|
Post by middleoftheboothen on Mar 10, 2023 22:37:42 GMT
Bonham - 5.5 should have saved the second Hoever - 9 Tuanzebe - 8 Fox 7.5 Sterling - 9 bonus point for playing so well out of position as left back Pearson -9 MOTM. As soon as he is off we concede 2!! Laurent - 8.5 Smallbone - another great game. Shame he couldn’t finish one of his two good chances 8 Campbell - good play, tidy finish 8 Gayle - played fairly well. Good cross for the first goal 7.5 Brown - Unfortunately wasn’t his day - 5.5 Subs Clucas 4 Tymon 5 Thompson 5 Baker 5 All of the subs weakened us and were a bit too early. So Bonham is criticised and gets a 5.5 Smallbone who misses 2 absolute sitters gets an 8? The difference is that other than not scoring the two chances Smallbone played brilliantly whereas Bonham had two things to do all game and completely fucked them both up.
|
|
|
Post by willieeetmiout on Mar 10, 2023 22:41:44 GMT
I didn't have a go at him for his score did I? I told him to grow up for giving a critical single rating of Bonham but not bothering to rate anyone else. Seeing your posts over the years you would hold a torch to anyone on the "fucking dumb" category. You did. You were questioning the scores for each. Why do you care? Hang on. In that post, as you accept, I was questioning someone's scores. That isn't having a go at them is it? For once in your 15 years engage your brain before your fingers.
|
|
|
Post by ukcstokie on Mar 10, 2023 22:46:36 GMT
Bonham 6
Hoever 7 (lost 1 point for his defending of their first goal) Tuanzebe 7 Fox 6 (lost 1 point for his defending of their second goal) Sterling 7
Pearson 9 Laurent 7 Smallbone 8
Campbell 8 Gayle 7 Brown 6
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Mar 10, 2023 22:48:44 GMT
You did. You were questioning the scores for each. Why do you care? Hang on. In that post, as you accept, I was questioning someone's scores. That isn't having a go at them is it? For once in your 15 years engage your brain before your fingers. You told him to grow up 😂😂😂
|
|
|
Post by Lesalanos on Mar 10, 2023 22:50:15 GMT
Aah, ok, so I am ? Based on the fact that I think Bonham is a liability? You’re clearly not particularly good at recognising a poor Div 1 goalie from a decent championship goalie. Overall an excellent performance and coasting, but every time the ball came into our final third I worried that something could go wrong. Not a feeling I had with Sarkic. I’ll take your word that you’re not an idiot. 👍 You decided not to rate any other player other than Bonham. Who, for no particular reason made you worried. No particular reason? We were clinging on at the end of a game they got two attempts on target? So you weren’t worried, good on you. To be fair I did think 3 would be enough. Rest of team very good, too many subs, would have kept Laurent on. Full backs 8, Fox 6, Axel 8, Pearson and Luarent 8, smallbone 7, gayle 7, Campbell 8 and Brown 7. On reflection I was probably a little generous on Bonham.
|
|
|
Post by willieeetmiout on Mar 10, 2023 22:51:22 GMT
Hang on. In that post, as you accept, I was questioning someone's scores. That isn't having a go at them is it? For once in your 15 years engage your brain before your fingers. You told him to grow up 😂😂😂 Why are you amalgamating two posts into one? In one post I questioned why Bonham was 5.5 and Smallbone (missed 2 sitters) a 8. Did not have a go. In another I told someone to grow up, not for the rating, but for harshly criticising Bonham and not bothering with anyone else. Like I said. Engage the brain before the fingers.
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Mar 10, 2023 22:52:06 GMT
You told him to grow up 😂😂😂 Why are you amalgamating two posts into one? In one post I questioned why Bonham was 5.5 and Smallbone (missed 2 sitters) a 8. Did not have a go. In another I told someone to grow up, not for the rating, but for harshly criticising Bonham and not bothering with anyone else. Like I said. Engage the brain before the fingers. It’s having a go about the scores. Or how someone scores. Why do you care?
