Player ratings vs. Ipswich!

[mrrine]

Aug 12, 2023 18:45:27 GMT robwahlmann said:

Aug 12, 2023 18:28:58 GMT numpty40 said:

He had a poor game as did at least 8 of his team mates.
I don't think he looked uninterested, things weren't happening for him and he was frustrated.
I just think much of the criticism is very unfair considering we're only 2 games into the season.

For me only Wesley of our lot came out of this in a decent way. The rest was from shit to really shit, and Mmaee was one of the worst if not the worst. This is the simple truth and nothing else. If you can't face the truth, well, .......

Absolutely agree,

Wilmot did *not* defend well. He defended in a better manner than Rose, which is a pretty low bar...

Everyone else is getting 4's. Totally sub-standard, a lot of that has to do with preparation and the starting 11 AND individual effort/performances as a secondary. 

[robwahlmann]

Aug 12, 2023 18:52:38 GMT westlandstokie said:

Aug 12, 2023 16:14:04 GMT robwahlmann said:

Travers 5, had some good saves, but parries everything back into the box.

Stevens 4, struggled the whole game.
Wilmot 4, would have got a 5 without his mistake for the second goal where he left his man unmarked.
Rose 4, looked slow and a bit uncomfortable on the ball too.
Hoever 4, possible his worst game for us.

Pearson 4, didn't look his usual self this afternoon.
Laurent 3, desperately poor.
Johnson 4, nothing really clicked today.

Mmaee 2, this was as poor as it possibly can get!
Vidigal 5, hardly got the ball in good positions the whole game.
Chiqinho 4, was sacrificed for Wesley.

Wesley 6, the only player in red and white today showing skills and some class.
Sidibe, not on long enough to make an impact.
Gayle, same as Sidibe.


Really hope to see McNally and Wesley from the start next game!

Your 4 for Wilmot seems a bit harsh…I listened to the match on the radio and it sounded like it was Wilmot versus Ipswich on his own…and judging by the other posts on here they think the same…opinions eh.

Must take the blame for their second, if not he'd get a point more for me in a shaky defence.

[robwahlmann]

Aug 12, 2023 19:06:53 GMT eriksson74 said:

Aug 12, 2023 18:10:38 GMT robwahlmann said:

At least you can show some effort! Today he looked totally uninterested, simply not good enough in my opinion. He might be talented, but so far he has impressed nobody.

To be honest that's bull shit, he looks like he expects more time which is understandable and is adjusting. From what I've seen admittedly in patches he will be an asset for us for sure

He might, but today he was shit. If you couldn't see that, well, you're entitled to your opinion, but really!?

[stokieinlondon]

Aug 12, 2023 18:17:44 GMT pushon said:

Aug 12, 2023 18:07:14 GMT stokieinlondon said:

People need to get off Ryan’s back - he’s in a new team, in a new country, he arrived here days before being put into the team and now he’s getting pelters for not being amazing from the off.

Maybe his family isn’t here yet. Maybe he’s trying to settle in. Maybe he’s feeling a bit out of it with such a massive change to his circumstances.

It’s been 2 games.

Maybe he shouldn't have been on the pitch then.

Maybe he shouldn’t - but either way it’s no reason to abuse him. What happened to giving people a chance?!

[thehartshillbadger]

Travers - Some good saves, poor for the first and dodgy kicking 5
Hoever - Got worse as the game wore on and appeared to be gassing 5
Rose - Fairly steady but it’s time for McNally 5
Wilmot - Guilty of some sloppy passing but stuck to the task 6
Stevens - He’s knocking on and it showed 5
Pearson - Given the run around 4
Laurent - Fucking shit 3
Johnson - Not much came off, bad day 5
Chiquinho - Sacrificed and rightly so 4
Mmaee - You can only hope he’ll get better 3
Vidigal - Best player going forward but faded 6
Wesley - Held it up well, kept possession 7