - 8 Collins -6 Whitehead - 6 Delap -7 Pennant n/a Tuncay - 9 Fuller - 7 Jones - 6 Walters - 9 Wilson n/a
|
|
|
Post by nickscfc on Nov 20, 2010 20:12:57 GMT
Picky from these ratings i get the impression you were impressed with Sir Sanli? yes he played well today as he has done in the previous games he has played in. So maybe deserves a start next match at home?? what you reckon ;D
|
|
|
Post by lordb on Nov 20, 2010 20:13:50 GMT
Tuncay 9?
he's been fantastic this season but not today imho
|
|
|
Post by march4 on Nov 20, 2010 20:14:51 GMT
Ryan and Huth were immense again for me and I remain impressed by Bego.
|
|
|
Post by nickscfc on Nov 20, 2010 20:23:50 GMT
Tuncay 9? he's been fantastic this season but not today imho Tuncay was awesome today, but in a more Whitehead kind of style as apposed to the Robinho approach ;D In other words he did alot of quality dirty work that goes unoticed. i..e helping Wilko massively.
|
|
|
Post by PickSCFC on Nov 20, 2010 20:30:12 GMT
yes he played well today as he has done in the previous games he has played in. So maybe deserves a start next match at home?? what you reckon ;D no, if pennant is fit i would keep the same starting line up except higgy in for collins
|
|
|
Post by nystoke on Nov 20, 2010 20:31:30 GMT
Bring back higgy?? more hoof, Collins at least gives it to Ethers feet so he can attack with it
|
|
|
Post by march4 on Nov 20, 2010 20:32:44 GMT
So maybe deserves a start next match at home?? what you reckon ;D no, if pennant is fit i would keep the same starting line up except higgy in for collins Spot on. How woeful does Collins have to get - still I suppose TP will say this defensive unit has kept another clean sheet.
|
|
|
Post by Beardy200 on Nov 20, 2010 20:37:12 GMT
Bring back higgy?? more hoof, Collins at least gives it to Ethers feet so he can attack with it No he doesn't. He hoofs it just as much as Higgy and no more accurately. On the odd occasion he does give it to Ethers he gives it to him in no room and then buggers off on the overlap leaving him under pressure with no back up if he loses it. I'd pick Higgy every time. He's more solid defensively and i can't think of anything Collins has done since he's been here to create a goal at the other end so i don't see the point.
|
|
|
Post by PickSCFC on Nov 20, 2010 20:38:53 GMT
Bring back higgy?? more hoof, Collins at least gives it to Ethers feet so he can attack with it but he cant defend this 'collins has better distribution than higgy' is a myth
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 20, 2010 20:47:59 GMT
Bego: 8 Wilko : 5 Collins: 5 Huth 7 Ryan:7 Whitehead: 6 Rory: 6 JP n/a Tuncay: 6 Ethers: 5 (worst game for Stoke - good penno though) Jones: 6 Ric: 7 Walters: 7 honestly I thought its the worst we've played for ages overall passing was shocking still good attitude throughout Spot on for me that, wilko and collins were atrocious, good job west brom were fucking awful
|
|
|
Post by Paul Spencer on Nov 21, 2010 0:37:50 GMT
Bego: 8 Wilko : 5 Collins: 5 Huth 7 Ryan:7 Whitehead: 6 Rory: 6 JP n/a Tuncay: 6 Ethers: 5 (worst game for Stoke - good penno though) Jones: 6 Ric: 7 Walters: 7 honestly I thought its the worst we've played for ages overall passing was shocking still good attitude throughout This is much more in the correct ball park imo. There's some markings further up, that have been very much influenced by the result, rather than the individual performances. Rory's and Deano's passing today was absolutely abysmal as was that of the two full backs. If those four players in a team can't pass a ball, then the rest of team is going to really struggle to get anything going offensively. Yes I know we scored three but it really was a pretty dire performance from both sides for long spells of the game today.
|
|
|
Post by aussiebluey on Nov 21, 2010 0:52:16 GMT
I thought both the full backs struggled, but Wilko especially. 2nd half he was much better as he got closer to their winger, but 1st half he got skinned way too many times. I think Collins is a much better left back than Higgy, the grass is always greener on the other side. Contrary to a few on here I thought Tunny did pretty well - he tracked back a lot in the 2nd half and is always a nuisance for the other side to deal with. Anyway 3 point in the bag, 8th in the league, start looking at flights to Europe next year boys
|
|
|
Post by rigsby on Nov 21, 2010 0:54:21 GMT
Bring back higgy?? more hoof, Collins at least gives it to Ethers feet so he can attack with it but he cant defend this 'collins has better distribution than higgy' is a myth Couldn't agree more mate.
|
|