|
|
|
Post by HarryTheHat on Mar 10, 2023 22:52:20 GMT
So Bonham is criticised and gets a 5.5 Smallbone who misses 2 absolute sitters gets an 8? The difference is that other than not scoring the two chances Smallbone played brilliantly whereas Bonham had two things to do all game and completely fucked them both up. Yep, exactly this. Had nothing to do all game and then when actually needed he failed dismally. Clearly can't be trusted by his teammates
|
|
|
Post by willieeetmiout on Mar 10, 2023 22:56:10 GMT
Why are you amalgamating two posts into one? In one post I questioned why Bonham was 5.5 and Smallbone (missed 2 sitters) a 8. Did not have a go. In another I told someone to grow up, not for the rating, but for harshly criticising Bonham and not bothering with anyone else. Like I said. Engage the brain before the fingers. It’s having a go about the scores. Or how someone scores. Why do you care? It's not having a go though is it. It's questioning someone. You've already accepted it's questioning someone so why are you now saying it's having a go. Why do I care? I'm entitled to ask why a keeper who makes maybe 1 mistake gets a much lower rating than someone who's misses could have been just as costly as the mistakes. As aside, you are the last person on god's green earth who should be asking the why do you care question. We are back to the irony again.
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Mar 10, 2023 22:57:37 GMT
It’s having a go about the scores. Or how someone scores. Why do you care? It's not having a go though is it. It's questioning someone. You've already accepted it's questioning someone so why are you now saying it's having a go. Why do I care? I'm entitled to ask why a keeper who makes maybe 1 mistake gets a much lower rating than someone who's misses could have been just as costly as the mistakes. As aside, you are the last person on god's green earth who should be asking the why do you care question. We are back to the irony again. There’s no irony. I don’t give a fuck about arbitrary marks made by people on the internet 😂😂
|
|
|
Post by lordb on Mar 10, 2023 22:59:12 GMT
Bonham - 5.5 should have saved the second Hoever - 9 Tuanzebe - 8 Fox 7.5 Sterling - 9 bonus point for playing so well out of position as left back Pearson -9 MOTM. As soon as he is off we concede 2!! Laurent - 8.5 Smallbone - another great game. Shame he couldn’t finish one of his two good chances 8 Campbell - good play, tidy finish 8 Gayle - played fairly well. Good cross for the first goal 7.5 Brown - Unfortunately wasn’t his day - 5.5 Subs Clucas 4 Tymon 5 Thompson 5 Baker 5 All of the subs weakened us and were a bit too early. So Bonham is criticised and gets a 5.5 Smallbone who misses 2 absolute sitters gets an 8? He had a really good game but yes he should have scored both
|
|
|
Post by willieeetmiout on Mar 10, 2023 23:00:06 GMT
It's not having a go though is it. It's questioning someone. You've already accepted it's questioning someone so why are you now saying it's having a go. Why do I care? I'm entitled to ask why a keeper who makes maybe 1 mistake gets a much lower rating than someone who's misses could have been just as costly as the mistakes. As aside, you are the last person on god's green earth who should be asking the why do you care question. We are back to the irony again. There’s no irony. I don’t give a fuck about arbitrary marks made by people on the internet 😂😂 Yes we have already established this. You give massive fucks about arbitrary comments made by people on the internet. But numbers. Oh no. No chance. BayernNFG
|
|
|
Post by numpty40 on Mar 10, 2023 23:00:39 GMT
Bonham is getting a bit of unfair criticism, yes the second he could have done better with but it wasn't exactly a dribbler through his legs. We subbed the heart of our team and the replacements are just not good enough and that is the reason we were hanging on at the end.
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Mar 10, 2023 23:01:32 GMT
There’s no irony. I don’t give a fuck about arbitrary marks made by people on the internet 😂😂 Yes we have already established this. You give massive fucks about arbitrary comments made by people on the internet. But numbers. Oh no. No chance. BayernNFG Do I? I tend to reply to people who can’t handle what I write tbh. Nevermind 😂
|
|
|
Post by wakeypotter on Mar 10, 2023 23:05:00 GMT
Sometimes I just love this forum 😃
|
|
|
Post by willieeetmiout on Mar 10, 2023 23:05:34 GMT
Yes we have already established this. You give massive fucks about arbitrary comments made by people on the internet. But numbers. Oh no. No chance. BayernNFG Do I? I tend to reply to people who can’t handle what I write tbh. Nevermind 😂 135,000 posts suggests you absolutely do
|
|
|
Post by bayernoatcake on Mar 10, 2023 23:08:21 GMT
Do I? I tend to reply to people who can’t handle what I write tbh. Nevermind 😂 135,000 posts suggests you absolutely do I enjoy chatting about a club I love and I love arguing. Like really love to argue
|
|
|
Post by Bojan Mackey on Mar 10, 2023 23:09:51 GMT
Bonham 4 - He’s fucking useless I’m sorry
Hoever 8 - Would have been 9 but loses a mark for not jumping with Brereton-Diaz, can clearly tell he’s got quality though, that finish for the first was outrageous.
