|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Oct 29, 2024 23:18:45 GMT
Why aren't you our keeper coach? Are you OK mate? I played Sunday league for a long time, some good teams some piss poor 😂 Coached kids (still do) for the past 15 years No I'm not as good or anywhere near as Tom Why the fuck would I be our keeper coach? I played in nets for 5 games when injured, it was horrific 😂 Doesnt mean you cant understand the game ffs Anyway, it was a good effort tonight, I feared the worst after 40 mins. Night all! You sound like just what we need. |
|
|
|
Post by spitthedog on Oct 29, 2024 23:30:42 GMT
No not really. At fault for goal #1, had already dived into the stand for the pen before he hit it, defending was poor for #3 (and Jr off the pitch again) but nowhere near it. Doesnt come for crosses Parries the ball back into danger - his 1 OK save tonight he was lucky it fell to Phillips not a striker. He is what he is, a lower league #2 keeper. Surely Phillips was at fault for the first one? Yes correct. Phillips lost his man, there is no way the goalie can a) get to it, as he was being blocked by a group of players and b) save it Defensive error plain and simple. |
|
|
|
Post by musik on Oct 29, 2024 23:30:52 GMT
I haven't seen him play anything at all since this was the first game they showed here and I was able to see. It was fun, I liked Tchamadeu, Kuomas and Million the most. From what I got Seko has just played very few minutes this season, coming in from the bench? A summer signing obviously. It was just 4" and first I thought it was Bae. 🤠|
|
|
|
Post by pottersrule on Oct 29, 2024 23:30:53 GMT
No not really. At fault for goal #1, had already dived into the stand for the pen before he hit it, defending was poor for #3 (and Jr off the pitch again) but nowhere near it. Doesnt come for crosses Parries the ball back into danger - his 1 OK save tonight he was lucky it fell to Phillips not a striker. He is what he is, a lower league #2 keeper. At fault for the first goal my arse, he was being blocked on the line by his own teammate ffs. Honestly I've never heard so much shit when it comes to Bonham, he's a perfectly adequate Championship number 2 and if he had to fill in for 6/8 games a season would not let us down....... He was Gillingham's third choice keeper don't you know.Another load of bollocks that did the rounds.Bonham is the least of our problems. |
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Oct 29, 2024 23:33:42 GMT
I haven't seen him play anything at all since this was the first game they showed here and I was able to see. It was fun, I liked Tchamadeu, Kuomas and Million the most. From what I got Seko has just played very few minutes this season, coming in from the bench? A summer signing obviously. It was just 4" and first I thought it was Bae. 🤠Showed where? |
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Oct 29, 2024 23:36:55 GMT
At fault for the first goal my arse, he was being blocked on the line by his own teammate ffs. Honestly I've never heard so much shit when it comes to Bonham, he's a perfectly adequate Championship number 2 and if he had to fill in for 6/8 games a season would not let us down....... He was Gillingham's third choice keeper don't you know.Another load of bollocks that did the rounds.Bonham is the least of our problems. He gets this tag of a League Two keeper but if you look at all the keepers we've played against this season aside from Cooper at Sheff Utd I'd say he's at least as good as the rest..... |
|
|
|
Post by liathroid on Oct 30, 2024 0:14:07 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by roylandstoke on Oct 30, 2024 1:48:33 GMT
Bonham 6 did ok
Dixon 4 looks like an academy player ( I know he is an academy player)
Philips 6 at fault for 1st goal
Rose 6
Junior 6 his best game of season
Thompson 6 he’s better against better opponents
Seko 8
Sidibe 6
Bocat 6
Vidigal 5
Cannon 5
Koumas 6
Manhoef 6
Moran 7
|
|
|
|
Post by roylandstoke on Oct 30, 2024 1:49:50 GMT
He is a huge improvement on Bursik. |
|
|
|
Post by Chewbacca the Wookie on Oct 30, 2024 7:26:12 GMT
Bonham 5 Not his greatest game
Junior 5 kept going but I just don’t rate him
Dixon 6 was never a pen
Rose 5 not the most composed
Phillips 6 should start on Sat
Thompson 5 invisible
Sidibe 5 not ready yet but will be a good player
Seko 7 composed
Vidigal 5 poor
Cannon 6 good finish but not involved
Subs;
Koumas 7 excellent when he came on
Million 6 caused them problems
Others N/A
Pelach 6
Ref 4 a real homer. Gave them literally everything
|
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Oct 30, 2024 7:59:36 GMT
Bonham 6.5, looked a bit out of position for their first, but apart from that he had a good game in my opinion.
Junior 6.5, decent game and looks like he has got some pace back as well.
Dixon 6, not bad at all, and really should have been awarded a free kick when he gave away that penalty.
