|
Post by Stretfordpotterer on Nov 11, 2018 12:28:41 GMT
Instinct at the time said clear red card. Seeing it again, I feel he goes the wrong way round the keeper, takes a heavy touch in doing so, the defender is getting the ball, he sees that and goes down when he’s successfully hurdled the challenge. He just pulls his feet up way to late for it to have been induced by any contact with the keeper. Poor forward play for me. Really poor. Prob still a foul but not a red as he’d played the ball straight to the covering defender. what a pile of steaming horseshit. you must have an agenda the gk clearly brings down afobe outside the box their is no defender between him and goal the defender you mean is the one who runs past afobe when he is on the ground. red card all day long Can you expand on what agenda I would be advancing? How often to you see a striker cut inside in that situation? Never. Why? Because you bring the ball back into where defenders might be getting back. He still might get there if he stays on his feet but I think the defender who runs in and takes the ball is getting there. On top of that the fall looks so contrived it can’t have done him any favours. When you’re falling naturally bits of your body that might break your fall, ie your legs, do not suddenly thrust into the air half way through the fall. It might well be a foul, it might be a red. But this having been the only replay i’ve seen i’m not convinced.
|
|
|
Post by march4 on Nov 11, 2018 12:38:55 GMT
What the fuck kind of header was that from Berahino? A typical one.
|
|
|
Post by Widget123 on Nov 11, 2018 13:00:56 GMT
what a pile of steaming horseshit. you must have an agenda the gk clearly brings down afobe outside the box their is no defender between him and goal the defender you mean is the one who runs past afobe when he is on the ground. red card all day long Can you expand on what agenda I would be advancing? How often to you see a striker cut inside in that situation? Never. Why? Because you bring the ball back into where defenders might be getting back. He still might get there if he stays on his feet but I think the defender who runs in and takes the ball is getting there. On top of that the fall looks so contrived it can’t have done him any favours. When you’re falling naturally bits of your body that might break your fall, ie your legs, do not suddenly thrust into the air half way through the fall. It might well be a foul, it might be a red. But this having been the only replay i’ve seen i’m not convinced. The way I look at it the replay is immaterial. The goalie does that in 10 games with different refs and 9 out of 10 send him off. Ergo we were screwed.
|
|
|
Post by maninasuitcase on Nov 11, 2018 13:16:09 GMT
Did the crouch header at the end get headed onto the bar by the defender? It was hard to tell where I was standing.
|
|
|
Post by Malcolm Clarke on Nov 11, 2018 13:21:41 GMT
Instinct at the time said clear red card. Seeing it again, I feel he goes the wrong way round the keeper, takes a heavy touch in doing so, the defender is getting the ball, he sees that and goes down when he’s successfully hurdled the challenge. He just pulls his feet up way to late for it to have been induced by any contact with the keeper. Poor forward play for me. Really poor. Prob still a foul but not a red as he’d played the ball straight to the covering defender. Having just watched it back several times, and,trying to apply the criteria we use on FA commissions, I think it was a foul and a red card. My only qualification to that is that, unlike commissions, we only get it from one camera angle and we can't slow it down. But the keeper went in with his feet and Afobe nicked it past him. Difficult to be certain from this clip whether there was contact but it looks like there was. If there was, the defender was not near enough to cover and Afobe would have had a shot on an open goal, so a clear goalscoring opportunity. Incidentally, if it had been in the area and given as a foul, i.e penalty, it would not have been a red card under the new DOGSO rules because the keeper had a reasonable prospect of playing the ball. But outside the area it should be a red (IMHO).
|
|
|
Post by mrcoke on Nov 11, 2018 13:22:08 GMT
I liked the Edwards free kick.
A foot to the left and, had the keeper not been 100% alert, that could well have sneaked in the bottom left corner.
|
|
|
Post by jarhead on Nov 11, 2018 20:27:13 GMT
Instinct at the time said clear red card. Seeing it again, I feel he goes the wrong way round the keeper, takes a heavy touch in doing so, the defender is getting the ball, he sees that and goes down when he’s successfully hurdled the challenge. He just pulls his feet up way to late for it to have been induced by any contact with the keeper. Poor forward play for me. Really poor. Prob still a foul but not a red as he’d played the ball straight to the covering defender. Agree with that. Totally agree. He shits out and EXPECTS a decision by the stupid jump and for me he has to go on the outside of the keeper ride the challenge and put it into a open goal and it’s end of story.
|
|
|
Post by liathroid on Nov 12, 2018 8:24:29 GMT
|
|
shimmer
Academy Starlet
Posts: 244
Location: Middle Earth
|
Post by shimmer on Nov 12, 2018 9:02:01 GMT
It really is a scandalous decision by the referee. Written all over his face wasn't it!
|
|