Fox 7 - Didn’t seem to do too much wrong from what I saw, it’s clear he doesn’t trust Bonham though.
Tuanzebe - 7, Very solid game and looks to be coming into fitness, he’s a monster.
Sterling - 8, One of the best full-backs we’ve had in some time.
Pearson - 10, I fucking love this bloke, he’s literally everything we hoped he would be
Smallbone - 7, Very good showing again but should have buried his two chances
Laurent 9 - Bloke is absolute mustard, he’s well up for it as well
Brown 6 - A clear area where we need to upgrade but pressed well.
Gayle 6.5 - Quality ball in for the first and some good passes but seemed to fade
Campbell - 8, When he’s in this mood he’s one of the best in the division.
Subs:
Clucas: 3 Thompson 3 Tymon 3
All three were shite when they came on.
N/A for Baker as he wasn’t on long enough.
|
|
|
Post by willieeetmiout on Mar 10, 2023 23:10:03 GMT
135,000 posts suggests you absolutely do I enjoy chatting about a club I love and I love arguing. Like really love to argue Unless it numbers. NFG about numbers
|
|
|
Post by kjpt140v on Mar 10, 2023 23:24:56 GMT
Bonham - 6 Hoever - 8 Tuanzebe - 7 Fox 7 Sterling - 8 Pearson -8 Laurent - 8 Smallbone - 8 Campbell - 8 Gayle - 8 Brown - 8
Subs Clucas 6 Tymon 6 Thompson 5 Baker 6
Referee 6
|
|
|
Post by thehartshillbadger on Mar 10, 2023 23:27:07 GMT
All these scores are just arbitrary scores and a matter of opinion. I do t know why folk get so worked up about them. A couple of mine were generous but that’s what happens when you see a performance like that without any hindsite. It was the best we’ve played home or away for the last couple of years. Enjoy it all and don’t get all pissy with each other.
|
|
|
Post by dwr17477 on Mar 11, 2023 6:07:51 GMT
Got bored with the petty squabbling above. Anyway, here are my scores, arbitrarily:
Bonham - 5.5 he could send what is beginning to look like a solid defence into panic. Poor for both goals and feel he's liable to one massive mistake in each half.
We really need a couple of keepers in the Summer.
Hoever - 8.5 - got sucked in for their first goal but he scored two great goals. Tuanzebe - 8 - like this guy, seems so accomplished. Fox - 7.5 overall good cover and a couple of decent passes. Sterling - 8 - bit silly with the yellow card but another confident display.
Shame three quarters of this defence are on loan. Best full backs we've has since being relegated and would love to sign them.
Pearson - 9.5 - reads the game so well and has had a massive bearing on the improved performances. Laurent - 9 - been immense since January. The run and ball for the third goal was brilliant. Smallbone - 8.5 - loses half a mark for missing two glorious chances but he's come into his own recently.
This is the midfield we need for next season and need to try and make it happen.
Campbell - 8 - is benefitting from those around him and seems to be enjoying it Gayle - 7.5 - lovely throughball to Brown(I think) in the first half plus great cross for the opener. Brown - 6 - never stops running.
There's goals in this front line but it does need bolstering.
Subs:
Clucas 4 Tymon 5 Thompson 3 - forgot he was on. Baker 6
Unfortunately, the Clucas, Thompson and Tymon changes take us back to the insipid bad old days and shows who we may have to turn to once the loanees have gone. Let's hope the rebuild means this isn't the case.
|
|
|
Post by idle on Mar 11, 2023 6:26:12 GMT
Bonham 5 - Didn't make a save before the goals, lost the ball on an interception.