Rose 6, OK, but he needs to be more aware about where he puts his clearences.
Phillips 6, if not for the first goal he would have got a 7 for the performance.
Bocat 6, a difficult job when they always doubled up on his side.
Thompson 5, works hard, but he lacks the quality to do much more.
Sidibe 5, very anonymous!
Seko 6, worked hard and was willing to receive the ball, but looks very slow to me.
Vidigal 5, worked hard, but what has happened to his skills on the ball!?
Cannon 6, scored a good goal and also a couple of good moments during the first half. Still too anonymous for most of the game.
Subs;
Koumas 7, he will become a great player!
Million 7, with Million and Koumas we looked far more dangerous going forward.
Moran 5, quiet!
Burger, not on long enough to get a rating.
|
|
|
|
Post by stokesupporter on Oct 30, 2024 8:19:31 GMT
Bonham 6 Can't really fault him
Phillips 8 Scored and did his other duties well
Rose 6 Pretty basic game
Dixon 6 has still lot to learn but not bad
Tchamadeu 6 One of his better matches, he never hides.
Seko 8 *MOTM Good range of passing, playmaker type who gave also lot of instuctions to other players. Very good full debut!
Thompson 6 Did what was probably asked from him
Sidibe 6 Another one who has still lot to learn but did rather okeish
Bocat 5 Didn't get going, defending a bit suspect at times
Vidigal 4 seems slower than last season
Cannon 6 scored a good goal, did also some pressing work
Koumas 7 Best of our subs, looked very dangerous
Manhoef 6 couple of good moments, almost scored too
Burger 6 getting better
Moran 5 quiet match by his standards
|
|
|
|
Post by wuzza on Oct 30, 2024 8:27:58 GMT
I wish I lived in a world where Bonham was a significant problem at SCFC !!!
|
|
|
|
Post by humbersidepotter on Oct 30, 2024 13:34:47 GMT
Bonham 4, got to be honest he has to save the first, the third his only excuse is that possibly he can't see it? Should have been closed down but he had an age to get across and save it, Vik saves both of those and stands a good chance at the 2nd with his pen record.
Dixon 5, some positive moments, but holds attackers too much for me. Needs a loan
Philips 6, the marking for the goal was atrocious. Did ok apart from that and gains a point for the finish
Rose 5, meh, he is what he is.
Junior 6, too much of a whimp for me in general for a lad of his size. Where's the exciting player gone from when he first came here?
Thompson 5, it's just the beginning of the inevitable every time he starts. The only decent game I can recall him having is when he played LB against Leeds at home.
Seko 7, Intriguing, looked good for patches - does look to play forward but I would like to see a little more urgency
Sidibe 5, massive fan and think he'll be a top player in the prem, but another that if he's not going to play give him a loan.
Bocat 5, same old - we know what we're going to get
Vidigal 3, seriously not good out for football in England, has to be moved on in January.
Cannon 6, people are complaining about how anonymous he was - one clear cut chance and he finished it. That's what he is, a poacher - sooner we stop attempting to use him as a focal point and play him in a two the better.
Koumas 7 - very lively, unlucky he couldn't sort his touch out when he skipped past the last defender on the half way line.
Manhoef 6, was shocking last tuesday, better yesterday but for the love of god just hit it. Still feel he was bought down by Ramsdale and on another day could have had a pen
Moran 6, neat and tidy as per.
Ref - 4, realistically trying to get into the good books of a prem club. Embarrassing the amount of 50:50's that went against us.
Narcis - 6, first half was horrible to watch. 2nd he went for it, I rate that - but we've got to see games out
|
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Oct 30, 2024 13:49:47 GMT
Bonham 4, got to be honest he has to save the first, the third his only excuse is that possibly he can't see it? Should have been closed down but he had an age to get across and save it, Vik saves both of those and stands a good chance at the 2nd with his pen record. Dixon 5, some positive moments, but holds attackers too much for me. Needs a loan Philips 6, the marking for the goal was atrocious. Did ok apart from that and gains a point for the finish Rose 5, meh, he is what he is. Junior 6, too much of a whimp for me in general for a lad of his size. Where's the exciting player gone from when he first came here? Thompson 5, it's just the beginning of the inevitable every time he starts. The only decent game I can recall him having is when he played LB against Leeds at home. Seko 7, Intriguing, looked good for patches - does look to play forward but I would like to see a little more urgency Sidibe 5, massive fan and think he'll be a top player in the prem, but another that if he's not going to play give him a loan. Bocat 5, same old - we know what we're going to get Vidigal 3, seriously not good out for football in England, has to be moved on in January. Cannon 6, people are complaining about how anonymous he was - one clear cut chance and he finished it. That's what he is, a poacher - sooner we stop attempting to use him as a focal point and play him in a two the better. Koumas 7 - very lively, unlucky he couldn't sort his touch out when he skipped past the last defender on the half way line. Manhoef 6, was shocking last tuesday, better yesterday but for the love of god just hit it. Still feel he was bought down by Ramsdale and on another day could have had a pen Moran 6, neat and tidy as per. Ref - 4, realistically trying to get into the good books of a prem club. Embarrassing the amount of 50:50's that went against us. Narcis - 6, first half was horrible to watch. 2nd he went for it, I rate that - but we've got to see games out Like he saved Campbell's you mean? |
|
|
|
Post by maine on Oct 30, 2024 13:56:45 GMT
Bonham 7 Blocked (I think by Thompson) for the first, a pen? (well not Victor) the third, a well positioned, powerfully hit shot. Played competently.
Phillips7. Weak first half, though excellent goal, Good second.
Rose 5. A little lower than his par
Dixon 7 I'd prefer him to Gibson. At least he was close enough to their forwards to foul them!
Tchamadeu 6 Hope a better display feeds his confidence.
Seko 6. OK, but I don't think he's the second coming!
Thompson 3 Awful on the night.
Sidibe 5. I think he's better than his last two first team appearances.
Bocat 5 Positional sense needs some attention.
Vidigal5 More effort, but he does seem slower than when he arrived.
Cannon 5 Good finish, but doesn't find the spaces he should.
Koumas 7 Certainly livened things up.
Manhoef 8 With better reffing, We'd probably think he'd made the difference
Burger 7. Never hides, recovering form
Moran 5 Didn't notice him.
|
|
|
|
Post by humbersidepotter on Oct 30, 2024 14:01:12 GMT
Bonham 4, got to be honest he has to save the first, the third his only excuse is that possibly he can't see it? Should have been closed down but he had an age to get across and save it, Vik saves both of those and stands a good chance at the 2nd with his pen record. Dixon 5, some positive moments, but holds attackers too much for me. Needs a loan Philips 6, the marking for the goal was atrocious. Did ok apart from that and gains a point for the finish Rose 5, meh, he is what he is. Junior 6, too much of a whimp for me in general for a lad of his size. Where's the exciting player gone from when he first came here? Thompson 5, it's just the beginning of the inevitable every time he starts. The only decent game I can recall him having is when he played LB against Leeds at home. Seko 7, Intriguing, looked good for patches - does look to play forward but I would like to see a little more urgency Sidibe 5, massive fan and think he'll be a top player in the prem, but another that if he's not going to play give him a loan. Bocat 5, same old - we know what we're going to get Vidigal 3, seriously not good out for football in England, has to be moved on in January. Cannon 6, people are complaining about how anonymous he was - one clear cut chance and he finished it. That's what he is, a poacher - sooner we stop attempting to use him as a focal point and play him in a two the better. Koumas 7 - very lively, unlucky he couldn't sort his touch out when he skipped past the last defender on the half way line. Manhoef 6, was shocking last tuesday, better yesterday but for the love of god just hit it. Still feel he was bought down by Ramsdale and on another day could have had a pen Moran 6, neat and tidy as per. Ref - 4, realistically trying to get into the good books of a prem club. Embarrassing the amount of 50:50's that went against us. Narcis - 6, first half was horrible to watch. 2nd he went for it, I rate that - but we've got to see games out Like he saved Campbell's you mean? He should have saved that but he's completely blind sighted by the defender. He's been our stand out player by a country mile this year |
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Oct 30, 2024 15:22:32 GMT
Like he saved Campbell's you mean? He should have saved that but he's completely blind sighted by the defender. He's been our stand out player by a country mile this year A bit like Bonham who was completely blind sighted by Jordan Thompson blocking his route to the ball for their first goal then....... |
|
|
|
Post by thornestein on Oct 30, 2024 17:29:46 GMT
He should have saved that but he's completely blind sighted by the defender. He's been our stand out player by a country mile this year A bit like Bonham who was completely blind sighted by Jordan Thompson blocking his route to the ball for their first goal then....... anyone who knows anything about football knows Bonham should have done better on the first goal , you’re just another who doesn’t like a bad word said about the club and can’t do with others having a different opinion than yours |
|
|
|
Post by prestwichpotter on Oct 30, 2024 17:46:10 GMT
A bit like Bonham who was completely blind sighted by Jordan Thompson blocking his route to the ball for their first goal then....... anyone who knows anything about football knows Bonham should have done better on the first goal , you’re just another who doesn’t like a bad word said about the club and can’t do with others having a different opinion than yours Calm down Lev Yashin. Just because people have a weird irrational dislike of Bonham doesn't mean In have to join the party. I criticise the club when I feel they need criticising....... |
|