Hoever 8 - has the same amount of goals as Gayle now, should have done better on their first goal Tuanzebe 8 - massive Fox 7 - very good until their second goal Sterling 8 - rock solid today
Pearson 9 MOTM - the midfield is shit without him. Our absolute marshall! Laurent 8 - the midfield is shit without him. What a raid for the third! Smallbone 8 - played very well, but missed the two xG=1's he had
Campbell 8 - he's is form, and a joy to watch. I'm fearful we get a bid for him in the summer if he keeps this up. Nice goal Gayle 6 - nice link-up for our first goal, works a lot but I expect more Brown 7 - ran at them all night, and they had a handful keeping him quiet
Clucas 4 - really don't understand why he's our new right winger Tymon 6 - ran a lot, didn't do anything Thompson 3 - the midfield completely folded when he came on Baker 5 - made our already open midfield even worse
|
|
|
Post by robwahlmann on Mar 11, 2023 7:32:03 GMT
Bonham - 6, did OK. Hoever - 8, think he was caught ball watching for their first, apart from that excellent! Tuanzebe - 7, looked good until we made all the substitutions and changed formation, but a bit shaky after that. Fox 7, steady Eddy again! Sterling - 8, very good one on one! Pearson -9, he was absolutely everywhere! Really impressed by Pearson! MOM Laurent - 8.5, has been really good lately! Smallbone - 7, a good performance again, but really should have scored at least one! Campbell - 8, confidence is growing! Gayle - 6, works hard, but he really isn't the answer. Brown - 7, lacks a bit of quality, but his pressing is verry good.
Subs Clucas 5, not too much time on the pitch which is good! Tymon 5, again showed he isn't a very good defender. That cross for their first would never have come in if Sterling had been in the same situation! Thompson 5, couldn't really replace Pearson's ability to be everywhere. Baker 5, will he be here next season?
|
|
|
Post by iamstokie on Mar 11, 2023 8:29:21 GMT
Grow up!? Do one, are you Bonhams Dad? No mate. I'm just not an idiot You’re certainly making yourself look one tbh
|
|
|
Post by Robo10 on Mar 11, 2023 11:27:39 GMT
Bonham - 4 - no saves to make until the end but went down like a geriatric robot for their second
Hoever 8 - was good! First was a stunning finish Tuanzebe 8 - very steady and commanding Fox 7 - decent, still appalling on the ball but defends well Sterling 8 - a revelation at LB, so much better than shoehorning Tymon in, and offers more going forward
Pearson 9 - ace Laurent 9 - ace Smallbone 8 - more if he took 1 of 2 easy chances!
Brown 6 - his lack of ball control or passing ability is an issue Gayle 7 - looks a lot more like the Gayle of old, good cross for the first, good movement Campbell 9 - had a great game, looked proper up for it
Baker, Thompson, Tymon - 5 - none were great when they came on
AN - 8 - good win, heart in mouth at the end
Ref - 6 - was fairly poor for both teams, our pen was nailed on, theirs....feck me.. Gayle saved it!
|
|
|
Post by Staffsoatcake on Mar 11, 2023 11:34:05 GMT
Bonham 4. Brown 4 Laurent 9. Clucas 2. The rest of the starting 11, 8
|
|
|
Post by CBUFAWKIPWH on Mar 11, 2023 11:45:20 GMT
We are starting to play like a team so the team gets an 8.
I think Neil made a mistake with the substitutions (which he seemed to admit in the post match interview) - too many and in too many key positions, completely disrupted our dominance of the game.
|
|
|
Post by AlbertTatlock on Mar 11, 2023 14:30:43 GMT
Bonham - 5 Hoever 8 Tuanzebe 8 Fox 8 Sterling 8 Pearson 9 Laurent 9 Smallbone 7 Brown 6 Gayle 8 Campbell 9 Subs Clucas 4 Thompson 5 Tymon 4 Gouranga.
|
|
|
Post by cvillestokie on Mar 11, 2023 14:42:20 GMT
I don’t think any of the starting 11 deserve worse than a 6. The game changed when AN subbed the heart of the team.
Bonham - 6 Hoever - 7.5 (scored two, at fault for their first, questionably in the wrong for their second) Tuanzebe - 6.5 (did okay, didn’t have much to do) Fox - 6 (lost a mark because of the second. However, he went up against a real aerial threat and lost out). Sterling - 7.5 (felt his link up with Campbell was excellent) Pearson - 9 (ran the show) Laurent - 8.5 (dominant) Smallbone - 8 (great game but missed two great chances) Brown - 6 (good in the press, poor in possession) Gayle - 7 (linked up play nicely) Campbell - 8.5 (tore their rb a new one all game).
|
|